zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Tesla Driver In Marsh Crash Now Says It Was His Fault And Not Autopilot's
Tesla Driver In Marsh Crash Now Says It Was His Fault And Not Autopilot's-April 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:39

Tesla’s semi-autonomous Autopilot feature caught flak on Sunday, as it appeared a driver had for causing his car to suddenly accelerate, head off a road, and roll over into a marsh. On Monday, his story changed. It wasn’t Autopilot’s fault, he said, it was his own.

The incident began on Sunday, when the Kandiyohi County Sheriff’s Office in Minneapolis released a statement that said a 2016 Tesla Model S ended up on its roof as a result of the incident, leaving all five occupants in the car with minor injuries.

“Clark stated that when he engaged the auto pilot (sic) feature that the vehicle suddenly accelerated causing the car to leave the roadway and overturn,” the sheriff’s office said in a press release. “Clark and his four adult passengers all sustained minor injuries.”

The police report said the Tesla was driving toward an intersection that dead-ended, requiring him to go right or left. The driver, 58-year-old David Clark, chose neither.

Tesla said it has “no reason to believe that Autopilot ... worked other than as designed.” The automaker reiterated the need for drivers to remain fully alert and watch the road, even if Autopilot is engaged.

The whole thing got weird on Monday, when Clark backtracked and said his initial statement wasn’t accurate. In an email to a sheriff’s deputy that was distributed by Tesla, Clark said he was “pretty shook up at the time when you and I spoke but I did not intend to put the blame Tesla or the auto pilot system as I am aware that I need to be in control of the vehicle regardless if the auto pilot system is engaged or not.”

“I have had a chance to discuss with passengers and try to replay the sequence of events leading up to the accident,” Clark wrote, adding:

To the best of my recollection I had engaged the autopilot system but then I had disengaged it by stepping on accelerator. I then remember looking up and seeing the sharp left turn which I was accelerating into. I believe we started to make the turn but then felt the car give way and lose its footing like we hit loose gravel. That was the feeling that I was trying to describe to you that I had lost control of the vehicle.

The next thing I know tall grass is whipping past the windshield and we were traveling at an odd angle in the ditch and then flipped over the right side and ended up on the roof.

I am truly thankful for the safety features that Tesla had put into this car that saved all 5 of us from serious injury.

A sheriff’s deputy responded:

I understand the misunderstanding about our conversation the day of the accident. When we have accidents with injuries it is our responsibility to provide the information regarding details to the press outlets.

With the information we talked about and how you explained them to me, I was in the understanding that the vehicle was in autopilot based on how you explained it. Therefore, that’s how it was reported.

It’s a strange situation. Initially, the sheriff’s office issued a statement that didn’t attribute the statement that blamed Autopilot for the crash to anyone, giving the impression that an investigation revealed that to be the case. Tesla said it didn’t believe Autopilot was at fault, and the statement was then adjusted to attribute the Autopilot comment to Clark. Now, Clark says he had it wrong.

In the past, Tesla has released logs in response to crashes that have been attributed to a sudden acceleration by Autopilot. Asked for the data logs from Clark’s vehicle for the incident, the automaker pointed Jalopnik to its original statement, which said that’s it’s working on an internal investigation of the accident. The sheriff’s office didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

Crashes are jarring, especially rollovers, and it wouldn’t necessarily be surprising if Clark spoke too soon without gathering a full recollection of what transpired. But the situation’s still an odd one.

Autopilot has been scrutinized by regulators, following a fatal crash that left a Tesla owner dead last year. Earlier this year, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration cleared Autopilot in the crash and said there was no evidence of a defect.

A class-action lawsuit filed in April accuses Tesla of making owners “beta-testers” for Autopilot and renders their vehicles “dangerous.” The case remains pending.

Taking Clark at his word, it’s another testament to while using semi-automated features in a car.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
I Rode All the E-Scooters. Most of Them Are Awful Except Two
I Rode All the E-Scooters. Most of Them Are Awful Except Two
One weekend morning toward the end of 2017, I woke up at home in Venice, CA and took a walk, only to see something entirely new: people on electric scooters. And I mean lots of people on electric scooters. Literally overnight, a new company called Bird, founded just two miles...
Apr 5, 2026
Startup Aurora Partners With FCA to Develop Autonomous Commercial Vehicles
Startup Aurora Partners With FCA to Develop Autonomous Commercial Vehicles
Earlier this year, , a self-driving startup, raised over from investors. It looks like the company is still doing okay, as Aurora announced yesterday that they’ll be partnering with Fiat Chrysler to start developing autonomous platforms for their commercial vehicles. More from : Over the last two years, this...
Apr 5, 2026
Tesla Driver Imitates Regulators by Appearing to Fall Asleep With Autopilot On
Tesla Driver Imitates Regulators by Appearing to Fall Asleep With Autopilot On
We’ve , and you better believe we’re going to see a hell of a lot more of it. According to and an interview with the person who shot the footage, a Tesla driver fell asleep at the wheel of the car while it was moving on a federal interstate for...
Apr 5, 2026
Good Gravy: AMG Is Getting 416 Horsepower Out of Just a 2.0-Liter Turbo Four
Good Gravy: AMG Is Getting 416 Horsepower Out of Just a 2.0-Liter Turbo Four
In every way I’ve seen so far, Mercedes-Benz has really stepped it up with the new and its coupe-ier sibling the CLA. What was once a penalty box designed solely to get millennials into dealerships and then trap them into leasing a more expensive SUV is now far nicer...
Apr 5, 2026
GM's Cruise Self-Driving Prototypes Are Riddled With Technical Glitches, Safety Concerns: Report
GM's Cruise Self-Driving Prototypes Are Riddled With Technical Glitches, Safety Concerns: Report
Last time we checked in on ’ autonomous-vehicle arm, it was worth a , because the dream of a self-driving world is one people are willing to dump loads of cash into, or not. That $19 billion,though, has apparently gotten Cruise a whole lot of on-road glitches and safety...
Apr 5, 2026
Reddittor Wonders: Should I Just Give Elon My Money?
Reddittor Wonders: Should I Just Give Elon My Money?
I know there’s sort of a stereotype about a certain sort of painfully obsessed Tesla fan/Elon Musk worshipper that is, likely, an unfair categorization of most Tesla fans. But then you see something like , and you remember that, oh yeah, sometimes stereotypes do come from somewhere. The OP...
Apr 5, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved