zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Beyond Cars
/
Syrian Mine Clearance Shows One Of The Worst Moral Quandaries Of War
Syrian Mine Clearance Shows One Of The Worst Moral Quandaries Of War-October 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:14:26

To call the Syrian Civil War "complex" is a vast understatement of our times. It's not only complicated in terms of who's fighting, its complicated in terms of what they're fighting for, and how exactly they're fighting it. Take this video of mine clearance, for example. Mine clearance is great, until it so very much isn't.

It's easy to say "landmines are bad." The Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction, also known as the Ottawa Treaty, also known as the treaty that completely bans the use of landmines, has been signed by 162 countries.

That's a lot of countries, and landmines certainly can be used for evil. But like any weapon of war, they're a tool. They don't care who deploys them, or who they kill.

And the people clearing them often don't care, either.

The video above is taken from the perspective of the Syrian Army, fighting on behalf of Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad, who is known to brutally torture his prisoners before indiscriminately executing them. It shows a Russian-supplied UR-77 mine clearance vehicle, going about its duty of clearing lethal minefields in the city of .

The State Department has obtained 27,000 photographs showing the bodies of Syrian torture victims —

Jobar, a city once venerated as holy by the Syrian Jewish community, has now been widely destroyed, and was one of the cities decimated by Assad's .

So on paper, destroying the mines is great. Landmines are indiscriminate killers, murdering and maiming anyone who dares to get too close, whether soldiers or children. And the Syrian rebels, who have often been lauded as , have littered a city block with mines in an effort to deny the space to Assad's soldiers.

It's not the first time they've done it, either, as the now-devastated city of Homs was with mines as the rebels pulled out.

And littering a city block with landmines, booby traps, and IEDs is heinous, no matter the strategic or tactical value, nor the stated goals of those that deployed them. So it's entirely understandable that even the forces belonging to an unconscionable dictator like Assad would want to remove them.

Yet the way they go about removing the minefield and IEDs is horrific in and of itself. Getting rid of landmines in an urban center is not that simple. To avoid damage to infrastructure, and casualties to people, it's a painstaking and slow process, requiring explosive ordinance demolition teams on foot, and robots when necessary.

It requires precision tools.

The UR-77 Meteorit mine-clearance vehicle is not a precision tool. In fact, using it like this is exactly how to turn what would be a life-saving vehicle, into an incredibly violent murder weapon.

The UR-77's "" system works by launching a rocket, attached to which is a long, thick rope. The rope is filled with explosives in a long line, which detonate outwards. The thinking behind it is that with the line laid across the minefield, it can detonate most enemy explosives with a friendly blast before anyone gets hurt.

Usually tanks are supposed to avoid mines and buried bombs, but somebody, and something, has to…

That's great for clearing mines in an open area. In a city block, it becomes a weapon in and of itself. As notes, the blast generated by the explosive rope 300 feet long and 20 feet wide. That's enormous. Add in all the explosive material that it's designed to destroy, and you have a blast that easily levels a city block, killing or injuring anyone – combatant or non-combatant – unlucky enough to be in the area.

So in this case, like in countless cases of war, there is no winner. The mines might be cleared, but so is the surrounding human life.

When you clear mines like this, there are no heroes.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Beyond Cars
Obama Tightens India Bond As A Mix Of Russian And U.S. Jets Fly Above
Obama Tightens India Bond As A Mix Of Russian And U.S. Jets Fly Above
Yesterday, President Obama was in India for Republic Day, which makes sense since its parade included a C-17 Globemaster III and the P-8 Poseidon, the most advanced maritime patrol and transport aircraft in the world, both imported from the U.S. and flying with Indian flags on their tails. Although the...
Oct 28, 2026
Greek Fighter Jet Crashes In Spain, At Least 10 Reportedly Killed
Greek Fighter Jet Crashes In Spain, At Least 10 Reportedly Killed
A Greek F-16 in Spain as part of a NATO training mission crashed shortly after takeoff, killing at least 10, according to . Thirteen were injured, including six critically injured, the Spanish Ministry of Defense confirmed. It's not immediately clear what caused the crash at Los Llanos airbase, according to...
Oct 28, 2026
Watch The Rescue Of A Pilot Who Ditched At Sea Using A Plane Parachute
Watch The Rescue Of A Pilot Who Ditched At Sea Using A Plane Parachute
In what seems like a perfectly coordinated long-range rescue, this Cirrus SR-22 pilot activated the after figuring out the plane would not have enough fuel to make it to Hawaii. What happens next is both intense and incredible, as the pilot goes from a long fall, to narrowly escaping their...
Oct 28, 2026
Watch The F-35 Execute Its First Flyover For The NFL Pro Bowl Game
Watch The F-35 Execute Its First Flyover For The NFL Pro Bowl Game
A positive milestone for the F-35 program came Sunday as a quartet of the $120M jets flew from their nest at Luke AFB to University of Phoenix stadium after a air-to-air training sortie to execute a four ship for the NFL Pro Bowl. Although the fingertip formation was nice, the...
Oct 28, 2026
This Is An Official Portrait Of Astronaut Leland D. Melvin
This Is An Official Portrait Of Astronaut Leland D. Melvin
Astronaut worked for NASA for 25 years, heading the Vehicle Health Monitoring team for the X-33 space shuttle successor, leading NASA's office for education and outreach program in the 2010s, and logging over 565 hours in space. Also, he likes dogs. The above is an official NASA portrait taken of...
Oct 28, 2026
Serious Props! Check Out The Massive Screws On The Burke Class Destroyer
Serious Props! Check Out The Massive Screws On The Burke Class Destroyer
Ship design is as much a study in proportions as anything else, but sometimes the most ridiculous elements lay out of view, below the waterline. Case in point: the gargantuan brass screws on the US Navy's Arleigh Burke Class . It's hard to get any real sense of scale with...
Oct 28, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved