zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Racing
/
Formula One Has A Frustrating Echo Chamber Problem
Formula One Has A Frustrating Echo Chamber Problem-August 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:11:17

Something has been blatantly missing from much of the public debate as to whether Formula One should get rid of grid girls: womens’ opinions.

We’ve heard from a number of male drivers and team heads, who all seem to trot out the same tired arguments about how it’s a tradition, they don’t see the harm and they . had more of them today, and once again, no one seemed to ring up Claire Williams.

Two of the men over Ferrari support keeping grid girls around, Autoweek writes:

Ferrari president Sergio Marchionne joined the fray this week by supporting the idea of grid girls, and now his Italian colleague and Ferrari F1 team principal Maurzio Arrivabene agrees.

“Grid girls were an integral part of Formula 1 for many years,” Arrivabene said. “I think Ross Brawn has more complex and important things to take care of.”

Ross Brawn is F1's managing director of motorsports whose comments that they may drop the use of grid girls this whole debate. Of course, it’s entirely F1's business to make sure the sport is welcoming to the wider audience, which is where this debate fits in.

Arrivabene’s statement is an odd one considering that he has more important things to concern himself with than this as well, like building a reliable car and not losing to Mercedes (again).

Another man who should definitely worry more about building a competitive car next year, Red Bull consultant Helmut Marko, chimed in with an even more frustrating take to Autoweek:

I just cannot imagine that. In America, cheerleaders appear before, during and after every game, so I see no reason why this should not be done in Formula 1.

I think we have other worries.

Oh boy. I hate the comparison to cheerleaders that inevitably comes up in this debate. While cheerleading has its own set of issues about , and at the pro level, it’s also a sport in its own right—and one usually open to both genders. Comparing women who mostly stand in one place to a set of precision-choreographed dancers and tumblers is about as apples to oranges as it gets. Worse yet, it implies that cheerleaders exist only for objectification, which isn’t the point of cheer, either.

But of course, another man from the team Ferrari and Red Bull keep losing to, Mercedes executive chairman Niki Lauda, told Autoweek that he’s okay with women seeking to better themselves as long as there’s not any change here:

The emancipation of women is perfectly right, and in fact they are in the process of overtaking us. But why should they not be allowed to stand on the grid anymore?

Yeah, no. Moving on from the weird tradition of using women only as decor doesn’t preclude anyone from working on a team, having a grid pass as a fan, driving or doing any number of activities on the grid. Hell, F1 might even pick up more female fans and participants if they drop the boy’s club veneer.

These disappointingly simplistic takes from men who are smarter than this speaks to the bigger problem: F1 is a bit of an echo chamber. Of course men who are surrounded primarily by other men see no issue here.

The practice of using pretty ladies as decor fundamentally doesn’t affect how anyone treats these men at the track, as it establishes that racing is a straight manly-man activity by default. That’s them! As a result, no one really questions their credentials or motivations for being there merely because of their gender.

But it’s frustrating to hear none of them considering why it’s mostly men in F1's upper echelons. Women in motorsport all too often get treated differently because of the perception that this is not for them, which is reinforced by having girls stand around as decor. Even though there’s less pressure for women to fit into certain occupations and interests now, the remnants of the old boys’ club in racing are alive and well.

Some research even suggests that a woman’s atmosphere can effect how women are treated. One study cited by noted that even modestly dressed women can be seen as less competent and intelligent by men who view sexualized imagery of women right before. In other words, those galleries of “paddock beauties” really don’t help.

This isn’t to say that mens’ opinions on the matter are worthless—rather, it’s obvious that they don’t have as much at stake in issues like this as their female counterparts. So, why aren’t we taking womens’ thoughts on the matter more seriously and giving them more airtime?

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Racing
Rally Champion Who Mentored Colin McRae Dies After His Plane Collided With A Helicopter
Rally Champion Who Mentored Colin McRae Dies After His Plane Collided With A Helicopter
The reports that rally champion Donald Milne, who also mentored , died after his private airplane collided with a fire-service helicopter in Spain on Saturday. Milne was 65 years old. Milne was in a small Bucker biplane when he and a helicopter owned by the state crashed at the Mutxamel...
Aug 1, 2026
This Is What Happened To A Honda Prelude Engine Flooded In Hurricane Harvey
This Is What Happened To A Honda Prelude Engine Flooded In Hurricane Harvey
The of for sale after a major hurricane can be temptingly cheap, but as the team is finding out, there are extremely good reasons why. POS Racing bought a 1992 Honda Prelude that they’d like to race in the 24 Hours of Lemons, and it came with a whole lot...
Aug 1, 2026
After Years Of Snubbing The Internet, F1 Is Finally Getting It
After Years Of Snubbing The Internet, F1 Is Finally Getting It
Formula One has never been big on that “internet” stuff, mostly because an and man ran the sport for years. That led F1 to be online, and in an era when a lot ofyoung people would rather pay to look at their phones and computers than pay for cable, that’s...
Aug 1, 2026
Weekend Motorsports Roundup, Jan. 6-7, 2018
Weekend Motorsports Roundup, Jan. 6-7, 2018
Welcome to the Jalopnik Weekend Motorsports Roundup, where we let you know what’s going on in the world of racing, where you can see it, and where you can talk about it all in one convenient place. Where else would you want to spend your weekend? The Dakar Rally (albeit...
Aug 1, 2026
Racer Scott Tucker Sentenced To Over 16 Years In Prison For Illegal Payday Lending Scheme
Racer Scott Tucker Sentenced To Over 16 Years In Prison For Illegal Payday Lending Scheme
Former American Le Mans Series champion Scott Tucker was sentenced to 16 years and 8 months in prison for illegal payday lending practices, reports . The $2 billion lending enterprise funded Tucker’s lavish lifestyle, which included racing an Audi LMP1 at as well as his Level 5 Motorsports based in...
Aug 1, 2026
Your Car Could Use A Boost From Formula One So Buy This Gigantic BMW F1 Turbo Kit
Your Car Could Use A Boost From Formula One So Buy This Gigantic BMW F1 Turbo Kit
Is your pesky BMW M12 inline four not cranking out enough power? Today is your lucky day! The full kit for a Garrett turbo as big as your face from a 1986 BMW Formula One engine is up for sale on for just £8,750.00, or $11,854.15 in ‘Murica Bucks. It’s...
Aug 1, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved