zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
The seven kinds of crappy car reviews
The seven kinds of crappy car reviews-March 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:14

All auto writers, even those of us here at Jalopnik, have sometimes been guilty of turning out crap car reviews. And when a review fails, it's likely because it falls into one of these seven, fail-encrusted categories.

Who has time to enjoy the fine wines and aged steaks that cap off a test-drive junket? These days, many writers spend the evening after a drive in their hotel room unpacking dense press releases, deciphering scribbled quotes from engineers and shotgunning details into Wordpress like a Western Union cable operator during the earthquake of 1906. All in an attempt to beat the guy in the next room to the "save" button. Brain dumps are no fun to write, they usually contain few real insights, and the best a reader can hope for is more verbs than adjectives and enough pretty photos to take the edge off.

The poor kid. That cranky old writer came back with 5,000 words on polar moment of inertia, camber thrust, slip angle ratios and lateral force variation, and couldn't be bothered explaining what the hell any of it means. "Oh, they'll get it," he bellows at the kid, who doesn't get paid enough to deal with this asshole. The kid knows the copy's bullshit, but the big bully's not having it. Who pays the price? The reader, because we're left with nothing worth reading.

The level of detail on these reviews is so excruciating, the pages so dense with terms and coinages and metaphors, that by the time you're nearing the vicinity of judgment on the car's cargo volume — at around, say, word 1,559 — it's too late because you've already climbed up on a wooden chair and looped your tie around a hot water pipe.

It takes a real pro like Jeremy Clarkson to launch a car review with an anecdote about a chutney spoon, then keep us engaged as he grouses about the Cotswolds, gets a haircut and drops a reference to Sir Robert Walpole –- before getting anywhere near an actual car. Most amateur attempts at this kind of writing fall flatter than one of Sir Geoffrey Howe's pocket squares.

There's no sin in calling on the great masters to make a point, just make sure it's precise, or you might wind up like the pompous windbag at the cocktail party who's trying to put his tweed sportcoat on over the lamp that's sticking out of his ass. "Be not afraid of greatness," Shakespeare once said, "Some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them. Like this 1597 Datsun."

It starts by putting the reader right into the action. "There I was, caroming athwart a dewy ribbon of Spanish pavement at 9/10ths, the luscious scent of orange blossoms filling the German sedan's cockpit with the early spring of Basque country, the honey'd aroma awakening my senses for the long, right-handed, on-camber sweeper I was about to skim like Danish butter across my Asian grandmother's vintage Griswold frypan ..." Seriously. Cut. It. Out.

Sure, we're fascinated with how it's possible to shave milliseconds off one's lap time in a Chrysler 300 by not being a careerist hack with an upside-down Detroit mortgage and two kids to support. But being an elitist whose cause célèbre is sniffing out elitism in others doesn't make a review more interesting, it makes it tedious garbage.

Now here's the fun part. Find for us an example for each and show your work in the comments below. Let's see who can collect them all!

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
At $14,999, Is This 1999 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am A Smokin' Good Deal?
At $14,999, Is This 1999 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am A Smokin' Good Deal?
Today’s Trans Am may not turn you into either Burt Reynolds (R.I.P.) or Sally Field, but that doesn’t mean it won’t elicit fond memories of Smokey and the Bandit. Let’s see if this Firebird’s price is just as memorable. I’ve always had a disconnect with Audi naming its TT...
Mar 21, 2026
Do Those Paint Upcharges Really Cost The Automaker That Much More?
Do Those Paint Upcharges Really Cost The Automaker That Much More?
As Jalopnik’s resident car-buying expert and a professional car shopper, I get emails. Lots of emails. I’ve picked a few of your questions and will try to help out. This week we are discussing paint upcharges from the factory and whether it’s more eco-friendly to keep your current car...
Mar 21, 2026
Jalopnik Editors Review The New Polestar 1 And Polestar 2
Jalopnik Editors Review The New Polestar 1 And Polestar 2
Polestar has worked very hard to make the new EV available to reviewers in different cities across the country (despite the ). The result is that a few of our editors were able to test drive it. Rory, Norman and Justin have all driven the hybrid as well, and here’s...
Mar 21, 2026
At $6,900, Is This 2005 Audi TT 3.2 Quattro S-Line Worth A Look?
At $6,900, Is This 2005 Audi TT 3.2 Quattro S-Line Worth A Look?
Today’s Audi TT looks good. And, with its VR6 engine and DSG gearbox, it should have the goods to back up those looks. Let’s find out if its price tag is in full support as well. Quite a few of you discounted any consideration of yesterday’s simply because of...
Mar 21, 2026
Oh My God Look At This Hummer
Oh My God Look At This Hummer
Look, we at Jalopnik . But has so much going on that my brain’s misfiring just trying to comprehend it. With that said, I’m going to try to get through a description of this...vehicle. What you’re experiencing here is apparently a 2003 Hummer H2 extensively modified by AIM Industries...
Mar 21, 2026
The Navy Is Sending Me To Hawaii! What Car Should I Buy?
The Navy Is Sending Me To Hawaii! What Car Should I Buy?
Alan is a Navy officer who will soon be stationed in Hawaii. His Highlander will be making the journey to the new post, but he is looking to supplement the family hauler with something a bit more fun. What car should he buy? (Welcome back to ? Where we...
Mar 21, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved