zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
Jalopnik Reviews: 2005 Nissan Maxima SL, Part 1
Jalopnik Reviews: 2005 Nissan Maxima SL, Part 1-May 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:22

The Nissan Maxima SL would have made a hell of a Buick. One shake of its golf-bag-devouring bustle, one blip of its throttle, and the fictional Buick Maxima would have drawn a crowd of Geritol guzzlers on the lookout for something Detroit is loathe to give them: a hot toddy spiked with a shot of adrenaline. A measured dose of Cialis, not a foot bath in Epsom salts.

Where it

s obvious Buick thinks of its customers posthumously, Nissan seems pretty sure they

re still kicking up dust. Put it this way: My mom

s uncle served in Burma during World War II. For the first 55 years of his driving life he owned Pontiacs exclusively; for the final 20, he owned Nissan Maximas. Wouldn

t be caught dead in an

old guy

s car,

he

d say. If he

d lived long enough to see the Maxima

s 2004 redesign, of which 2006 will likely be the final model year, it

s assured he would have again traded up.

(Though Nissan claims its typical Maxima buyer is nearly two decades younger, on the road we

ve been seeing lots of gray terrain bobbing above new Maximas

seat rests.)

That

s because the Maxima SL is, at base, a sensible, entry-luxury car

offering all the comforts of a Lincoln Townhouse without the seagoing road feel. Not as rough and ready as its SE model sibling, which is tuned for younger spines undaunted by disc degeneration, it

s nonetheless comfortable without being comfortably numb.

Under the hood, however, beats the heart of a Georgia feist on a possum hunt. In fact, tip-in is so overanxious, you

d think Nissan

s ubiquitous 3.5-liter V6 (265 hp in the Max) was financed by the rubber industry. It

s a great engine, smooth if not sonorous — the same one Nissan inserts in the 350Z and Pathfinder. But in the Maxima, it

s got a mischievous streak wide enough to play Australian rules football on. Pull my finger, it bids. And, by cracky, you always fall for that one.

Torque steer is the result. Heaps of it. Swings wilder than Babe Ruth

s after a night of bathtub gin at El Morocco. The Maxima

s a front-driver, you see, built athwart the same underpinnings as its Altima sibling. That means an interior measured in acreage, but a driveline that misbehaves like Golden Ticket-holders in Wonkaland. Despite the benefits of instant power, if gramps wants to overtake a semi, he

d better have both hands firmly to the wheel.

Still, the Maxima SL is a decent handler overall. The massive rubber quotient and sufficiently damped suspension collude like felonious bankers to keep the blocky sedan more or less on track. From behind the wheel, however, it feels huge and heavy, more so than its spec-sheet weight and measurements would suggest. Safe is how some would put it.

Inside, with wood-inlaid curvilinear shapes enfolding the cockpit and a novel, rectangular moonroof bisecting the overhead space, the Maxima

s interior rivals Copenhagen

s Opera House for Danishness. Someone in wardrobe took the time to hunt down excellent faux finishes, from the

suede

along the doors, to the

cashmere

headliner, to the

wood

tone accents. If my hands hadn

t felt the real thing, I

d almost swear these materials were authentic. Outside, the surface-y design language is closer to the avant garde than any other sedan on the road. Art-house pretense aside, it

s got the face of a robotic armadillo, and the bum of a Victorian hoop-skirt model.

Uncle Nick would have loved it.

[by Mike Spinelli]

Related:

Jalopnik Reviews: 2005 Nissan Maxima SL, , [internal]

Exterior Design: ****With the Altima and Maxima starting to look like fraternal twins by 2002,…

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
At $9,999, Will This 1979 Mazda RX-7 Survivor Survive Our Scrutiny?
At $9,999, Will This 1979 Mazda RX-7 Survivor Survive Our Scrutiny?
The seller of today’s RX-7 is looking to cull a car collection, and this Mazda has to go. Let’s figure out if that collector’s loss could be someone else’s gain. Life is full of little risks. One such gamble is the increasingly less remote chance that the tuna sushi...
May 20, 2026
Should I Go For More Performance Or Better Features?
Should I Go For More Performance Or Better Features?
As Jalopnik’s resident car-buying expert and a professional car shopper, I get emails. Lots of emails. I’ve picked a few of your questions and will try to help out. This week we are discussing if it’s better to prioritize performance over features and if a dealership is getting “revenge”...
May 20, 2026
At $4,000, Is This 1984 Lincoln Continental Diesel A Bustle-Back Bargain?
At $4,000, Is This 1984 Lincoln Continental Diesel A Bustle-Back Bargain?
One of the most interesting stories to come out of 1980s autodom was Ford’s purchase of BMW diesel engines for its Lincoln brand. Today’s Continental is a rare surviving example of that ill-fated plan. Let’s see if historical value holds any sway over that of the car. About halfway...
May 20, 2026
Marvel At The Deep Discounts And Slick Deals On EVs That Too Few Folks Want
Marvel At The Deep Discounts And Slick Deals On EVs That Too Few Folks Want
If you have been looking for a cheap green car, or if you love bargains on cars that hardly anyone wants, listen up. Chevy and Toyota are offering incentives that are nearly unprecedented on their EV and FCEV models — vehicles that are often overlooked. In what may be...
May 20, 2026
At $3,500, Is This 1999 Porsche Boxster A Hot Deal Or A Potential Heartbreaker?
At $3,500, Is This 1999 Porsche Boxster A Hot Deal Or A Potential Heartbreaker?
They say there’s no such thing as a cheap Porsche and yet today’s Boxster is...a cheap Porsche. Could its low price make it an easy onramp to Porsche ownership? Or is it a rocky road to future expenses? The path plied by yesterday’s was certainly an interesting one. On...
May 20, 2026
At $11,990, Does This 2016 Chevy Sonic RS Turbo Sound Like A Good Deal?
At $11,990, Does This 2016 Chevy Sonic RS Turbo Sound Like A Good Deal?
As an example of the last subcompact model sold in the U.S. to have actually been built in the U.S., today’s Sonic is a small car that’s kind of a big deal. Let’s see if this hot hatch is priced to hatch a quick sale. I recently discovered that...
May 20, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved