zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Beyond Cars
/
Someone Actually Shot Down A $200 Drone From Amazon With A Patriot Missile
Someone Actually Shot Down A $200 Drone From Amazon With A Patriot Missile-July 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:14:08

U.S. General David Perkins an audience at a military symposium recently that a U.S. ally shot down a $200 drone with a Patriot missile, usually used to take down Iraqi Scuds. He said the drone “did not stand a chance against a Patriot,” according to of his remarks. No shit. Of course it didn’t.

Now, for many people, Perkins’ remarks could be read as funny as hell (I sure as hell chuckled at first) and viewed as an overkill response (I thought so initially) akin to“shooting a mouse with an elephant gun.” Well, after thinking about it and making a few calls, it turns out that such a simple analogy doesn’t consider the complexities that the American ally (whoever it was) faced on the ground.

Thomas Karako, director of the Missile Defense Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), told Foxtrot Alpha that this isn’t the first time a Patriot missile was used to shoot down a drone. The main takeaway, Karako says, is that the growing threat of drones will pose greater threats to alliance air defense systems than what was heard of in the past.

“You can’t really blame the Middle Eastern actor who probably took a shot at this,” he said. “When something pops up on their screen as a radar blip, they may not know that it costs $200 from Amazon. It may just show up as a radar blip. So what this really points to is the lack of sufficiently precise surveillance that informs the air defense mission. Now, if that was an aircraft rather than a drone, an air defense missile may be appropriate. But the difficulty is you don’t always know. It could be a cruise missile, could be a slow-moving aircraft. What this points to is a need for better sensors that know what the threat is.”

To be clear, Patriot missiles aren’t designed to shoot down drones. The MIM-104 Patriot is a (SAM) system, for example, is geared to shoot down cruise missiles and large aircraft. It has an AN/MPQ-53/65 radar set that has an antenna array consisting of “.” More than capable of detecting fast-moving targets like stealth aircraft and cruise missiles, the AN/MPQ-53/65 Radar Set was not conceived to fire at drones, per se. But it’ll get the job done.

That is the main issue. Moreover, while a Patriot may have been justifiably used to hit the drone, it wasn’t the best use of the missile, especially seeing as how each one is 19 feet (19 feet!) long and weighs 1,500 pounds. Also, each unit costs around $2-3 million, so killing drones with Patriots isn’t exactly cost effective longterm.

As an alternative, Karako says there may be “non-kinetic effectors” that could be used to neutralize drone threats. For those who are unfamiliar with non-kinetic vs kinetic, kinetic is the use of bullets or missiles, for example, to take out a threat; non-kinetic is the use of radio-frequency signals () to neutralize a threat. As the explains, it is also known as electric warfare:

Electronic warfare (or EW) is the use of radio-frequency signals to achieve military effects. It can be as gross as an electromagnetic pulse that shuts down every unprotected electronic system over hundreds of square miles, or as limited as a tailored jamming transmission that prevents improvised explosive devices from detonating along a particular road. Either way, EW as it exists today reflects the gradual migration of the military away from traditional explosive methods of waging war, to more subtle, “non-kinetic” kill mechanisms.

Of course, this doesn’t eliminate the need for Patriots. Saudi Arabia has used U.S.-made Patriots to rockets fired by Houthi rebels inside of Yemen over the years. So, you really can’t blame a U.S. ally for popping a drone with a Patriot.

Still, folks may want to snicker at the sight of a huge Patriot taking down a drone. But the need to do so reveals that they are posing a new threat to America’s air defense system that will require a major radar upgrade.

“I think folks are looking at this and their kind of chuckling, but I think that is the wrong conclusion to take away from this,” Karako said. “The better insight here is that we have an air defense surveillance need that is going to require some new capabilities.”

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Beyond Cars
Deadliest Train In America Kills 3 People In 2 Separate Collisions At The Same Crossing
Deadliest Train In America Kills 3 People In 2 Separate Collisions At The Same Crossing
operate between Orlando and Miami and hold the unwelcome distinction of being both the first intra-city high speed rail in the U.S. and the , by far. After three people died at a single grade crossing in two separate incidents last week it seems the feds are finally perking...
Jul 4, 2025
Marshmallow Treats Ended Up On The Royal Air Force's No-Fly List
Marshmallow Treats Ended Up On The Royal Air Force's No-Fly List
Over in the United Kingdom, there’s a certain dessert known as a “teacake” — or, as a British friend kindly informed me, it’s more accurately known as a “Tunnock” in Scotland. Basically, the food in question for this particular story are actually a cookie base topped with marshmallow, coated...
Jul 4, 2025
Aircraft Touch Tips During Blizzard At Japanese Airport
Aircraft Touch Tips During Blizzard At Japanese Airport
As at , its port side wing the starboard vertical stabilizer of bound for Hong Kong. This comes at Tokyo’s Haneda Airport, and . “Our aircraft, which was stationary at the time with no customers nor crew onboard, was struck by a Korean Air A330 which was taxiing past,”...
Jul 4, 2025
2023 Zero DSR/X: The Bike Of The Future, But Not Our Future
2023 Zero DSR/X: The Bike Of The Future, But Not Our Future
The world, in 2023, is cyberpunk. We’ve got the , the , and the that keeps the and the . But in cyberpunk media, people are always riding . Why are we stuck with the same bikes we’ve always had? , it seems, wants to address this grievous wrong....
Jul 4, 2025
String Of Boeing Failures Continues With 737-800 Flight Turning Back With Cracked Cockpit Windshield
String Of Boeing Failures Continues With 737-800 Flight Turning Back With Cracked Cockpit Windshield
In the wake of recent major , including , , and the debacle that was , it isn’t a good time for further failures by the company. that would , an unrelated 737-800 with a cracked windshield, became international news this weekend. The flight took off from Sapporo-New Chitose...
Jul 4, 2025
Crystal Chunks Are Bursting Through The Road In China
Crystal Chunks Are Bursting Through The Road In China
A video of what looks like quartz breaking through the surface of a is making the rounds on . I don’t get over there much, being suspicious of the Chinese over concerns of it spying on its users, as the reports. OK, fine. Actually, I just don’t get the humor...
Jul 4, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved