zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
The Best And Worst Cars I've Driven This Year
The Best And Worst Cars I've Driven This Year-February 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:10

In the past, the coveted Travis Okulski Award For Best Car I've Driven This Year would go to the only car I drove: My Miata.

But in the last year since I've joined the glitterati world that is automotive journalism, I've been lucky to drive a veritable cornucopia of various and sundry excellent cars. What did I love and what did I loathe?

Let's find out together, shall we?

Now, I should say that going later in the lineup has made it difficult for me. Like and , I've driven the FR-S, Morgan Three Wheeler, Citroen SM, and Porsche Boxster, and I really loved them. But alas, I don't want to repeat what has already been said.

End-of-year awards tend to be impersonal and predictable, so we've left it open to our contributors

I was lucky enough in my first year of automotive journalism to spend time with many great cars. I've also had the misfortune of driving some upsetting cars that could be so much better.

Ok, without further ado, dig in for my picks.

Best: 2012 Cadillac CTS-V Wagon

How can this car not make the list? It's a station wagon with 556 horsepower. Who cares that it got 16 MPG on the highway? It can chirp the tires in first, second, and third. It's faster than most anything I drove this year AND can haul anything you throw at it.

Especially ass.

Yet it's refined. Magnetic ride makes it supremely comfortable. It was also great around corners. The interior was awash in piano black accents and Alcantara as far as the eye could see. it was comfortable, beautifully built and really freaking fast. I also (which shares an engine with the CTS-V), but the V is nicer inside and out, and you can see out of it. That's why you aren't seeing the ZL1 here.

In the past, the large American V8 was considered a symbol of freedom and the open road. But today,

If I had the money, I'd have one in a heartbeat. A heartbeat. Fantastic.

Best: 2013 Porsche Panamera GTS

I happen to be in a very small minority: I'm one of seven people that have liked the design of the Panamera since it was released. The other six people that like it designed the Panamera.

If you don't like the way it looks, don't worry, cause you'll love the way it drives. In terms of driving dynamics, the GTS is in a class of its own. It . It's a far more capable car than pretty much everything in its class and is easily the best version of the Panamera.

Epic car.

Best: 2014 Audi R8

In back to back weeks, I got to drive the and the . I scored the Porsche higher in the review, but my thoughts kept coming back to the R8.

For decades, Audi was synonymous with rally excellence. In the 2000s, Audi turned its focus to…

First, there were the looks. This thing is all robot futuristic and I seriously love it. But experiencing the car in all conditions is what sold me.

It's a supercar. It shouldn't be this good on mountain passes covered with snow and ice. It shouldn't feel like an A3 around town. It shouldn't be easy to see out of. But it is. It's all of these things. At least for me, the 911 has been unseated.

Best: 2012 Fiat 500 Abarth

Per dollar, the Abarth is the best sounding car you can buy. It's like a mini Italian supercar, all angry and growly. I love the way it looks and the way it drives. My only contention are the seats that make you feel like you're sitting on the toilet waiting to take a nice dump. But I can forgive it for that, because it's such a quirky fun little car. I was smitten from the moment I saw it.

It's also the only car on my best car list that I could theoretically afford outside of my dreams. Maybe I should buy one.

Worst: 2012 Toyota Prius C

I totally get the point of the Prius C. It's the ultimate expression of an economy car and perfect in towns and cities.

It's also sooooooo boring. If you're going to make a small city car, it should be fun and engaging to drive. It should be eager and zippy. That's what the Mazda2 is, it's a little puppy that wants to romp all day. "Come on, let's go for a run! I wanna catch that stick! Throw me a frisbee!"

The Prius C . "I'm tirrrrreeeeedddddd."

Worst: 2012 Infiniti G37S

I guess the G37 was actually my most disappointing car of the year, because it technically isn't a bad car. It was just not memorable. It was actually forgettable enough that I forgot to take a picture of it.

I found the interior lackluster, and the color combo on my particular car was atrociously bad: White with a light grey interior. It just didn't have any character.

The one part of the car that was memorable was the gearbox, and not in a good way. It possibly had the vaguest clutch and shifter I've ever used. Gear changes were rubbery and indirect and the clutch had about zero feel. It was nearly impossible to be smooth at all.

Thankfully there's a new one for 2014, cause this one needs to go away.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
Apparently Some Car Dealers Think It's OK To Detain Customers Against Their Will
Apparently Some Car Dealers Think It's OK To Detain Customers Against Their Will
You would think that by 2021 car dealers would have wised up and fixed the broken mess that is car shopping. Many stores have adapted, but some are still relying on classic “stealership” tricks. One of the most egregious is preventing someone from leaving the showroom. Imagine going to...
Feb 27, 2026
At $9,900, Could You Get Stoked About This 1995 Callaway Camaro 383 Stroker?
At $9,900, Could You Get Stoked About This 1995 Callaway Camaro 383 Stroker?
Today’s Callaway Camaro represents the tuner’s attempt at an à la carte car build. Let’s see if the price tag proves to be a chef’s special. How would you categorize the Italian marque Maserati? Is it a high-end sports car maker akin to Ferrari and Lamborghini? Or is it...
Feb 27, 2026
At $1,600, Would You Give This 1989 Chrysler TC By Maserati The TLC It Needs?
At $1,600, Would You Give This 1989 Chrysler TC By Maserati The TLC It Needs?
Today’s Chrysler is probably the cheapest running car in America wearing the Maserati nameplate. It’s pretty worn, so let’s see if it’s cheap enough. There are two ways to ensure a vehicle’s rarity. One is for the manufacturer to restrict production far below demand. The other is for that...
Feb 27, 2026
The Audi E-Tron And Porsche Taycan Only Help Tesla
The Audi E-Tron And Porsche Taycan Only Help Tesla
The is finally here, and it’s going to kick off a friendly rivalry with its distant stablemate, the . But I can’t stop thinking that the real winner in all this isn’t Volkswagen Group. It’s . And it’s less about the Model S suddenly becoming a less-formidable competitor —...
Feb 27, 2026
At $39,500, Would You Drop The Hammer On This 1992 Mercedes-Benz 500E?
At $39,500, Would You Drop The Hammer On This 1992 Mercedes-Benz 500E?
Today’s 500E has two parents — Mercedes-Benz and Porsche — who jointly engineered and built this special model. Let’s see if this rare German hot rod’s price makes you seriously consider an adoption. I noticed a prevalent theme while perusing the comments on yesterday’s . That was begrudging respect...
Feb 27, 2026
Someone Spent $97,000 On This Delightful 1980 Ford F-250
Someone Spent $97,000 On This Delightful 1980 Ford F-250
As you all know, I love spending inordinate amounts of time . I also look at Bring a Trailer just to see what’s out there. Usually, the auctions are for yet another boring overpriced classic, but this minty is a real gem. Honestly, I was considering dropping the platform...
Feb 27, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved