zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Wrenching
/
CarMax Is Exactly The Same As Any Other Used Car Dealership
CarMax Is Exactly The Same As Any Other Used Car Dealership-June 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:13:45

Back in June I that a number of consumer groups were pressuring the FTC to investigate CarMax for deceptive advertising. Yesterday an revealed that more than 1500 consumer complaints have been filed against the dealership group, but is it really a big deal?

The consumer group is making the case that CarMax is deceiving their customers by advertising a rigorous inspection of all their vehicles, yet cars are being sold with open recalls.

"It is inherently deceptive for an auto dealer to represent that its vehicles have passed a rigorous inspection, while failing to take even the most basic step of checking the vehicle's safety recall status"

It should be noted that only New York City has CarMax says they disclose any open recalls to potential customers and direct car-buyers to visit their local brand dealership where the recall will be fixed at no charge.

According to the report, when the consumer groups first petitioned the FTC, the commission did not disclose the number of complaints against CarMax. They have now revealed that since 2011, more than 1500 complaints have been filed, however the FTC did not say how many of those complaints were related to advertising practices.

So 1500 seems like a lot of complaints, but how does that figure compare with the rest of the industry. Luckily, friend of Jalopnik and statistics ninja, Juan Barnett put some really interesting data into the following graph-

I'm confident there are plenty of legitimate reasons why consumers filed complaints against CarMax, after all they are a used car dealership. But CarMax is not some outlier in regards to deceptive business practices anymore than most dealerships are.

(Photo Credit: Getty Images)

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Wrenching
This Weekend Is Going To Be A Wrenchathon Of Epic Proportions As I Fight To Get My Fleet Down To Five
This Weekend Is Going To Be A Wrenchathon Of Epic Proportions As I Fight To Get My Fleet Down To Five
Five. That’s the goal. And though to the layperson that may seem achievable, to me — someone currently in possession of 13 mostly broken cars — it seems impossible. But this weekend, I’m going to make a strong push towards freedom. I really am talking about freedom, here. I...
Jun 22, 2026
Man Spends Three Days Trying To Remove Oil Filter, Lives Every Wrencher's Nightmare
Man Spends Three Days Trying To Remove Oil Filter, Lives Every Wrencher's Nightmare
To say Tony Rotundo’s first oil change on his recently-acquired 1965 Plymouth Formula S was a disaster would be an understatement. The San Francisco-based wrestling photographer suffered for three days trying every trick in the book, turning a clean orange cylinder into a beat-up thin plate and his excitement...
Jun 22, 2026
Someone Agreed To Buy My Beautiful Jeep Cherokee But Under The Condition That I Go Through Wrenching Hell
Someone Agreed To Buy My Beautiful Jeep Cherokee But Under The Condition That I Go Through Wrenching Hell
There are some repair jobs so soul-suckingly awful that I can’t help but procrastinate on them. In my garage is a that I sold to someone under the condition that I swap the rear leaf springs. Why did I agree to this? Because I am a fool, that’s why....
Jun 22, 2026
No Stuck Part Will Stay In Your Way When You Have An Air Hammer
No Stuck Part Will Stay In Your Way When You Have An Air Hammer
A lot of automotive jobs become so much harder the moment a part won’t come off the way it’s supposed to. Our David Tracy detailed when a man spent three days trying to remove an oil filter. In the process, that wrencher used a tool we should all probably...
Jun 22, 2026
This Effortless Tool Gets Your Broken Project Car Out Of Your Way
This Effortless Tool Gets Your Broken Project Car Out Of Your Way
I’m going to be spending much of this winter doing a . Don’t worry, you haven’t missed anything; I just haven’t announced it yet. It’s going to be an exciting project because for the first time since becoming a motorcyclist I have a nice, warm area to work on...
Jun 22, 2026
This 1973 Dodge Challenger Was Rebuilt In A New York City Apartment Building
This 1973 Dodge Challenger Was Rebuilt In A New York City Apartment Building
New York City isn’t exactly known for empty streets, plentiful garages, or spacious abodes. It’s seen as a hellish place to be a car owner, let alone a car enthusiast — a place where working on your own car is about as feasible as finding a reasonably-priced takeout option...
Jun 22, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved