zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
A German Court Dismissed a Climate Lawsuit Against BMW
A German Court Dismissed a Climate Lawsuit Against BMW-June 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:11:59

Image for article titled A German Court Dismissed a Climate Lawsuit Against BMW

A court in Germany has sided with and rejected a brought against the automaker by climate activists. The Environmental Action Germany group, or (DUH) — as the group is known in Germany — hoped the lawsuit could convince the courts to tell to stop selling ICE-equipped cars by 2030, according to the .

The DUH argued that allowing BMW to continue selling combustion-powered cars poses a threat “to people’s right to property, health and life” given these cars’ greenhouse gas emissions. But a court in Munich threw the suit out on Tuesday, citing “no threat of illegal encroachment” upon anybody’s rights on the part of BMW. The court qualified its ruling by saying that there was no current threat, at least.

Image for article titled A German Court Dismissed a Climate Lawsuit Against BMW

That’s what makes the lawsuit being thrown out amusing: climate activists are more or less arguing that irreparable harm is being done, but it will take years to confirm. So until individuals or corporations are held accountable in advance, the courts are powerless to intervene. BMW was pleased with the ruling, saying that “efforts to cut emissions should be determined by democratically elected parliaments, not in the courts,” as the notes.

Of course, the suit being rejected is no surprise, since have already sided with other German automakers: DUH brought a similar suit earlier against . The activists were pushing for an end to M-B’s combustion-powered cars by 2030, but a court in Stuttgart threw out the lawsuit last year. This and previous dismissals have set a precedent that we are now seeing in effect.

The latest BWM ruling added that while the environmentalists’ argument was valid on its surface, the lawsuit didn’t hold up in court because lawmakers in Germany are allegedly working towards the goals set by the of 2015. Any measures enacted after the Paris accords are proof enough (in the eyes of the courts) that Germany is doing something to address greenhouse gas emissions.

The argument from the DUH is that Germany may be doing something, but it’s not doing enough, and that’s where the courts have washed their hands clean despite the “plaintiffs’ arguments couldn’t be dismissed from the outset.”

The environmentalists could still appeal the ruling, which is what they’ve done with the Mercedes-Benz lawsuit, and what they will probably do when the courts inevitably reject a similar lawsuit against German oil and gas major Wintershell Dea, scheduled to be heard in August. Indeed, it could be appeals all the way down.

Image for article titled A German Court Dismissed a Climate Lawsuit Against BMW

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Subaru Had It Right All Along
Subaru Had It Right All Along
When first came to the United States, it sold small funky cars that were decidedly un-American. As the company grew its own identity and became more established in the U.S., it became the first automaker to offer an all-wheel-drive passenger car in 1975. Subaru was also an early-adopter of...
Jun 21, 2025
Toyota Is Moving A Prewar 700-Ton Press Machine Halfway Around The World
Toyota Is Moving A Prewar 700-Ton Press Machine Halfway Around The World
closed its São Bernardo Plant in November 2023, marking the end of its first overseas production facility. The closure caps off a period of continuous car production in São Paolo, , lasting over 60 years. The plant was home to a Komatsu 700-ton press that predates itself. And now...
Jun 21, 2025
I Entered My Lifted Miata In A Real Off-Road Race, Here's What Happened
I Entered My Lifted Miata In A Real Off-Road Race, Here's What Happened
I have two automotive loves: The first is the Miata, the second is off-road racing. For a while I raced air-cooled Volkswagens in the deserts of California and Nevada and I was lucky enough to co-drive in a class 11 stock bug in the Baja 1000 a few years...
Jun 21, 2025
I Can't Get Enough Of This YouTuber Who Builds Tiny, Fully Functional Scale-Model Cars
I Can't Get Enough Of This YouTuber Who Builds Tiny, Fully Functional Scale-Model Cars
I love tiny, of . I have a that is roughly half the size of a normal cat, and she’s perfect. I own a 2013 , which is like the miniature version of a normal-sized vehicle (at least here in Texas) — but beyond that, I also own a Hot...
Jun 21, 2025
2024 Kia EV9: What Do You Want To Know?
2024 Kia EV9: What Do You Want To Know?
At long last, we are about to get behind the wheel of for the first time. Sure, , and sure, , and sure , but hey — what can you do? Anyway, before we get behind the wheel of this three-row electric beast, we want to know what you...
Jun 21, 2025
Watch ABS Fail When MotorWeek Tests A 1997 Chevy S-10
Watch ABS Fail When MotorWeek Tests A 1997 Chevy S-10
MotorWeek’s is some of the on the internet. The long-running automotive news magazine has a treasure trove of tests after being on the air for over 40 years. Where else can you find detailed instrumented testing of long-forgotten cars like the or a ? MotorWeek’s recent Retro Review upload is...
Jun 21, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved