zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
As One Pipeline Struggles To Reopen, Another Defies Order To Shutdown
As One Pipeline Struggles To Reopen, Another Defies Order To Shutdown-May 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:20

 A sign is posted on a bridge to indicate water contamination after an oil spill of approximately 800,000 gallons of crude in the Kalamazoo River July 28, 2010 in Marshall, Michigan. A 30 inch-wide underground pipeline owned by Calgary, Alberta-based Enbridge Energy Partners LP, began leaking on June 26.

Enbridge Energy, the Canadian company that , is also battling Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer over the aging Line 5, which runs right under the Straights of Mackinac between Lake Huron and Lake Michigan.

Enbridge Mainline System operates one of the largest pipeline systems in the world with 3,000 miles of pipeline corridors in the United States and Canada. The company doesn’t have a good reputation in the state of Michigan or, really, anywhere else. Ten years ago, a pipeline run by the company into the Kalamazoo River. The cleanup took years and polluted waterways from Western Michigan to Illinois.

Such a spill from Line 5 would be devastating for the Great Lakes region, potentially poisoning huge swaths of the largest fresh water system on the planet. Whitmer revoked the easement that allows Pipeline 5 to rest on the bottom of the Great Lakes and gave Enbridge 180 days to shut down the line. The deadline is Wednesday, but it looks like the company is going to refuse to comply,

In the six months since Gov. Gretchen Whitmer gave Enbridge 180 days to stop transporting petroleum across the tempestuous waterway that links Lakes Michigan and Huron, and the four months since Enbridge vowed to defy her, state officials have been adamant that the order still stands.

But as for what Michigan can or will do if Enbridge keeps the oil flowing beyond midnight on Wednesday?That’s unclear.Spokespeople for the governor declined to answer questions about their plans, but supplied a written statement noting that Whitmer “stands behind her decision” to cancel the easement that first gave Enbridge’s predecessor permission to build a pipeline along the sandy bottom of the straits 68 years ago.

“We cannot risk the devastating economic, environmental, and public health impacts of a catastrophic oil spill in the Great Lakes,” the statement reads.

Enbridge says it won’t be shutting down Line 5 unless a judge or regulator orders them to do so, which is highly unlikely, Bridge reports. In fact, the company thinks it’s actually Michigan that is violating the law by demanding the shutdown, Ryan Duffy, a spokesperson for Enbridge told Bridge:

“Part of the easement agreement is that if there’s something that’s found that the state believes is an issue or a safety issue, they would let us know about it, and then we have a certain amount of time to fix it,” Duffy said.

By the time a safety issue is identified, it may be too late to prevent polluting waterways, as was the case with the 2010 Enbridge pipeline spill. Enbridge has one of the worst safety records in the industry, reports, with 1,068 spills that dumped 7.4 million gallons of oil between 1999 and 2013. And Enbridge hasn’t always been forth coming about its own spills. The company took a year to alert Wisconsin state regulators of a spill of 1,386 gallons of a diluted hazardous substance which polluted drinking water wells in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin, the reports.

Even Enbridge acknowledges the company would never be allowed to build a pipeline in such an environmentally delicate area today while, at the same time, insisting the nearly 70-year-old pipeline is safe. Environmentalists and native people, who hold fishing and hunting rights in the area, are demanding some consequences for Enbridge thumbing its nose at Whitmer’s order:

On Thursday, the 181st day since Whitmer’s Nov. 13 shutdown order, the groups say they’ll deliver “eviction notices” to the company’s offices in Mackinaw City and Lansing. It’s a purely symbolic gesture, said David Holtz, spokesperson for the anti-Line 5 coalition Oil & Water Don’t Mix.=

Holtz’ group was among those that pressured Whitmer for months to revoke the easement. Achieving that milestone only to watch Enbridge keep the oil flowing, Holtz said, would be a disappointment.

But “we are going to continue holding Enbridge accountable,” he said.

In interviews with Bridge Michigan and Michigan Radio, Holtz and other Line 5 opponents called upon state and federal regulators to step in.

“There has to be a consequence for ignoring the law,” Holtz said.

Pipeline 5 is a ticking time bomb, and who knows when, if ever, it will be defused. But for a company with little regard for natural resources, native people’s rights or even the health and safety of the communities it operates in, the crude must, and will, keep on flowing.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Taillight Trend Alert: The Technosquiggle
Taillight Trend Alert: The Technosquiggle
Last night I was at the Southeast’s fifth-most popular taillight-themed bar, The Scarlet Bulb, when things started to take a strange, almost ominous turn. “Something’s happening,” slurred the old, drunk guy next to me, a former, now disgraced, taillight designer for a major OEM. A woman approached and flung...
May 19, 2026
Meh Car Mehstery: The Suzuki Kizashi
Meh Car Mehstery: The Suzuki Kizashi
I know many of you seek out Meh Car Mondays (on whatever days) for reasons of comfort and security. The categorization of a particular car as “meh” can be the only bit of certainty in the lives of a shocking number of people, and I’m always privileged to provide...
May 19, 2026
Americans Are Back To Borrowing A Lot Of Money To Buy Cars
Americans Are Back To Borrowing A Lot Of Money To Buy Cars
Auto lending dropped sharply when the pandemic started but is now hitting record levels, it’s EV Day at Stellantis, and Tesla. All that and more in for July 8, 2021. Taking out a loan to buy a depreciating asset isn’t optimal, but many people don’t have a choice because...
May 19, 2026
Hemi Dodge Charger Pickup Kit Puts The Bed On The Ground Like Its Future Owner
Hemi Dodge Charger Pickup Kit Puts The Bed On The Ground Like Its Future Owner
U.S. enthusiasts have long yearned after the forbidden fruit of international utes, now suffering a drought of local comparable cars pairing the utility of a pickup bed with the footprint of a sedan left by the collapse of the El Camino and Subaru Baja markets long ago. Now, a...
May 19, 2026
There's A Fairytale Story Behind The 2004 Ford Shelby Cobra Concept
There's A Fairytale Story Behind The 2004 Ford Shelby Cobra Concept
Welcome to another installment of , a series at Jalopnik where we flip through the pages of history to explore long-forgotten concepts and how they had a hand in shaping the cars we know today. Last week we learned the one-off 2004 Ford Shelby Cobra concept will soon go...
May 19, 2026
Two Dead After C8 Corvette Carrying Three People Crashes Into Pool
Two Dead After C8 Corvette Carrying Three People Crashes Into Pool
On Wednesday, a convertible crashed through the backyard of a home and into a pool. The crash killed two of the vehicle’s occupants while a third is critically injured. NBC Los Angeles that the crash happened at around 2:18 in the morning in Chino, California. The vehicle, a C8...
May 19, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved