zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
How Bob Lutz saved GM from Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh and itself
How Bob Lutz saved GM from Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh and itself-January 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:14

In his new book, former General Motors Vice Chairman Bob Lutz calls , Glenn Beck and other right-wing critics of GM "reckless" for their hatred of anything linked to the Obama administration — including the . Here's our exclusive first drive review of the soon-to-be-published book.

In his book, "," Lutz reveals what anyone who pays even the slightest of attention to the auto industry has known for years, that far from being created by the Obama administration, the original idea of the Volt sprouted in 2005 — and it would have never survived GM's bureaucracy without a push from .

Chris Paine's new movie "Revenge of the Electric Car" will get its World Premiere at the Tribeca…

Lutz — a cigar-smoking, jet-flying former Marine — has long admitted that the halo cast by the Toyota Prius unfairly sainted Toyota while casting GM vehicles as pollution-barfing tanks. Lutz's original idea was to recommit GM to a pure electric vehicle with lithium-ion batteries — a prospect that GM's engineers and executives hated due to the scars from the EV1 project.

When Musk unveiled the Tesla Roadster in 2005, it gave Lutz the ammo he needed to get a concept approved by GM's management. But as he talked with engineer Jon Lauckner, Lauckner said he had a better idea, and sketched out an electric-powered four-seat sedan with a T-shaped battery cell charged for extended range by an onboard engine — the basic design of the Chevy Volt sitting on dealer lots' six years later.

The birth of the Volt would take several more years and hundreds of tougher hurdles, including GM's collapse into an Obama administration bailout. Lutz makes clear the Volt did not sprout from environmental concerns; his detailed take on global warming matches his previous comments labeling it poo-filled ceramics. But Lutz contends the Volt's transformation into a "political football," by both and Limbaugh has robbed the credit due to GM's engineers for its invention:

Earlier this week, an automotive blogger took to the pages of the New York Times to argue that the…

Animosity towards the Obama administration is so intense among the right-wing talk-show hosts that any vulnerability, however tenuous, must be attacked and blamed on ‘socialist influence,' with no regard to truth or to the damage these reckless claims can make…

The skeptics, the pundits, the GM haters, and those who detest lithium ion as a chemistry will all be dragged, however unwittingly, to the same conclusion: Volt paved the way, Volt was first with the extended-range EV concept, Volt demonstrated the will and technological capability of General Motors…And to all the doubters, opponents, critics and skeptics… [including] Glenn Beck, I say: ‘Eat your hearts out. Volt is the future.'

"To all the doubters… [including] Glenn Beck, I say: ‘Eat your hearts out. Volt is the future.'"

The heart of Lutz's book details the problems he faced upon being coaxed out of retirement by GM Chairman and CEO Rick Wagoner in 2001 to remake the company's vehicle development process. Lutz had worked at GM before in the ‘60s, before stints at Ford, BMW and Chrysler, and he details the long decline of American automakers from the inside, pinging number-crunching CEOs, demurring stylists and engineers, and U.S. fuel economy standards, which he contends handed huge advantages to Japanese and European automakers.

When Lutz finally comes back to GM in September 2001, he finds a bureaucracy asphyxiating on its own hubris, convinced the terabytes of PowerPoints will lead GM to global triumph despite all common sense. GM's pre-Lutz ideas included a Buick concept that could be driven entirely by voice control, because that's what Buick's elderly owners said they wanted in focus groups. Whether it was covering the first-generation Chrysler 300 in 90-odd post-it notes showing how its popular design failed GM standards, or worrying that adding chrome trim to the Chevy Impala would kill a cost target even while making the car attractive, Lutz details just how close GM came to being irreparably broken.

Lutz was lucky to find under the bureaucracy's avalanche a hovel of talented people - from French-born designers to Harley-riding metal stampers - that knew exactly what needed changing, but had never had the chance to say so, or even been asked. He also managed to start the process of turning GM into a global automaker, rather than a cage match of regional vice presidents who fought ideas like selling the Holden Commodore SS as a Pontiac sports sedan. (Lutz's plans to turn Pontiac into an affordable American BMW offer some of the saddest what-might-have-been moments).

Lutz argues the same dynamic that pushed GM to collapse threatens the rest of American business as well. He sees in too many executives the same numbers-obsessed, MBA groupthink that turned GM from world dominator to ward of the state. And he bleakly warns that the United States may have to come close to a Chapter 11 of its own before ridding itself of the idea of "too big to fail."

To his credit, Lutz admits that even if he had been GM's CEO, he would not only have made many of the same mistakes as Wagoner, he might have added a few new ones too, like not buying Korea's Daewoo, which has become the source of GM's small car engineering worldwide. And that's the real secret: "Car Guys vs. Bean Counters" isn't a contest. It's the formula for success; when one side gets too dominant, the entire system falls apart.

GM's newest models have proven successful, profitable and able to keep pace with some of the world's best. When Lutz came out of retirement in 2001, one Wall Street analyst estimated that if he successfully set GM's carbuilding right, Lutz could add $1 billion to GM's roughly $10 billion market value. Without him, GM probably would have struggled through until 2008, and still been bailed out — but left bereft of knowing how to build cars that people want. The old GM might have tried to put a value on Lutz's contributions. The new GM should know numbers never tell the whole story.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
At $27,500, Is This Low-Mileage 1991 Ford Mustang LX 5.0 a Foxy Deal?
At $27,500, Is This Low-Mileage 1991 Ford Mustang LX 5.0 a Foxy Deal?
Shrewd people can be described as “sly as a fox,” but we’ll still have to determine if buying today’s 5.0 Fox body Mustang will prove a cunning move. Beetle Bailey is one of the world’s longest-running comic strips, even outlasting its creator, Mort Walker. There must be something about...
Jan 13, 2026
Mercedes Plans to Kill Nearly All of Its Wagons and Coupes in the Next Few Years
Mercedes Plans to Kill Nearly All of Its Wagons and Coupes in the Next Few Years
If you’re a fan of Mercedes Benz and their or models, you may want to act fast if you’re keen on getting your hands on a new one. Those models won’t be long for this world if a report from is any indication. The luxury brand plans to take...
Jan 13, 2026
You Could Buy Every Toyobaru on AutoTrader for the Price of the Final Bugatti Chiron
You Could Buy Every Toyobaru on AutoTrader for the Price of the Final Bugatti Chiron
The billionaires of our world often face tough choices, most importantly: What’s the most they can possibly spend on a new car? CNN reports that the Bugatti Chiron Profilée, the the brand will ever build, this week — the highest price ever paid for a brand-new car. Add in...
Jan 13, 2026
The E28 BMW 5-Series Showed a Brand Entering its Golden Era
The E28 BMW 5-Series Showed a Brand Entering its Golden Era
People love BMW. Or, rather, they seem to love how BMW was from the 1980s up to the mid-aughts. Nowadays, the company is leaning hard into and , burning a lot of the enthusiasm people had for the brand. I used to be a big BMW fan, and one...
Jan 13, 2026
The 2023 Acura Integra A-Spec Lets You Hold Onto Your Youth
The 2023 Acura Integra A-Spec Lets You Hold Onto Your Youth
sucks, but the is a car that can ease the transition from adolescence into adulthood. Few vehicles hit that sweet spot between and , but an with a six-speed manual transmission makes shifting into your more mature years that much easier. : Acura lent me an Integra A-Spec with...
Jan 13, 2026
I Need a Fancy Family Hauler for Under $20,000! What Car Should I Buy?
I Need a Fancy Family Hauler for Under $20,000! What Car Should I Buy?
John just moved to New Jersey from New York City and had the quick realization that one car is not going to cut it for a suburban family. He has a modest budget but wants an SUV on the nicer side that can hold him over for a few...
Jan 13, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved