zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Beyond Cars
/
The Truth About Europe Paying Its ‘Fair Share’ For NATO
The Truth About Europe Paying Its ‘Fair Share’ For NATO-November 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:14:08

At a time when Russia is against Europe, that is President Donald Trump’s first month in office and not backing down in , NATO seems to be needed more than it has since the end of the Cold War. Though the tone from the White House suggests Europe is a deadbeat partner not paying its fair share of the rent, the reality of the situation is a lot more nuanced.

In short: Europe may be paying its fair share in ways Washington doesn’t appreciate. That may need to change as we contemplate the defense needs of the region in 2017 and beyond.

Trump has lamented that NATO is “” and that our European allies need to pay their “fair share” financially. His newly appointed Defense Secretary James Mattis said last week that alliance members must pay at least two percent of their GDPs on defense or face “” military support from Washington. So far, only five of the 28 alliance members spend two percent or more of their GDP on defense. To be fair, the two percent benchmark was agreed upon by NATO countries themselves in 2006.

First, a few facts on spending. As noted last year, America pays 22 percent to cover NATO directly as an organization, with Europe covering the rest of the costs. That is far less than the “lion’s share” Trump talks about. Though when he mentions indirect contributions, he has a point, as The Post reported:

“The volume of the US defense expenditure effectively represents 73 per cent of the defense spending of the Alliance as a whole,” . “This does not mean that the United States covers 73 per cent of the costs involved in the operational running of NATO as an organization, including its headquarters in Brussels and its subordinate military commands, but it does mean that there is an over-reliance by the Alliance as a whole on the United States for the provision of essential capabilities, including for instance, in regard to intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance; air-to-air refueling; ballistic missile defense; and airborne electronic warfare.”

Now, I agree that Europe could do a much better job in supporting NATO operations. For example, Belgium sent and 155 people to Operation Inherent Resolve in Iraq. Many other NATO members have similar contributions that could be improved upon the military front.

That said, national defense doesn’t always amount to the number of guns, tanks, fighter jets and troops a nation is ready to deploy. Another reality we have to consider is that America is the overwhelming contributor to NATO’s coffers because its military objectives are far larger than, say, Estonia or Slovakia or even France. Context matters.

Here’s a few points to consider when we ask Europe to pay its “fair share”, and what that can and does look like.

Hundreds of thousands of refugees have migrated to Europe over the past five years, most of them coming from Syria since the beginning of its civil war in 2011. In 2015 alone, Germany took in . Other European countries have taken on the challenge of welcoming refugees that enter Europe by the thousands each day.

America, , has admitted more than 10,000. While plenty of research exists that shows refugees negatively affected the economies of the countries that host them, it still costs substantial sums to integrate this population. Helping refugees find employment, learn the host country language, and making them feel they are part of their adoptive nation’s society should all count as national security. Trump has complained that Syrian refugees pose a major national security risk to America. Why, then, can we not consider that Europe integrating them into society is one way to counter terrorist organizations’ propaganda toward them?

Also, what would the consequence be of having thousands of people in Berlin or Paris without a good-paying job? For example, a in 2016 found that migrants committed or tried to commit more than 69,000 crimes in Germany during the first quarter of last year; most of the crimes were theft or forgery related. Making sure that people who enter Europe have jobs so that they do not resort to a life of crime is a form of security and could be argued as an anti-terrorism measure.

Most Americans can’t imagine the challenges Europe has with the influx of refugees. Because of the oceans that insulate the U.S. from most of the world, the migrant crisis has little impact on us so far. Europe is picking up the heavy lifting of hosting refugees, and the continent must constantly fight any propaganda suggesting that ISIS or Al-Qaeda care more about them than their new hosts.

One reason why most of Europe may not pay two percent of its GDP for defense is because its global objectives aren’t as robust and far-reaching. America has in more than 70 countries, making it the most global military on the planet. In comparison, France, Britain and Russia have .

NATO is primarily financed by the U.S., but Americans almost never go into combat alone. America’s operations in Afghanistan, for example, includes from partner countries. A middle ground could be European nations sending more of its troops to combat missions that help U.S. objectives. This may not be as much a question of military spending as it is of deployment.

We also have to consider how Europe supports its soldiers. As Peter Layton explains in , Europe pays for defense in ways we may not have considered:

America’s defense budget also allows for spending on unrelated items. For instance, medical spending nearly 10 percent of the Department of Defense budget. Other nations pay for family and ex-service personnel medical care as part of national health systems—it is not a defense impost.

Additionally, the items within various defense budgets varies considerably. Perhaps 10 percent should be added to allies’ defense totals to compensate for this difference? Varying accounting approaches allow many ways to game a 2 percent benchmark, and it has already .

The bottom line is that Europe could certainly be more proactive in contributing to NATO’s finances and military missions, but it is not nearly the freeloader the Trump administration suggests it is. A new way of looking at what European NATO members contribute, how it supports its military and how they can help Washington’s long term objectives may fill the economic gap Trump—and prior administrations—complain about.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Beyond Cars
"Sorry About Your Field, Comrade"
A photo from 2007 showing a cosmonaut enjoying a "relaxing afternoon" in a field next to his Soyuz capsule after missing his planned landing spot by 43 miles. Think you can come up with a better caption? [via ] ...
Nov 3, 2026
Richard Branson's Spaceport Is Actually Being Built
Richard Branson's Spaceport Is Actually Being Built
Later today, flamboyant British multi-millionaire Richard Branson will commemorate the completion of the main runway of , near the town of Las Cruces, New Mexico, where the project is based. Here's a look before Branson's big bash. , which could carry paying customers into suborbital space by early 2012, had...
Nov 3, 2026
These Are The Blueprints For The Millennium Falcon
These Are The Blueprints For The Millennium Falcon
Not a single Bothan died to get us . Take that Leia. Also, please note that Han lied. Those hidden smuggler compartments? They are totally on the blueprints. OK, sorry, back to the car geekery. ...
Nov 3, 2026
Ridin' That Train, High On Refined Petroleum
Ridin' That Train, High On Refined Petroleum
I've always been told not to worry because it's not the size of a rocket that matters. Then I saw this and realized that yes, yes it is what matters. More on my own inadequacy below. This is the TMA-01M spacecraft rolled out by train to the launch pad at...
Nov 3, 2026
NASA Wants A “100-Year Starship”
NASA Wants A “100-Year Starship”
It may sound like science fiction, but after a loose-lipped scientist revealed a /DARPA program to colonize other planets, NASA has confirmed. Some day, your great grandchildren might be driving cars on Mars. "The human space program is now really aimed at settling other worlds," the director of 's Ames...
Nov 3, 2026
"As A Kid This Was The Only Van We Wanted To Ride In"
Commenter explaining how the (pictured) 1983 Excella "Astrovan" is the transportation he coveted when he was younger. We'll take the shuttle too. Photo Credit: Photo by Eliot J. Schechter/Getty Images ...
Nov 3, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved