zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Wrenching
/
A BMW Dealer Tried Mechanically Totaling An M5, So The Owner Fixed It at Home For 90 Percent Less
A BMW Dealer Tried Mechanically Totaling An M5, So The Owner Fixed It at Home For 90 Percent Less-June 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:13:33

Alex goes over his ridiculous invoice.

When the BMW dealership gave Alex Palmeri a $17,000 estimate to fix his 409,000-mile E39 M5, the car was declared mechanically totaled. At that price, it would cost most of its value to repair. Palmeri wasn’t ready to give up, though.

Unsurprisingly, a lot of the work that the BMW dealership claimed was necessary really wasn’t. In one case, the dealership recommended replacing valve cover gaskets with only 2,000 miles on them. They also said it needed brake lights, despite the brake lights still working, and wanted him to replace some fluids that were also recently flushed and replaced.

But still, the M5 needed a lot of work. Despite not having any experience working on BMWs (though and clearly has a great garage setup) Palmeri jumped in and took care of every necessary repair.

He documents every repair and how much it costs compared to what BMW would charge. The video, on his channel , is really worth checking out:

He left a few things off, like replacing the catalytic converters and an airbag light, but with only 5 hours of work he finished most of the $17,000 repair using only $675 worth of parts.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Wrenching
Elvis Presley Shot This Cadillac And It Can Be Yours For $230,000
Elvis Presley Shot This Cadillac And It Can Be Yours For $230,000
The King of Rock and Roll had a thing for Cadillacs. Presley purchased this 1968 Topaz Gold Firemist Eldorado in December of '67 and made it is his daily driver for many years. When the car didn't work properly, Presley did what any rock star would do...he shot it. This...
Jun 23, 2026
The Greatest Ford Taurus Ever Made Is Ridiculously Cheap
The Greatest Ford Taurus Ever Made Is Ridiculously Cheap
The 1989 Ford Taurus, was anything but fun. However, the engineers at Ford made a version that didn't include such a tragic drivetrain, and instead installed a 220 HP Yamaha V6 and gearbox that was - get this - manual. This was the purest driving Taurus ever - . ,...
Jun 23, 2026
I Bought A Cadillac ELR And It Was Cheaper Than You Think
I Bought A Cadillac ELR And It Was Cheaper Than You Think
Most people think of the Cadillac ELR as nothing more than a fancy Chevy Volt, but it's actually a pretty decent car. The problem was it was too expensive and most buyers opted for the Model S. and Opponaut The World of Vee picked one up. No one is going...
Jun 23, 2026
Golfer Who Accused Dealer Of Bait And Switch Gets Kia K900
Golfer Who Accused Dealer Of Bait And Switch Gets Kia K900
Remember the and thought he scored a $60,000 Kia K900, but actually just won $25,000 in sneaky bait and switch? The dealership is going to give him a brand new K900 after facing media pressure. Woo, media pressure! Folsom Lake Kia had parked a K900 on the course making it...
Jun 23, 2026
How To Make The Honda Accord V6 All Kinds Of Awesome
How To Make The Honda Accord V6 All Kinds Of Awesome
Welcome to Fatal Flaw, where I choose a cool car that is made significantly less desirable by one major, glaring fault — and show you how to fix it. Today's feature is on the 6th generation Honda Accord V6 and how to fix the ticking time bomb known as its...
Jun 23, 2026
Sunday Drive: 1971 Volkswagen Karmann Ghia
Sunday Drive: 1971 Volkswagen Karmann Ghia
Many of us fantasize about a weekend car for cruising, canyon carving, or attacking our local race track. A car that throws practicality aside for pure driving enjoyment. Therefore, Car Buying has scoured the internet to find a ride for your perfect Today's selection comes from a time when cross-company...
Jun 23, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved