zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Google Didn't Actually Pay City To Use Emergency Vehicles In Driverless Car Test (Updated)
Google Didn't Actually Pay City To Use Emergency Vehicles In Driverless Car Test (Updated)-December 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:39

, Google’s driverless car developing unit, conducted an “emergency vehicle testing day” in the city of Chandler, Arizona last month to help driverless cars better understand the sights and sounds of police cars and fire trucks. Now, documents and interviews with the city and Waymo reveal Waymo did not pay Chandler for using four of its emergency vehicles, and the parties did not sign a formal agreement that would hold Waymo liable in the case of an accident.

Waymo held a demonstration and media event on June 28 to record and map emergency vehicles to help driverless cars yield.

The test occurred from 5:15 p.m. to 9:15 p.m. to gather data during daylight, dusk and nighttime. Police sedans, motorcycles and firetrucks drove in front of Waymo’s self driving cars while sensors gathered information. Waymo’s vehicles were not operating autonomously at the time.

A Waymo spokesperson confirmed the company did not pay for the use of emergency vehicles during this test, and the city did not have any records of agreements associated with the emergency vehicle demonstration.

The company and the city had, however, “a longstanding relationship” prior to the emergency testing day. Waymo had been testing its driverless cars in Chandler since April of last year, to expose its cars to like extreme heat and dust storms. The driverless car company also opened a Chandler operations center in October 2016, where they local residents to operate their cars.

Matt Burdick, communications and public affairs director, said the city created a “mutually beneficial” environment with Waymo: the city supports technology research in the hopes of producing local jobs and receiving public safety and mobility benefits from self-driving technology.

“Participating in Waymo’s emergency vehicle test advanced the research and development of this technology, while offering emergency responders the opportunity to interact with self-driving vehicles,” Burdick said in a statement to Jalopnik.

A mutually beneficial relationship isn’t unusual between corporations and local governments, but agreeing to resource exchanges without a written or formal agreement raises red flags, according to John Forrer, director of the Institute for Corporate Responsibility at George Washington University.

David Super, professor of law at Georgetown University, also mentioned that all levels of government provide direct and indirect subsidies to businesses from time to time, but these kind of partnerships are “looked at somewhat critically.” Issues arise if the government does not receive enough benefit from the partnership, or if the company could have easily paid for the research or tests itself.

Furthermore, Forrer said liability for accidents during these tests could get tricky since compensation was not exchanged between the two parties.

Burdick said each party, Waymo and Chandler, were responsible for their own liability.

Google’s self-driving car project, the wonderfully named Waymo, took time out from a high-profile…

Chandler’s notes field operation machinery and equipment expenditures last year amounted to $298,087. The field operations insurance cost the city more than $22,000, and repairs and maintenance cost over $52,000—a significant amount of money the city would have to cough up if the driverless car test went south.

Waymo and Chandler carefully administered the test to ensure an accident would not occur. The test occurred on a closed roadway, and Waymo engineers prepared Chandler fire and police personnel with test scenarios. The test themselves involved only one emergency vehicles at the time.

In the event of an accident, however unlikely, Super said the company would likely still owe the government for the damage to emergency vehicles. But without a formal agreement, the company has more ability to deny liability for an accident, deny negligence, stall or force the city to pay damages in full, Super said.

The fuzzy line between driverless car companies and the public resources they use for testing speaks to a broader issue: whether local governments are sacrificing money at the expensive of self-driving research.

Mary Peters, the former Secretary of Transportation under former President George W. Bush, recently argued driverless cars should pay to operate on public roads. Though potential game changers in safety and economic growth, driverless cars strip the government of tax revenue. Robot cars that perfectly obey traffic laws will reduce the millions of dollars that cities and states collect in traffic fines, Peters said, and electric autonomous cars make valuable gas taxes obsolete.

Some states have already seen the issue with driverless cars operating for free on public roads. proposed a fee of at least $0.025 for every mile a self-driving vehicle drives. Tennessee for the applications of AVs in the state, including a $0.01/mile or $0.026/mile tax depending on the vehicle size.

Super, however, doesn’t think most local governments depend on traffic tickets for a significant fraction of their revenue. If driverless cars on the roads mean less accidents, local governments may actually save money allocated towards police resources for dealing with wrecks, he said.

Furthermore, pollution from internal combustion engines may be a greater risk to society than lost government earnings via gas taxes.

“If these things really did drive better so their wouldn’t be more tickets, there would be savings as well as costs,” Super said.

Waymo’s relationship with Chandler raises an important question in how much self-driving car companies are leveraging brand names and bold promises of economic prosperity to take advantage of local government resources—and the taxpayer money that funds them.

: This post has been updated to include additional context from David Super, professor of law at Georgetown University.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
Tesla Will ‘Begin To Enable Full Self-Driving Features’ In August, But It’s Unclear What That Means
Tesla Will ‘Begin To Enable Full Self-Driving Features’ In August, But It’s Unclear What That Means
has been a leader in semi-autonomous driving tech for some time, but that’s been a double-edged sword. While ahead of many competitors, it now faces several investigations over crashes involving its Autopilot system and a flurry of criticism from safety advocates over how it is advertised. Nonetheless, CEO Elon Musk...
Dec 17, 2025
Lawsuit: Tesla Fired Exec After He Raised Concerns About Workplace Injuries Going Unreported (Updated)
Lawsuit: Tesla Fired Exec After He Raised Concerns About Workplace Injuries Going Unreported (Updated)
Tesla has been dogged by reports that it , and now the automaker’s former safety director is claiming in a lawsuit that he was fired in retaliation for raising concerns about the alleged practice. Tesla has responded to the lawsuit, alleging that the executive was fired after management received an...
Dec 17, 2025
GM Dumped $500 Million Into Lyft But It's Not Really Working Out
GM Dumped $500 Million Into Lyft But It's Not Really Working Out
Both General Motors and have ambitious goals to commercialize autonomous taxis in some way, but after teaming up more than two years ago, with the former investing $500 million in the latter, it seems they’ll no longer be pursuing that endeavor together. The plan originally was for GM and the...
Dec 17, 2025
The Electric Byton K-Byte Comes With Big Promises And A Huge Dash Screen
The Electric Byton K-Byte Comes With Big Promises And A Huge Dash Screen
Electric car startup Byton made a big splash at this year’s CES Conference, introducing an SUV concept with . Now, it has a half-billion dollars more in funding to get off the ground, along with a new concept, a fully-autonomous, all-electric sedan called the K-Byte. It looks sharp. Byton’s $500...
Dec 17, 2025
Bird, A Company That Rents Scooters, Is Reportedly Now Valued At $2 Billion
Bird, A Company That Rents Scooters, Is Reportedly Now Valued At $2 Billion
Electric scooters have flooded the streets of several cities across the U.S., propped up by venture capitalists backing several scooter renting startups that are duking it out to become Scooter Champion. One in particular, , is raising an additional $300 million in new funding, , which would value it at...
Dec 17, 2025
Tesla Is Laying Off 9 Percent Of Its Workforce
Tesla Is Laying Off 9 Percent Of Its Workforce
is laying off approximately 9 percent of its staff across the company, CEO Elon Musk said Tuesday in a staff-wide email, which he characterized as “an effort to reduce costs and become profitable.” In the email, Musk said the cuts were “almost entirely made from our salaried population and no...
Dec 17, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved