zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Limits Of Tesla's Autopilot And Driver Error Cited In Fatal Model S Crash
Limits Of Tesla's Autopilot And Driver Error Cited In Fatal Model S Crash-April 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:38

The U.S. National Transportation Safety Board ruled today that the “operational design” of played a key role in a 2016 fatal crash that left the owner of a Model S dead. The vehicle’s semi-autonomous system permitted the driver, Joshua Brown to use Autopilot in ways “inconsistent” with warnings from Tesla that “permitted his prolonged disengagements from the driving task” and ultimately contributed to his death.

The nearly three-hour hearing offered a wide-ranging discussion on the limitations of automated systems on the road today. The NTSB suggested to any maker of semi-autonomous vehicles to prevent the use of the technology on roads where the vehicles aren’t suited to travel without human control of the vehicle.

Brown, a 40-year-old self-described Tesla fanatic, died in May 2016 when his Model S sedan rammed into the side of a trailer on a big-rig truck that was turning left in front of the vehicle. The Model S was traveling at 74 mph using Autopilot, which failed to identify the truck and never slowed the vehicle down, the NTSB said.

But Brown and the truck driver bore some fault, as well, in the Florida crash, the agency said.

The NTSB issued 13 findings related to the crash, including a pair of citations over Brown’s driving patterns. Brown relied too much on automation, and demonstrated a “lack of understanding of system limitations,” the agency said.

Part of that, the NTSB indicated, had to do with Tesla. Tesla has repeatedly said in the past that drivers must keep their hands on the wheel and pay attention to the road if they enable Autopilot.

But Tesla could’ve taken additional steps to prevent misuse of Autopilot, which worked as designed, the NTSB said, but the feature was used in ways that weren’t intended—and that Tesla didn’t go far enough to ensure drivers remained alert. (Tesla has previously said to a separate federal regulator that it evaluated the potential for some drivers .)

“Tesla allowed the driver to use the system outside of the environment for which it was designed and the system gave far too much leeway to the driver to divert his attention,” said Robert Sumwalt, the NTSB chairman.

The truck driver, who refused to be interviewed by the NTSB, failed to yield the right of way to Brown, but the agency said both Tesla and the driver had “at least 10 seconds” to see each other, and there’s “no evidence” that either took evasive action to prevent the crash.

In a statement, a Tesla spokesperson said the “safety of its customers comes first” and “Autopilot significantly increases safety, as [the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has found that it reduces accident rates by 40 percent.” (The conclusion of that 40 percent figure is the .)

“We appreciate the NTSB’s analysis of last year’s tragic accident and we will evaluate their recommendations as we continue to evolve our technology,” the spokesperson said. “We will also continue to be extremely clear with current and potential customers that Autopilot is not a fully self-driving technology and drivers need to remain attentive at all times.”

Brown’s death drew worldwide attention as it was the first known fatal crash to involve a vehicle traveling on its own using semi-automated technology. A preliminary report released earlier this year by the NTSB found that Brown kept his hands on the wheel of his 2015 Model S70D for only 25 seconds of an extended 37-minute period where his car was . The vehicle gave numerous audio and visual warnings before the crash.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk that a later update to Autopilot—improving the system’s ability to differentiate a truck from a sign—“very likely” would’ve prevented the crash.

The NTSB staff said that Brown was knowledgable about the vehicle, but that the Tesla user manual offered sometimes conflicting accounts.

“A driver could have difficulties interpreting which roads it might be appropriate [to use Autopilot],” Ensar Becic, an NTSB human performance investigator, said during the hearing.

The NTSB also found that relying on sensors that determine whether a driver’s hands are on a steering wheel isn’t an effective method of determining whether they’re paying attention.

Above all, the NTSB’s 80-page report illustrated the limitations of tech currently commercially available semi-autonomous cars. The Tesla Model S was not a fully self-driving car, stressed Sumwalt, the NTSB chairman, in a warning call of sorts to consumers.

“It’s a long way from partially automated vehicles to self-driving cars,” he said. “And until we get there somebody still has to drive.”

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
An Autonomous Truck Just Carted Watermelons 1,000 Miles And We Have Some Questions
An Autonomous Truck Just Carted Watermelons 1,000 Miles And We Have Some Questions
One scenario where autonomous driving could ultimately prove useful is in the long-haul trucking industry, where drivers routinely do 10-hour stints with legally required breaks in between. An autonomous truck wouldn’t have to stop to rest. To put this into perspective, a startup named , which develops assisted driving...
Apr 5, 2026
Ford Is Beating Tesla In One Of The Most EV-Saturated Markets In The World
Ford Is Beating Tesla In One Of The Most EV-Saturated Markets In The World
It can be hard to know how to accurately judge Tesla’s sales performance, as for many years there simply weren’t other options in the luxury electric market. Also, until pretty recently, Tesla didn’t sell all that many cars, making the sample size small. More instructive would be to look...
Apr 5, 2026
China's Bet To Do The Dirty Work No One Else Wanted Is Paying Off In The Age Of Electric Cars
China's Bet To Do The Dirty Work No One Else Wanted Is Paying Off In The Age Of Electric Cars
Officials from the United States and South Korea recently met to discuss the auto industry’s electrification — among other things — according to a report from the . The two countries are trying to forge a better partnership in the interest of reaching their , but there’s an elephant...
Apr 5, 2026
Here's The New 2022 BMW i4 EV And The Best Detail
Here's The New 2022 BMW i4 EV And The Best Detail
The automotive world is in a mild tingly genitals state because BMW’s new all-electric car, the i4, was , e. Now, though, we know all the specs, and, even better, we got to see what I think is the car’s best detail, which I think is also a first...
Apr 5, 2026
The Most Annoying Car That Defines This Moment In Time Is This 3-Wheeler That Mines Bitcoin
The Most Annoying Car That Defines This Moment In Time Is This 3-Wheeler That Mines Bitcoin
Now that the idea of going to parties again is becoming a possibility, here in the sandalwood-scented year of 2021 there are three kinds of people you should be terrified of being trapped in a conversation with: me, wild-eyed QAnon types, and people really, really into Bitcoin or Dogecoin...
Apr 5, 2026
It's Time To Get Used To Seeing The Toyota BZ4X Concept
It's Time To Get Used To Seeing The Toyota BZ4X Concept
We at the Shanghai Auto Show, the likely template for what will be a swift move into the all-electric cars for Toyota, who have so far been a bit slow to it. BZ4X’s full U.S. debut came Wednesday, when Toyota showed a car that looked more or less the...
Apr 5, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved