zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
GM's Legal Battle With Fiat Chrysler Is Turning Toward The Absurd
GM's Legal Battle With Fiat Chrysler Is Turning Toward The Absurd-August 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:38

Image for article titled GM's Legal Battle With Fiat Chrysler Is Turning Toward The Absurd

GM over alleged corrupt union bargaining, a lawsuit that though one that so far . Things when GM said that FCA had a “mole” inside GM. Today, FCA said GM’s allegations “would make John Le Carré cringe.”

The documents were filed in response to GM asking U.S. District Judge Paul Borman to reinstate the suit last week, while also speaking of the “mole” and various offshore bank accounts GM said it had discovered since filing the original complaint. That complaint alleged that FCA sabotaged contract negotiations for GM with the UAW, which in turn gave FCA a competitive advantage in the form of lower labor costs.

FCA has denied GM’s version of events all along, but the new “mole” allegations drew open ridicule. The spiciest part of the legal documents filed today:

GM’s proposed Amended Complaint reads like a script from a third-rate spy movie, full of preposterous allegations that FCA paid not one, but two, “mole[s]” to “infiltrate[] GM” and “funnel[] inside information to [FCA]” using money “stashed” in a “broad network” of “secret overseas [bank] accounts.” (Motion 2, 5, 7-8, 20- 21.) None of that is true. That GM has extended its attacks to individual FCA officers and employees, making wild allegations against them without a shred of factual support, is despicable.

[...]

In addition to concocting an unfounded tale of “corporate espionage” that would make John Le Carré cringe (Motion 21), GM (i) improperly seeks to reargue the standard for “direct causation” under RICO, (ii) misrepresents the legal standard governing leave to amend after judgment has been entered, and (iii) accuses the Court of committing “manifest error” by dismissing the Complaint without granting GM leave to amend, even though GM spent two years drafting its original complaint and did not previously request leave to amend. GM is wrong in every respect.

This motion is the latest example of the lengths to which GM is prepared to go in attacking FCA, accusing the Court of misconduct along the way. GM’s fictional account of “corporate espionage” is based entirely on two unremarkable allegations:

1. FCA—a Dutch corporation headquartered in the United Kingdom, with subsidiaries that operate facilities in Italy and more than 40 other countries, and sales to customers in more than 130 countries—maintains “foreign bank accounts” in “countries such as Switzerland, Luxembourg, Liechtenstein, Italy, Singapore, the Cayman Islands, and others.” (Motion 5.) That is unremarkable, and certainly not illegal.

2. Certain individuals—such as Alphons Iacobelli (who GM hired without asking FCA for a reference after his employment was summarily terminated by FCA) and Joseph Ashton (a former UAW official who served on GM’s Board of Directors and has no connection to FCA)—also held or controlled bank accounts in some of those same countries. (AC ¶¶ 35, 43.) Even if true, there is nothing illegal about that either.

Based solely on the “existence of [these] foreign bank accounts” (Karis Decl. ¶ 10), GM leaps to the bold conclusion, which it pleads solely on “information and belief,” that Iacobelli and Ashton were “mole[s]” paid by FCA through “secret overseas [bank] accounts” to “infiltrate[] GM,” “funnel[] inside information to [FCA],” and ensure that benefits and concessions provided to FCA by the UAW were not also provided to GM. (Motion 2, 5, 7-8, 20-21.) No facts alleged in the proposed Amended Complaint—not a single one—support this outrageously speculative accusation.

GM gave the following statement Monday in response to FCA’s response, :

“FCA’s corruption of the collective bargaining process remains undeniable — a federal investigation is ongoing and there have already been multiple guilty pleas,” GM said in a statement. “New facts uncovered through GM’s investigation which FCA tries to discount — including offshore accounts in multiple countries — implicate numerous individuals and make GM’s RICO case even stronger. GM seeks to uncover in court the full extent of harm the FCA bribery scheme caused GM.”

GM said nothing in FCA’s replies “counters the significance of these allegations and the direct harm the defendants’ corruption caused GM, and the Court should amend its prior judgment and reinstate our case.”

This is all getting a bit convoluted, but this what it looks like when both sides have seemingly unlimited amounts of money to spend on lawyers, in addition to all the time in the world. Borman, , is likely to make a quick ruling on GM’s reinstatement request, but who can say where this case goes from there.

You can read FCA’s entire response below.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Jalopnik Is Hosting Another Virtual Car Trivia Night FRIDAY So Get Ready For Some Fun
Jalopnik Is Hosting Another Virtual Car Trivia Night FRIDAY So Get Ready For Some Fun
There’s a lot of general malaise and melancholy going around in this world right now, but we can’t let it obnubilate our love for automobiles. That’s why my colleague Jason Torchinsky and I will be hosting on Friday to remind you all of two things: 1) Why you love...
Aug 1, 2026
I Asked A Real Car Color Professional Hard-Hitting Questions About Car Color And Here's The Result
I Asked A Real Car Color Professional Hard-Hitting Questions About Car Color And Here's The Result
It’s no secret that our nation—no, our world—is currently in crisis. Despite frivolous distractions like this whole “pandemic” and “global economic shutdown” we all know that the real crisis is the Crisis of Boring Car Colors. I’ve ranted about the tyranny of grays and whites and blacks before—colors the...
Aug 1, 2026
Seal--'Kissed By A Rose'
Seal--'Kissed By A Rose'
Traffic sucks, so why not start your morning off with some music? You provide the toast and we’ll provide the jams. In honor of saying goodbye to Michael Ballaban, I give you his favorite song. He demanded we all sing this over Zoom last night to send him off. Mike...
Aug 1, 2026
The Brazilian Volkswagen Fastback Was Even Weirder Than You Realize And Brings Up Some Big Questions
The Brazilian Volkswagen Fastback Was Even Weirder Than You Realize And Brings Up Some Big Questions
I’m well aware that if you even realize the Brazilian Volkswagen Fastback was weird at all, you’re already in kind of a minority, human-being-wise. But that’s okay—I’m here to walk you through this, and through it we will get, together. We’re going to start with this premise: though the...
Aug 1, 2026
Volkswagen Doesn't Know How Bad This Will Get
Volkswagen Doesn't Know How Bad This Will Get
Volkswagen’s profits are tumbling, Bentley extends its production shutdown, and Ford hopes to possibly restart production with the help of wristbands. All that and more in for April 16, 2020. Companies typically provide guidance to investors on how they think they will perform in the coming months. Amid the...
Aug 1, 2026
The Absurd Story Of How Some Genius Crashed Into The Same Home Three Times With Two Different Cars
The Absurd Story Of How Some Genius Crashed Into The Same Home Three Times With Two Different Cars
“...HIGH DRIVER CRASHES INTO HOUSE...THREE TIMES...WITH TWO DIFFERENT VEHICLES,” the ’s Marin-area office writes on its Facebook wall before continuing: “The details of the call were so strange that we started our response not really knowing exactly what had just happened.” Buckle up for an absolutely absurd story. Jalopnik’s...
Aug 1, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved