zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Wrenching
/
Does 'Best In Class' Really Make You Want To Buy A Car Or Truck?
Does 'Best In Class' Really Make You Want To Buy A Car Or Truck?-October 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:13:45

"Best In Class" has been a favorite phrase for car commercials and billboards forever, particularly in the pickup truck market. Now that are raging especially hard over who's "," it's time to settle the real debate: does anyone give a damn?

From where I'm standing, "Best In Class" claims are meaningless annoyances to cut through when you're trying to make an educated buying decision. My main grievances:

What class are we even talking about? "Classes" within pickup trucks alone are confusing to car-nerds, let alone the average consumer. (Check out our explainer if you want to know more)."Best In Class" ratings are often achieved using a very specific trim of a certain model; i.e. the 2015 Ram 3500's 30,000 pound capacity claim; which is only attainable with their rear-drive single-cab dually.How many people are actually running their vehicles to the ragged edge of performance? Whether it's towing capacities, top speed... I never see any of these being tested on public roads. Where people spend most of their time driving.Capacity ratings like towing and payload are made up by the manufacturers. If a competitor releases a better figure, all a company has to do is "re-certify" and boom; better capacity. It happens over and over again.

And yet, company representatives call me every day (no, really. Every day.) to remind me " their vehicle is best-in-class, and that I better stop telling people "best-in-class" is stupid because they've just spent tons of money earning the right to put that on their dealership posters and by the way, the other guy's truck is a steaming heap of duty with only, like, one cupholder."

What the hell do I know. It's time to turn this debate over to The People, do "best in class" claims matter to you? Do they affect your decision to buy a new vehicle? Drop a simple "yes or no" in the poll here and tell us why in the comments.

Image: Andrew P. Collins (graphics from Chrysler, Ford, Stuart Caie/

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Wrenching
Here's How Much It Really Costs To Own A 20-Year-Old BMW M3
Here's How Much It Really Costs To Own A 20-Year-Old BMW M3
Everyone dreams of buying that childhood dream car for cheap on Craigslist through the magical power of depreciation. But as we’ve seen time and time again, purchase price is only one small part of the equation. One of my favorite car-related video series this year has been fromCarThrottle, wherehost Alex...
Oct 29, 2025
Here's What The Inside Of A Neglected World War II Jeep Engine Looks Like
Here's What The Inside Of A Neglected World War II Jeep Engine Looks Like
I just yanked the engine out of my 1948 Willys CJ-2A; here’s a look at the innards of that old cast iron hulk called the “Go Devil” that powered America’s troops through World War II. The Go Devil engine is a 134-cubic inch, cast-iron flathead inline four found in World...
Oct 29, 2025
This Guy's Car Fetish Is So Normal It's Actually Pretty Weird
This Guy's Car Fetish Is So Normal It's Actually Pretty Weird
Like so many of us, Tyson Hugie dreamed of one day owning a very specific car collection. Classic 4x4s? European sports cars? Nah, man—early 90’s Acuras. It doesn’t sound too intrinsically exciting, but looking at this fleet. I think he might actually be on to something here. Hugie reached out...
Oct 29, 2025
Getting Drunk Could Save Your Life From Automotive Fluid Poisoning
Getting Drunk Could Save Your Life From Automotive Fluid Poisoning
If, for whatever reason, you just sucked down a quart of DOT 3 brake fluid, windshield washer fluid or antifreeze, get your butt to the hospital right away. But if you can’t get to the hospital quickly, it may be time to break out the booze. We’ve probably all heard...
Oct 29, 2025
These Mad Geniuses Are Doing A Car Build Show You Will Actually Want to Watch
These Mad Geniuses Are Doing A Car Build Show You Will Actually Want to Watch
Do ? Are they too heavy on drama without enough actual building for you? Do you find yourself more interested the actual fabrication than the fabricated drama between mechanics or cast members? Do you wonder how Richard Rawlings gets any work done with all those rings? Well, two Brits are...
Oct 29, 2025
Welcome To My Favorite Time-Wasting Car Website, ScuderiaCarParts.com
Welcome To My Favorite Time-Wasting Car Website, ScuderiaCarParts.com
Like you, I often harbor idle dreams of one day owning a Ferrari. For reasons obvious to anyone who has seen the state of my apartment, this is never going to happen. Still, I like to dream, and one website supports my fantasies: . The fun thing about ScuderiaCarParts.com is...
Oct 29, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved