zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
A Tesla That The Driver Says Was On Autopilot Crashed Into A Stopped Police Car, Again
A Tesla That The Driver Says Was On Autopilot Crashed Into A Stopped Police Car, Again-July 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:27

Image for article titled A Tesla That The Driver Says Was On Autopilot Crashed Into A Stopped Police Car, Again

Recently, we reported about ed into emergency vehicles, like or . It appears that another such crash may have happened this . Thankfully, nobody was injured, but this does seem to reinforce the idea that Autopilot has a problem with authority.

A statement from the Florida Highway Patrol (FHP) reported that a FHP officer had stopped to assist a driver with a disabled 2012 Mercedes-Benz GLK 350 on the shoulder of I-4 around Orlando.

The 2019 Tesla Model 3, which the driver claims was in Autopilot mode, struck and sideswiped the cop car, then struck the stricken Mercedes as well, perhaps just to be really thorough and certain that everyone’s day would be ruined.

There’s an investigation currently taking place to actually confirm the reports about the status of Autopilot and what role it had in the crash; it’s certainly not impossible that this information could prove to be wrong, but, then again, this sort of incident is one that’s been seen with Autopilot before,

Image for article titled A Tesla That The Driver Says Was On Autopilot Crashed Into A Stopped Police Car, Again

I’ve made my stance on Autopilot, and, really, driving systems quite clear: they suck, not necessarily for technical reasons, but for conceptual ones that have to do with how human beings—the primary target market of Teslas and many other new cars—interact with them.

Humans are pretty good at avoiding emergency vehicles parked on the side of the highway. Autopilot seems to be quite bad at it. If Autopilot was being used properly in this instance, the human driver would have seen that the car was deciding to drive smack into the police car, and taken over.

But the problem is that when a system is doing nearly all of the actual driving—like Autopilot can often do in highway situations and how the system is generally demonstrated to be doing—humans are terrible about keeping attention focused on monitoring the system.

It’s the human’s fault, sure, but it’s also the result of a bad system that doesn’t take into account how human beings actually work. It’s technically, it was fine, but the design didn’t take into account how human hands were actually shaped, and as a result, it was a disaster.

Those mice didn’t crash into cop cars along the side of the road, it’s worth mentioning, too. Autopilot and other L2 systems are making the same basic mistake by ignoring how humans actually work.

I’m curious to see the results of this investigation, and if video from the car can be pulled. If it does show Autopilot was in control, I’d hope that would spur Tesla to really focus on improving the ability to avoid parked cars on the sides of roads in an update to the system as soon as possible.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
This is How Daimler and Bosch's Automated Valet Parking Works
This is How Daimler and Bosch's Automated Valet Parking Works
There are very few things worse than handing over your keys to a stranger and praying they take care of your car and don’t stuff it into a wall or, y’know, . The struggle of valet parking is something I’m sure we all have to deal with on a very...
Jul 16, 2025
Detroit Should Not Give Ford a $104 Million Tax Break
Detroit Should Not Give Ford a $104 Million Tax Break
Ford, as expected, launched a charm initiative this week to win over the Detroit City Council and secure a $100 million tax break from the city to support its rehab of a train station near downtown. The facility, Michigan Central Station, has been shuttered for decades, and Ford wants to...
Jul 16, 2025
How Honda's VTEC Engines Work and How VTEC Can Kick In, Yo
How Honda's VTEC Engines Work and How VTEC Can Kick In, Yo
Honda’s Variable Valve Timing & Lift Electronic Control system, known as VTEC instead of the more accurate VVTLEC, is one of those things that various parts of , and as a result, almost everyone with even a passing interest in cars is aware of VTEC and its propensity to kick...
Jul 16, 2025
Cadillac is Putting Its Diesel Program on Hold Because the Future Looks Electric (Updated)
Cadillac is Putting Its Diesel Program on Hold Because the Future Looks Electric (Updated)
There was a period in the recent past where it looked like the future might be powered by diesel engines. With a generally greater fuel efficiency than your standard gasoline engine, the automotive industry today could have been massively different. Then, happened and manufacturers got a little hesitant being associated...
Jul 16, 2025
Tesla Autopilot Not Working After Latest Over-the-Air Update, Owners Say
Tesla Autopilot Not Working After Latest Over-the-Air Update, Owners Say
A hiccup in Tesla’s latest over-the-air update caused several owners to lose all functionality of their vehicle’s semi-autonomous driver aid system. Tesla told one driver it’s a “known issue” internally and a fix is expected by Friday. Tesla’s cutting-edge ability to send fixes remotely to vehicles has earned the company...
Jul 16, 2025
Tesla's Now On Trial Over an Elon Musk Tweet
Tesla's Now On Trial Over an Elon Musk Tweet
Tesla heads back to court later this month to continue a trial over allegations from the National Labor Relations Board that the automaker’s management violated federal labor laws. When both sides meet in court, they’ll duke it out over a new, potentially thorny legal issue that emerged in late August:...
Jul 16, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved