zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
Another Study Shows Just How Careless Driver Assist Tech Is Making Us
Another Study Shows Just How Careless Driver Assist Tech Is Making Us-June 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:33

A safety driver sits behind the wheel of a self-driving taxi in South Korea.

The closer cars get to driving themselves, the we’ll become behind the wheel. It’s hardly a surprising thought, but it’s been supported once again by a new study from the and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s AgeLab.

For this experiment, 20 Massachusetts drivers were given one of two cars with differing assisted-driving technologies to use for a month. Ten were provided with a Range Rover Evoque equipped with adaptive cruise control, while the other 10 were supplied with a Volvo S90 outfitted not only with adaptive criuse control but also Volvo’s Pilot Assist system. Pilot Assist allows the car to steer itself within its lane as well as to adjust the vehicle speed for a safe following distance, making the S90 a Level 2 autonomous vehicle. The Range Rover, conversely, is classified as Level 1.

It probably won’t surprise you to learn that after the month was over, all participants were more likely to exhibit habits of “disengagement” compared with their driving of a vehicle without assistance technology. Disengagement is what the IIHS calls behaviors like removing both hands from the wheel or diverting attention from the road to use cellphones and adjust vehicle controls. The more alarming bit is how bad it got for the Volvo group, as IIHS senior research scientist Ian Reagan explains (important parts bolded by yours truly):

“Drivers were to show signs of disengagement after a month of using [Volvo’s] Pilot Assist compared with the beginning of the study,” Reagan says. “Compared with driving manually, they were to take both hands off the wheel after they’d gotten used to how the lane centering worked.”

This is an inevitability. The road to full autonomy is very long, and until carmakers get to the end of it we’re going to keep seeing progressively more capable technologies that automate certain aspects of driving but never the whole act. Of course, drivers must always be at the ready to assume control in case human intervention is suddenly needed. But that’s fundamentally at odds with the reasons people want self-driving cars in the first place, which is to do everything but drive.

Communication between assisted driving systems and drivers could also use some improvement. A few months ago, I drove a Hyundai Sonata Hybrid equipped with the Highway Driving Assist feature. I took my hands off the wheel on a few occasions to determine how long the car would do its thing before demanding my full attention. Sometimes it’d take 10 seconds; other times, more than half a minute. I was never able to determine the reason for the inconsistency.

However, there may be a silver lining here. Remember the group driving the Range Rover Evoque that had only adaptive cruise control? Turns out that while those subjects did pick up some ill-advised habits, the particular behaviors weren’t as careless, and those drivers were no more likely to stop holding the wheel at the end of the month:

Drivers of the Evoque, who used ACC often, were more likely to look at or pick up a cell phone while using the assistance technology than when driving manually, and that tendency increased substantially as they grew familiar with ACC. On the other hand, increased familiarity did not result in more frequent texting or other kinds of cell phone manipulation known to increase crash risk (see “,” Dec. 10, 2015). Unlike drivers using Pilot Assist, drivers using ACC in both the Evoque and the S90 weren’t any more likely to remove both hands from the wheel than when driving manually.

Perhaps there’s a sweet spot — a “just right” degree of assisted driving tech that makes road travel safer but still requires enough engagement that drivers can’t ever completely nod off. It’s a nice thought, but the way modern cars are marketed, and the expectations buyers have of them, suggests that this problem is going to keep getting worse before it gets better.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Tesla Is Here To Stay
Tesla Is Here To Stay
Tesla is doing just fine, Volkswagen isn’t, and Waymo. All that and more in for January 21, 2021. I’ve , but Tesla has long been a Rorschach test. Many people will look at the company and CEO Elon Musk’s antics and declare it to be a massive fraud. Many...
Jun 27, 2026
The Dodge Durango SRT Hellcat Is Nearly Sold Out
The Dodge Durango SRT Hellcat Is Nearly Sold Out
The team at SRT isn’t afraid to put the famous 6.2-liter Supercharged V8 engine into different Stellantis products. One of the latest vehicles to get the beast of an engine is the . Sadly, if you want one of the 2021 Dodge Durango SRT Hellcats, you may to have...
Jun 27, 2026
Leaked Ford Memo Threatens Loose-Lipped Suppliers With Repercussions Over New Truck Photos
Leaked Ford Memo Threatens Loose-Lipped Suppliers With Repercussions Over New Truck Photos
A memo that’s reportedly an internal Ford document obtained by says that the automaker is threatening “business repercussions” and “recovery actions” against suppliers who are found responsible for leaked Ford photos or information. Ford called out Tier 1 suppliers specifically but stopped short of naming a particular supplier or...
Jun 27, 2026
Ford Will Recall Another 3 Million Cars With Takata Airbags After NHTSA Appeal Fails
Ford Will Recall Another 3 Million Cars With Takata Airbags After NHTSA Appeal Fails
Much like General Motors, Ford has for years been fighting the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s order to recall several million cars carrying potentially defective Takata airbag inflators. And, the Blue Oval’s appeals have been unsuccessful, as reported Tuesday that Ford must repair the affected cars after all. The...
Jun 27, 2026
Blip: In The Bag? Oh, Nothing Important
Blip: In The Bag? Oh, Nothing Important
“Hello, friends! Thanks for stopping! Say, are you fellows and ladies headed by that book depository? Could you drop me by that grassy knoll nearby? No reason. In the bag? Uh, just, um, a baguette. Why?” ...
Jun 27, 2026
What's A Good Car For Smuggling?
What's A Good Car For Smuggling?
Using a car for smuggling goods is a concept almost as old as the car itself. Here in America, the NASCAR series has its roots in bootleggers running from the police with their illicit products. Bootleggers drove small street vehicles that were souped up to outrun the cops. That...
Jun 27, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved