zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
The Real Reason Google's Self-Driving Car Doesn't Have Controls
The Real Reason Google's Self-Driving Car Doesn't Have Controls-April 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:43

The most dangerous thing about autonomous cars isn't snow or rain or Neo hacking the mainframe. It's the meat bag behind the wheel. Specifically, it's the "handoff" from car to driver, and that's why nixed the steering wheel, brake, and accelerator on its self-driving prototype.

The when introducing Google's third generation autonomous car with the line that, "Google's brightest minds now say they can't make that handoff work anytime soon."

Here's the problem: You're riding in your self-driving car, reading emails, checking tweets, admiring the latest Kate Upton spread when – for whatever reason – the car encounters a problem. It needs you to take over. Like, immediately.

That's where Google has a problem. It hasn't figured out how to manage the transition from piloted mode to manual mode in a safe, controlled fashion. And it's something that leaders in the autonomous driving movement have been trying to solve, with no solution in sight.

, the late Stanford University professor, has talked about it in the past.

"People worry about the wrong thing when it comes to the safety of autonomous cars," . "There are going to be times where the driver has to take over. And that turns out to be by far the most dangerous and totally understudied issue."

Take a driver that's been zoning out for the past 45 minutes and thrusting them into traffic spells disaster. They're unfocused, they're distracted, – hell, they could be shitfaced – and they're complete unaware of the environment they're forced to navigate.

Consumer research firm KPMG agrees. In its , it identifies this transition from piloted to manual mode as the dominant snag in the program:

We believe the hand-off of control between self-driving vehicles and their human passengers may present the greatest challenge. If self-driving becomes a reality and those who are incapable of assuming control of the vehicle (whether because they are asleep, drunk, unlicensed or impaired in some way), what exactly will happen? Would passengers and their vehicles be stranded?

Obviously, some kind of advanced warning system will be key in the handoff from car to driver, but Google has nixed this ability altogether with its purpose-built autonomous car. Without any controls for the driver, they've taken the "easy" way out. Add in the fact that speeds are limited to 25 MPH – the national speed limit for both residential areas and school zones – and it becomes even more apparent that Google can't trust the driver to take control. A 25 MPH impact has less than half the kinetic energy as a 35 MPH crash, let alone something approaching freeway speeds.

Both MIT and research firm IHS have called out this issue before.

that "at precisely the time when the automation needs assistance, the operator could not provide it and may actually have made the situation worse."

IHS echoes that sentiment in , saying, "One identified standard need is how to hand back the control from self-driving mode to human driving mode. Clear procedures or standards for this process will be needed in a few years and preferably sooner."

If any of this sounds vaguely familiar to plane buffs, it should. It's a problem the FAA has been studying for nearly a decade. The agency that identified an over reliance on auto pilot systems and required pilots to manually fly planes to keep their skills intact.

That's what's required of an elite cadre of professionals that carry hundreds of souls onboard – not your average driver that hasn't been tested since they snagged their license at 16 under woefully inadequate testing procedures.

Pilots is one thing. Drivers engrossed in their Facebook feed is another. That's where the real problem lies and why Google made the decision to remove the most basic driver controls. It's a step backwards for the autonomous driving movement. They've hobbled functionality in the pursuit of perfection, and until Google figures that out, we'll still be years away from an autonomous car for the masses.

But at least they remembered the cupholders.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
BMW's Last V12s Are Going Out With A Bang
BMW's Last V12s Are Going Out With A Bang
You can still buy a car with a BMW V12, even now, though that fact , given that a V12's very existence is against the prevailing winds of our time. BMW’s V12s now, however, have an end date. BMW uses the V12 in its flagship 7 Series, the M...
Apr 5, 2026
Winnebago Is Prepping Itself For The Electric Future
Winnebago Is Prepping Itself For The Electric Future
Winnebago, yes that Winnebago, is jumping onboard the electric vehicle bandwagon in a big way. This week at the RV Super Show in Tampa, Fla. the company unveiled the e-RV, what it is calling the first all-electric zero emission motorhome concept. You can look at it and instantly tell...
Apr 5, 2026
Ford Is Making Something To Monitor Your Car Remotely With A Camera
Ford Is Making Something To Monitor Your Car Remotely With A Camera
Ford and ADT, the home security company, are working jointly on something called Canopy, that will eventually let you monitor your car remotely, something I’m told Ring does for homes. The concept, as shown in the video below, is pretty straightforward, if also completely ridiculous, at least in the...
Apr 5, 2026
Expert Sheds Light On Why Some Ford Mach-Es Are Freaking Out After Being Hooned
Expert Sheds Light On Why Some Ford Mach-Es Are Freaking Out After Being Hooned
The should be able to put its tires through quite a bit of agony thanks to its upwards of 600 lb-ft of torque. That’s especially true if you deactivate traction control and set about spinning ruts into the earth. It turns out, though, that some Mach-Es sort of lose...
Apr 5, 2026
EV Hubs Are Shell's Idea Of The Future Of Refuelling
EV Hubs Are Shell's Idea Of The Future Of Refuelling
The charging situation for EV drivers on the go is currently a bit tenuous. For the most part, if you drive an electric car, you’re doing the lion’s share of your charging at home or at work — or both — probably on a slower Level 2 charger. Shell...
Apr 5, 2026
Respected Automated Driving Expert Gives Tesla FSD Beta An
Respected Automated Driving Expert Gives Tesla FSD Beta An "F"
has been working with computers since way way back in the day (dude helped port in 1979, for example) and has been involved with automated vehicle development since 2007, , and then joining Google’s team (that later became Waymo) in 2010. Templeton has been in the driving automation space...
Apr 5, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved