zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Lawsuit: Tesla Fired Exec After He Raised Concerns About Workplace Injuries Going Unreported (Updated)
Lawsuit: Tesla Fired Exec After He Raised Concerns About Workplace Injuries Going Unreported (Updated)-April 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:37

Tesla has been dogged by reports that it , and now the automaker’s former safety director is claiming in a lawsuit that he was fired in retaliation for raising concerns about the alleged practice. Tesla has responded to the lawsuit, alleging that the executive was fired after management received an “onslaught of complaints” about his behavior, which included intimidation and making allegedly inappropriate comments about women.

If found to be accurate, the claims by the former executive substantiate those made in a scathing report by the magazine in April that disputed the electric automaker’s safety record.

Carlos Ramirez was Tesla’s Director of Environmental, Health, Safety, and Sustainability until June 2017, according to a complaint filed last Wednesday in Alameda County Superior Court. Prior to that, his LinkedIn page says, he worked as the Vice President of Safety for SolarCity, the energy company that Tesla acquired in late 2016.

While at Tesla, according to the complaint, Ramirez was assigned the task of creating a safety program at Tesla’s assembly plant in Fremont, California.

“To accomplish this, Plaintiff became familiar with the Tesla Fremont manufacturing plant,” the suit says. “In addition, Plaintiff and his team audited the Tesla Incident Reporting System, in which workplace accidents/injuries are record and managed.”

As a result of the audit, Ramirez claims Tesla’s incident reporting system revealed “numerous instances of lack of treatment of Tesla employees that suffered workplace injuries, recordkeeping violations, and improper classification of workplace injuries to avoid treating and reporting workplace injuries.”

Ramirez claims he reported the discrepancies to Tesla, and says in the lawsuit that the automaker “made allegedly untrue statements to the state and the public based on incorrect and incident rate numbers.” (Mark Le Clerc, Ramirez’s attorney, told Jalopnik: “We do not have any comment at this time.”)

Issues surrounding Tesla’s workplace records came to light in April, after the nonprofit Center for Investigative Reporting’s publication Reveal put out a story that Tesla improperly classifies injuries on the OSHA 300 report—paperwork by the government required to log serious work-related injuries and illnesses—which effectively bolstered its safety record.

California regulators launched an investigation , without saying whether it was in response to Reveal’s report. Tesla vehemently denied the allegations and insisted its workplace injury rate is better than the auto industry’s average. (Incredibly, the automaker went so far as to label Reveal, a Pulitzer Prize-winning nonprofit news outlet, of being an )

Over the past year, as Tesla has struggled to ramp up production of the Model 3 sedan, the company…

But now Ramirez’s suit alleges he flagged the very issue at hand in Reveal’s report over a year ago directly to the automaker.

At a May 19, 2017, workplace meeting, Ramirez alleges he reported “unsafe and unhealthy working conditions and practices” and “disclosed information he had reasonable cause to believe disclosed a violation” of state or federal laws, including “allegedly inaccurate Tesla OSHA 300 records, incident rate numbers, and improper classification of workplace injuries.”

Weeks later, the suit says, Tesla fired him.

“Among other adverse employment actions, Tesla wrongfully accused Plaintiff of bullying, brought unfounded complaints against him, and terminated Plaintiff’s employment on June 8, 2017,” the lawsuit alleges.

Tesla didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

Ramirez’s suit lays out a litany of issues that he said he raised to Tesla about “unsafe and unhealthy working conditions and work practices,” including chemical and oil spills, chemical fires, workplace injury rate discrepancies and inaccuracies, and a failure to report or document workplace injuries.

Around the time of the May 2017 meeting, Ramirez alleges he also complained to his boss about two Tesla employees being “racially biased” toward him. (Ramirez identifies as a Mexican-American Hispanic in the suit.)

Ramirez says his supervisor asked him if he “really needed to send” an email “that contained a complaint and report of such lawful conduct,” according to the suit. “He told Plaintiff that his complaint would just create problems.”

The lawsuit lays out several claims for retaliation and discrimination and asks for various compensatory and nominal damages.

Tesla has been hit by several lawsuits over the last year from employees at the Fremont factory for alleged workplace violations, as well as sales employees, who recently from the automaker over the alleged compensation issues. (Tesla denied any wrongdoing in the settlement.)

The National Labor Relations Board , after the agency said it corroborated claims levied by the United Auto Workers. A trial over the NLRB complaint began Monday and is slated to resume Tuesday morning.

: A Tesla spokesperson responded to the lawsuit with the following statement:

Mr. Ramirez was employed by Tesla for less than four months after joining from SolarCity, and during his short time at Tesla, it was his job to identify ways to enhance our safety program, and he certainly was not terminated for doing so. That would make no sense.

Mr. Ramirez was terminated because after an extensive investigation, it was clear that he had engaged over and over again in harassing workplace behavior and used extremely inappropriate language that violated any reasonable standard. We conducted our investigation after we received an onslaught of complaints about Mr. Ramirez’s behavior, with nearly a dozen different employees stating that he engaged in clear bullying, sought to intimidate his colleagues, and repeatedly made inappropriate comments about women. Importantly, this was not a case of he said/she said. There were literally almost a dozen people who came forward to complain about Mr. Ramirez – notably, from a wide variety of different locations and departments within the company, some of whom were Mr. Ramirez’s direct reports and others who were his peers in other departments. Among the evidence that was provided:

One employee said that Mr. Ramirez commented on a fellow employee by saying ‘she’s got some big old [expletive].’ This obviously made the employee very uncomfortable.

One of Mr. Ramirez’s direct reports said that he made inappropriate comments towards women, calling them names like ‘hun’, and that he regularly tried to intimidate others.

Another employee told her manager that because of the abrasive language that Mr. Ramirez repeatedly used against her, she never wanted to interact with him again.

One of Mr. Ramirez’s direct reports said that he regularly mistreated his team, and that she felt he bullied team members and others with abusive remarks.

Multiple employees said that they were fearful of coming forward because they had witnessed Mr. Ramirez engage in intimidation and they were scared of being retaliated against by him.

Bullying and harassment have no place at Tesla.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
Different Strokes For Different Folks: A Super Cruise Discussion
Different Strokes For Different Folks: A Super Cruise Discussion
GM’s Super Cruise system is, by , the best semi-autonomous system on the market today.If safety is part of the consideration, and it should be, then it is . But it isn’t without its flaws, such as about direct sunlight throwing the system into total confusion and kicking control...
Apr 8, 2026
The Legal Argument That Could Destroy Uber
The Legal Argument That Could Destroy Uber
Days after Uber began selling stock, the National Labor Relations Board’s top lawyer gave the company a huge gift. In an advice memo, the general counsel’s office determined that Uber’s drivers . If drivers are legally determined to be employees, it would throw Uber’s entire business model into question...
Apr 8, 2026
Mercedes' Latest Experimental Safety Car Has a Little Robot Triangle, Among Other Things
Mercedes' Latest Experimental Safety Car Has a Little Robot Triangle, Among Other Things
Experimental Safety Cars were a big deal back in the 1970s, when most major manufacturers were building (usually) bright yellow, heavy-looking sedans with massive black rubber bumpers front and rear, all in an attempt to develop and showcase safety technology. Mercedes started building these again back in 2009, and now...
Apr 8, 2026
GM's New Electrics Could Be Why the Mid-Engine Corvette Isn't Here Yet
GM's New Electrics Could Be Why the Mid-Engine Corvette Isn't Here Yet
, then rest assured with the knowledge that a replacement is on its way. And it’s not just a replacement for the infotainment, either—it seems like there’s an update from the ground up. Unfortunately, this update may or may not have delayed GM’s other big projects; namely, the ....
Apr 8, 2026
Chevron and EVgo Partner to Build Fast Chargers at Gas Stations
Chevron and EVgo Partner to Build Fast Chargers at Gas Stations
EVgo wants to bring electric car charging infrastructure to the mainstream by fitting them in convenient places. Far too often are electric charging stations placed in the middle of nowhere without even so much as shelter from the rain or a place to relieve yourself. It makes sense to...
Apr 8, 2026
Tesla's Navigate Is Worse Than Human Driving: Consumer Reports
Tesla's Navigate Is Worse Than Human Driving: Consumer Reports
Car buyers have shown that they’re ready to —but are automakers actually equipped to meet that demand? A new Consumer Reports article evaluating the viability of Tesla’s Autopilot software says that we’re... not quite there yet. Tesla recently updated its Autopilot software to include , an optional program that...
Apr 8, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved