zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
Here's How A 425,000-Mile Tesla Model S Has Held Up
Here's How A 425,000-Mile Tesla Model S Has Held Up-August 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:11

Electric cars have grown more popular in the past five years than in any other time in automotive history, but that short time period has left a lot of questions about how these vehicles will age and wear. Now, High Mileage Reviews is checking out a 2015 Tesla Model S 70D with 425,000 miles on the odometer to help us get a better sense of what we could expect from a well-driven EV.

We’ve covered similar high-mileage Teslas before on Jalopnik, including about a 2016 Model X that drove over 400,000 miles. There, he found that the car required just under $30,000 of service, maintenance, and repairs. Many of the issues were similar to those we deal with in ICE cars, including minor electrical switch failure and standard replacements. Tesla had its own specific issues around build quality, and Tracy noted that there were also some EV-specific concerns about battery failure but that the driver didn’t have to worry about all the fiddly pieces of a combustion engine falling apart. But by looking solely at service records, there didn’t appear to be anything majorly wrong.

In the video from High Mileage Reviews, we get a more comprehensive sense of the vehicle:

From an aesthetic standpoint, the car is in pretty good shape. The Model S has accumulated some exterior wear-and-tear, the worst of which is some condensation in the lights. Its interior has also held up well — all impressive feats, since this car was used as an Uber and saw folks in all states of life climbing in and out of it.

But as High Mileage Reviews points out, that doesn’t tell the whole story. The retracting door handles have had to be replaced seven times — which cost $1,000 per handle when the car was out of warranty. The infotainment screen also malfunctioned, which left the owner without turn signals, HVAC controls, or rear-view cameras until it was repaired. The adhesives binding the screens also failed, leaving the screens with a soap-scum look.

How about everything else, though?

The original battery was replaced at 250,000 miles for reasons not noted in the service documents. Out of warranty, that replacement would have cost $15-20,000, but in-warranty it was free. The current battery is also pretty well-loved, and it gets about an 87 percent charge for a range of just over 200 miles. There was also a front drive unit replacement and suspension repair at 375,000 miles, and brake pad and rotor replacement and HVAC repair at 300,000 miles.

Overall, there had been quite a few fixes, but as High Mileage Review noted in the comments, the cost of repairs was comparable to what you’d expect in a combustion car of a similar age and use. A lot of those cheaper repairs came thanks to Tesla’s exceptional eight-year and 250,000-mile warranty, which helped offset the costs of some finicky repairs that came thanks to new technologies.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Land Rover Once Made An Edible Survival Guide And I'm Trying To Find One, To Eat
Land Rover Once Made An Edible Survival Guide And I'm Trying To Find One, To Eat
Like most people willing to listen to me talk about cars for more than 15 seconds, I have a sort of irrational affection for Land Rover. They’re extremely capable machines in extreme environments and , well, at least the old ones were, but they’re full of rugged, unpolished charm....
Aug 11, 2026
I've Encountered A Type Of VW Beetle Turn Indicator I've Never Seen Before And I'm Going Nuts
I've Encountered A Type Of VW Beetle Turn Indicator I've Never Seen Before And I'm Going Nuts
The other night I was hanging out at Flashing Amber’s, my local turn-signal fetishists’ bar (not to be confused with , the pub I go to when I want to talk about taillights) when a friend I know from the turn indicator enthusiast community came up to me, slightly...
Aug 11, 2026
Why I Sometimes Wear A Mask Even While Driving
Why I Sometimes Wear A Mask Even While Driving
Every once in a while, I see memes or social media posts making fun of people who are wearing face masks while behind the wheel. “Why would anyone wear a mask while driving?” Well, there are several reasons. You might be wearing a mask if you are driving with...
Aug 11, 2026
Neither The Election Nor The Pandemic Can Stop Detroit's Car Culture From Thriving
Neither The Election Nor The Pandemic Can Stop Detroit's Car Culture From Thriving
Seventy-Four year old Lewis Emanuel had less than a dollar in his bank account, and just a quarter tank of fuel in his leaky, rusty 2003 . But somehow, he managed to find a way to show up to a Detroit-area car show on Saturday. It is a testament...
Aug 11, 2026
What Are The Quirks Of Your Local Car Culture?
What Are The Quirks Of Your Local Car Culture?
What you see above could only be described as Pure Michigan. It’s a scene from a car meet and Woodward cruise our own David Tracy to throw the next day in suburban Detroit. We were talking about the peculiarity of the Michigan car scene in Jalop Slack, and it...
Aug 11, 2026
Legendary McLaren P1 Designer Sketched A Redesigned Ferrari F40
Legendary McLaren P1 Designer Sketched A Redesigned Ferrari F40
Hey now, look at that! You may have just finished reading ’s great interview with legendary designer . Well Frank has moved on from working on McLarens to now making internet videos, and in his latest he attempts to redesign the iconic . While I’m always charmed by the...
Aug 11, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved