zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
Jalopnik Reviews: 2005 Nissan Maxima SL, Part 1
Jalopnik Reviews: 2005 Nissan Maxima SL, Part 1-December 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:22

The Nissan Maxima SL would have made a hell of a Buick. One shake of its golf-bag-devouring bustle, one blip of its throttle, and the fictional Buick Maxima would have drawn a crowd of Geritol guzzlers on the lookout for something Detroit is loathe to give them: a hot toddy spiked with a shot of adrenaline. A measured dose of Cialis, not a foot bath in Epsom salts.

Where it

s obvious Buick thinks of its customers posthumously, Nissan seems pretty sure they

re still kicking up dust. Put it this way: My mom

s uncle served in Burma during World War II. For the first 55 years of his driving life he owned Pontiacs exclusively; for the final 20, he owned Nissan Maximas. Wouldn

t be caught dead in an

old guy

s car,

he

d say. If he

d lived long enough to see the Maxima

s 2004 redesign, of which 2006 will likely be the final model year, it

s assured he would have again traded up.

(Though Nissan claims its typical Maxima buyer is nearly two decades younger, on the road we

ve been seeing lots of gray terrain bobbing above new Maximas

seat rests.)

That

s because the Maxima SL is, at base, a sensible, entry-luxury car

offering all the comforts of a Lincoln Townhouse without the seagoing road feel. Not as rough and ready as its SE model sibling, which is tuned for younger spines undaunted by disc degeneration, it

s nonetheless comfortable without being comfortably numb.

Under the hood, however, beats the heart of a Georgia feist on a possum hunt. In fact, tip-in is so overanxious, you

d think Nissan

s ubiquitous 3.5-liter V6 (265 hp in the Max) was financed by the rubber industry. It

s a great engine, smooth if not sonorous — the same one Nissan inserts in the 350Z and Pathfinder. But in the Maxima, it

s got a mischievous streak wide enough to play Australian rules football on. Pull my finger, it bids. And, by cracky, you always fall for that one.

Torque steer is the result. Heaps of it. Swings wilder than Babe Ruth

s after a night of bathtub gin at El Morocco. The Maxima

s a front-driver, you see, built athwart the same underpinnings as its Altima sibling. That means an interior measured in acreage, but a driveline that misbehaves like Golden Ticket-holders in Wonkaland. Despite the benefits of instant power, if gramps wants to overtake a semi, he

d better have both hands firmly to the wheel.

Still, the Maxima SL is a decent handler overall. The massive rubber quotient and sufficiently damped suspension collude like felonious bankers to keep the blocky sedan more or less on track. From behind the wheel, however, it feels huge and heavy, more so than its spec-sheet weight and measurements would suggest. Safe is how some would put it.

Inside, with wood-inlaid curvilinear shapes enfolding the cockpit and a novel, rectangular moonroof bisecting the overhead space, the Maxima

s interior rivals Copenhagen

s Opera House for Danishness. Someone in wardrobe took the time to hunt down excellent faux finishes, from the

suede

along the doors, to the

cashmere

headliner, to the

wood

tone accents. If my hands hadn

t felt the real thing, I

d almost swear these materials were authentic. Outside, the surface-y design language is closer to the avant garde than any other sedan on the road. Art-house pretense aside, it

s got the face of a robotic armadillo, and the bum of a Victorian hoop-skirt model.

Uncle Nick would have loved it.

[by Mike Spinelli]

Related:

Jalopnik Reviews: 2005 Nissan Maxima SL, , [internal]

Exterior Design: ****With the Altima and Maxima starting to look like fraternal twins by 2002,…

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
What's the Best Way to Avoid All the Upsells in the Dealership's Finance Office?
What's the Best Way to Avoid All the Upsells in the Dealership's Finance Office?
As Jalopnik’s resident car buying expert and professional car shopper, I get emails. Lots of emails. I’ve decided to pick a few questions and try to help out. This week we are discussing avoiding the finance office, inspecting “certified” cars, and when ridesharing makes more sense than owning. First...
Dec 19, 2025
At $4,500, Could This 1985 Kawasaki GPz900 Ninja Make You The Top Gun?
At $4,500, Could This 1985 Kawasaki GPz900 Ninja Make You The Top Gun?
Once made famous by Tom Cruise in the movie Top Gun, the Kawasaki GPz900 Ninja like to today’s example is still modern enough that it could still fill a staring role in anyone’s driveway. Let’s see if its price is equally a maverick move. Have you ever noticed how...
Dec 19, 2025
At $25,000, Could This 2015 Mitsubishi Lancer Make You Believe in EVO-lution?
At $25,000, Could This 2015 Mitsubishi Lancer Make You Believe in EVO-lution?
Over the years, Mitsubishi’s EVO line of Lancers have traced a bell curve of hot to hard core and then back again. Today’s EVO may be on the downward slope of that, but could its price still throw you for a curve? Well, well, well. It appears that few...
Dec 19, 2025
At $4,800, Could This Rebuilt-Titled 2007 Dodge Magnum 5.7 Salvage a Win?
At $4,800, Could This Rebuilt-Titled 2007 Dodge Magnum 5.7 Salvage a Win?
Today’s Dodge is a fine example of the maxim “they don’t build ‘em like they used to.” Could however, that old school attitude and cool Chrysler front clip be enough to outweigh its tainted title and its price? Annnnnd, I’m back. Did you miss me? The correct answer to...
Dec 19, 2025
This Supercharger Has a Datsun Roadster Attached to It
This Supercharger Has a Datsun Roadster Attached to It
Superchargers are awesome because they provide extra power with a very linear delivery curve. There’s no lag because they aren’t exhaust driven. Obviously, there needs to be a car attached to a supercharger for it to be effective. This particular supercharger lives in the engine bay of a 1969...
Dec 19, 2025
10,000 Miles Owning a Buick Regal TourX Wagon: What I've Learned
10,000 Miles Owning a Buick Regal TourX Wagon: What I've Learned
General Motors doesn’t want you to know that Buick is building a good car right now. Hidden in among the nondescript “That’s a Buick?” crossovers on lots is a beautiful machine built on the last vestiges of GM’s control of Opel. It’s the only American-nameplate wagon left in a...
Dec 19, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved