zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
Ford Wants To Compete With Tesla, But Its Dealers Are Getting In The Way
Ford Wants To Compete With Tesla, But Its Dealers Are Getting In The Way-August 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:09:29

Image for article titled Ford Wants To Compete With Tesla, But Its Dealers Are Getting In The Way

Ford Motor Company is serious about offering more electric cars in its lineup. The and the upcoming are impressive products. However, the company’s approach to actually selling these products is leaving some customers frustrated and looking elsewhere. While short-term sales seem good right now, the long-term impact may not be.

The first issue is that on these EVs Ford has moved to what it calls “e-invoice” pricing; this means that the invoice price (or dealer cost) and MSRP are identical. Usually dealer invoice pricing is lower, allowing dealers to offer deals below MSRP, which just isn’t as clean or simple to a consumer, who may rather want to just pay what the car costs instead of worrying about getting the best deal. Whether Ford will admit it or not, with this “e-invoice” pricing, it seems to be taking a page from Tesla’s playbook where everyone pays the same price for a car. If you buy a Tesla, the price online is what you pay. No games, no dealer nonsense. Except, despite Ford’s “e-invoice” pricing, dealers can play games and markup cars well over the MSRP.

recently reported that Ford is implementing a program where dealers can “snitch” on each other if a dealer advertises the upcoming Lighting below MSRP. Advertising well over sticker price is perfectly okay, though; the “voluntary” program says a dealer can sell a car for whatever they decide, but it is only attempting to discourage advertisements that indicate any level of savings.

I have assisted with several Mach-E deals for various customers in different areas of the country, and though there are some vehicles for sale at MSRP, I’ve seen upwards of $10,000 over sticker. There are even dealers putting a markup of over $33,000 on these cars.

Image for article titled Ford Wants To Compete With Tesla, But Its Dealers Are Getting In The Way

Image for article titled Ford Wants To Compete With Tesla, But Its Dealers Are Getting In The Way

There is a lot of demand and not enough supply. When those factors come together, sellers can charge whatever they like. However, earlier in the summer Ford’s Manager of Communications Mike Levine sent out a tweet responding to a customer’s frustration regarding dealer markups.

Image for article titled Ford Wants To Compete With Tesla, But Its Dealers Are Getting In The Way

I was curious as to exactly how Mr. Levine, or Ford corporate for that matter, planned on enforcing any type of “policy” that would disincentivize dealers from selling these cars over MSRP. I reached out to him on a few occasions to get clarity on the matter but did not get a response. I did get a response from Emma Berg who is the director of Ford’s communications for EVs:

“If a customer isn’t happy with their dealer, our team can help them find a different dealer that’s a better match. Dealers are independent franchises and ultimately the final price a customer will pay for any vehicle is agreed between themselves and a dealer.”

I totally understand the franchise agreement and that dealers can sell for whatever they want. While I think it’s great that Mr. Levine was personally active in communicating with dealers on behalf of customers, it’s also not a great look for the brand when your PR representative has to be an intermediary between the customer and the retailer.

There are ways to limit these practices if an automaker was actually serious about it. While Ford cannot dictate what a dealer can sell a car for, it could perhaps tie future allocations for other in-demand cars based on how many vehicles a dealer sells at or below MSRP.

The other issue is that when it comes to leasing Ford’s EVs, lessees cannot take advantage of the tax credits as part of a cost reduction on the car. Several brands use the Federal EV tax credit as essentially an upfront discount on leases. For example, if you lease VW’s ID4, which like the Mach-E, has no margin between the invoice and MSRP, you get the $7,500 rebate which makes the VW lease much more competitive than a similarly priced Mach-E.

Right now demand is far outpacing supply, which creates a market where the sellers have the leverage, but that won’t always be the case. Tesla has been drawing customers not just due to a compelling product, but because people don’t want to buy cars with typical dealer hassles. If Ford, and other mainstream automakers want to compete in that space, offering electrified vehicles alone is not enough. Automakers are going to have to figure out a way to work with their dealerships so that the sales process isn’t sending EV clients to competitors.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
Autotrader Bot Writes a Kind of Poetic Ford Focus RS Ad
Autotrader Bot Writes a Kind of Poetic Ford Focus RS Ad
To us humans, the Most already know it’s one of the most powerful and enjoyable hot hatchbacks on the market. Apparently our future electronic overlords disagree, and now a bot for Autotrader has penned an overview of the RS for an Idaho dealership which is, honestly, kind of lyrical. A...
Aug 27, 2025
At $3,000, Is This 1990 Nissan Maxima SE 4DSC Totally 2G2BT?
At $3,000, Is This 1990 Nissan Maxima SE 4DSC Totally 2G2BT?
Today’s Maxima is a car once described by maker as a 4-door sports car, or ‘4DSC.’ Let’s see if the price tag on this rare manual-equipped edition’s has you LOL’ing. Breaking into the car market with an untested brand is a daunting task, just ask Elon Musk. Of course Musk...
Aug 27, 2025
2018 Hyundai Ioniq Is a Car to Get if You Love Money
2018 Hyundai Ioniq Is a Car to Get if You Love Money
“Not much to this thing,” I thought as I plopped into the 2018 Hyundai Ioniq’s firm driver’s seat and gripped its rock-hard plastic steering wheel. Then I found the price tag: just over $23,000. Then I found the fuel range: just over... holy crap, 600 miles? As far as new...
Aug 27, 2025
My Mom Is 79 and Wants a Cool Ride! What Car Should She Buy?
My Mom Is 79 and Wants a Cool Ride! What Car Should She Buy?
Dean is trying to help a 79-year-old mother out. She’s a cool lady who was rocking a 1994 Nissan 300ZX until disaster struck. Dean wants to find her a cool car that still has style and speed, but is maybe a little easier to manage. What car should she buy?...
Aug 27, 2025
At $32,500, Might You Aspire to This 2002 Panoz Esperante?
At $32,500, Might You Aspire to This 2002 Panoz Esperante?
Don Panoz made his money in pharmaceuticals, but the family name was made amongst auto enthusiasts by building cars like today’s Esperante. Let’s see if this Mustang-based special comes with a price that you think is a deal, or paying through the nose. What scares you? For me, it’s clowns,...
Aug 27, 2025
At $5,000, Could This Supercharged 1993 VW Passat be Your Bag?
At $5,000, Could This Supercharged 1993 VW Passat be Your Bag?
Bagged suspensions are an acquired taste, one that seems to have been favored by the seller of today’s Passat. Let’s see if this modded wagon’s price is so sweet that you can almost taste it. You know, some of you say that you could tidy up any car, slap a...
Aug 27, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved