zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Beyond Cars
/
Syrian Mine Clearance Shows One Of The Worst Moral Quandaries Of War
Syrian Mine Clearance Shows One Of The Worst Moral Quandaries Of War-December 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:14:26

To call the Syrian Civil War "complex" is a vast understatement of our times. It's not only complicated in terms of who's fighting, its complicated in terms of what they're fighting for, and how exactly they're fighting it. Take this video of mine clearance, for example. Mine clearance is great, until it so very much isn't.

It's easy to say "landmines are bad." The Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction, also known as the Ottawa Treaty, also known as the treaty that completely bans the use of landmines, has been signed by 162 countries.

That's a lot of countries, and landmines certainly can be used for evil. But like any weapon of war, they're a tool. They don't care who deploys them, or who they kill.

And the people clearing them often don't care, either.

The video above is taken from the perspective of the Syrian Army, fighting on behalf of Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad, who is known to brutally torture his prisoners before indiscriminately executing them. It shows a Russian-supplied UR-77 mine clearance vehicle, going about its duty of clearing lethal minefields in the city of .

The State Department has obtained 27,000 photographs showing the bodies of Syrian torture victims —

Jobar, a city once venerated as holy by the Syrian Jewish community, has now been widely destroyed, and was one of the cities decimated by Assad's .

So on paper, destroying the mines is great. Landmines are indiscriminate killers, murdering and maiming anyone who dares to get too close, whether soldiers or children. And the Syrian rebels, who have often been lauded as , have littered a city block with mines in an effort to deny the space to Assad's soldiers.

It's not the first time they've done it, either, as the now-devastated city of Homs was with mines as the rebels pulled out.

And littering a city block with landmines, booby traps, and IEDs is heinous, no matter the strategic or tactical value, nor the stated goals of those that deployed them. So it's entirely understandable that even the forces belonging to an unconscionable dictator like Assad would want to remove them.

Yet the way they go about removing the minefield and IEDs is horrific in and of itself. Getting rid of landmines in an urban center is not that simple. To avoid damage to infrastructure, and casualties to people, it's a painstaking and slow process, requiring explosive ordinance demolition teams on foot, and robots when necessary.

It requires precision tools.

The UR-77 Meteorit mine-clearance vehicle is not a precision tool. In fact, using it like this is exactly how to turn what would be a life-saving vehicle, into an incredibly violent murder weapon.

The UR-77's "" system works by launching a rocket, attached to which is a long, thick rope. The rope is filled with explosives in a long line, which detonate outwards. The thinking behind it is that with the line laid across the minefield, it can detonate most enemy explosives with a friendly blast before anyone gets hurt.

Usually tanks are supposed to avoid mines and buried bombs, but somebody, and something, has to…

That's great for clearing mines in an open area. In a city block, it becomes a weapon in and of itself. As notes, the blast generated by the explosive rope 300 feet long and 20 feet wide. That's enormous. Add in all the explosive material that it's designed to destroy, and you have a blast that easily levels a city block, killing or injuring anyone – combatant or non-combatant – unlucky enough to be in the area.

So in this case, like in countless cases of war, there is no winner. The mines might be cleared, but so is the surrounding human life.

When you clear mines like this, there are no heroes.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Beyond Cars
NASA To Kick Off Squid Uprising With Latest SpaceX Payload To The ISS
NASA To Kick Off Squid Uprising With Latest SpaceX Payload To The ISS
The 22nd SpaceX cargo resupply mission is going to be delivered to the International Space Station this month and, among the materials for the various experiments NASA is working on, there will be 128 baby Bobtail Squid that are just the cutest lil’ babies ever. I mean just look...
Dec 26, 2025
GT Racer John Shoffner Is Going To Space With Axiom
GT Racer John Shoffner Is Going To Space With Axiom
There is one single profession cooler than being a race car driver: being an astronaut. In the second half of 2022, though, GT racer John Shoffner is going to have both professions under his belt when he heads into space with Axiom. Shoffner epitomizes the gentleman driver, having put...
Dec 26, 2025
Are We The Bad Guys?
Are We The Bad Guys?
Normally, when a new Major General is sworn in it is a solemn, dignified affair. When Maj. Gen. DeAnna Burt was sworn in to the U.S. Space Force last month at the Vandenberg Air Force Base in California, it involved folks dressed as Stormtroopers. I thought what many of...
Dec 26, 2025
What Do You Want To Know About The 2022 Honda Grom?
What Do You Want To Know About The 2022 Honda Grom?
The Honda Grom is a totally rad little bike to have in your back pocket for daily riding around the city. I I tested last year, and with the visual and mechanical upgrades the bike has received for the 2022 model year sound extremely exciting. As you read this...
Dec 26, 2025
United Tapped A Startup To Build 15 Supersonic Jets That Would Cut Flight Times In Half
United Tapped A Startup To Build 15 Supersonic Jets That Would Cut Flight Times In Half
United Airlines announced a plan to buy 15 supersonic jets from a still-in-testing startup Thursday, returning the hope of supersonic travel to commercial customers 18 years after the last took the skies. We should say upfront that the company that United partnered with, Boom Supersonic, isn’t exactly a household...
Dec 26, 2025
Here's What Happens To A Regular Car Tire Spun Up To 385 MPH
Here's What Happens To A Regular Car Tire Spun Up To 385 MPH
keeping car occupants safe and comfortable for thousands of miles. But what happens when you take a regular car tire far past its limits, far past the top speed of even the fastest production car? We love the team at Garage 54 for their outlandish experiments. Whether they’re or ,...
Dec 26, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved