zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
This Easy Trick Can Help Weed Out Low-Ballers When Selling a Used Car
This Easy Trick Can Help Weed Out Low-Ballers When Selling a Used Car-August 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:09:17

Image for article titled This Easy Trick Can Help Weed Out Low-Ballers When Selling a Used Car

Selling your used car privately can be more lucrative than trading it in at a dealership. , and there’s nothing worse than who want to offer you a case of beer and several grand less than your asking price. I think I’ve come up with a method to weed out these tire-kickers so you can focus on more serious buyers.

I work with a lot of customers who, due to a variety of reasons, would prefer to sell their car privately rather than trade it in at a dealership. The tip that I give the most often is very similar to one I use for maximizing trade-in value. The key is to get some bids ahead of time, so you have actual offers to compare. When evaluating what your car is worth, there are resources like Kelly Blue Book and Edmunds to give you a range of values based on your vehicle’s age, miles, and equipment. However, these “book values” are a bit theoretical because they aren’t actual offers. The old saying is true: Your car is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it.

This is where online retailers like , and come in. In many cases, these retailers will give you an actual offer on your car without having to leave your house — all you have to do is go to those respective websites and plug in the relevant information. Those online offers can give you a sense of what your asking price should be when you list your car privately, and you can even use the top offer to set a floor for what you’re willing to accept from a private buyer.

Last year, my wife and I inherited my late-father-in-law’s 2011 Buick Lacrosse with about 75,000 miles. We had a lot of things to manage with the estate, and selling the car on top of all that was not something I was looking forward to. I didn’t want to just sell it to a dealer, knowing that I would be leaving money on the table. Luckily, one of my father-in-law’s neighbors had a family member who needed a car, and he reached out to me.

Of course, the first question was “What do you want for it?” I had the offers from Carvana, Vroom, and Carmax ready at hand, which made the price negotiation so much easier. I sent him a text with a screenshot of the highest bid, which was about $6,800, and told him I would like to get $7,500. He countered with $7,000; we had a deal, and I was happy to see a good car go to a local family.

I was fortunate that I didn’t have to deal with calling and texting with low offers, just to see if they could pick up a bargain. Even if you do decide to advertise your used car on one of these community sites, having firm offers on hand from an online car retailer will allow you to filter out conversations with buyers who aren’t serious. Keep in mind, these online offers are typically only valid for about a week, and while your car’s value isn’t likely to dramatically change within a handful of days, an outdated Carvana, Vroom or Carmax offer may no longer be a valid benchmark for a car that has been listed for sale for several months.

A methodology that I haven’t tested, but that might work for you, would be to post the highest e-retailer bid as a photo on your ad with an upfront disclaimer like, “The highest bid I’ve been offered on this car is X. Only contact me if you have a more competitive offer.”

Of course, if you’re selling something that is really old, or a specialty car where finding comparable prices is difficult, honing in on the right price will be more challenging. But if you are selling something relatively new, in the $10,000-and-up range, having these offers on hand before you advertise is a good place to start.

More on selling cars from G/O Media’s partner:

Jalopnik is not involved in creating these articles but may receive a commission from purchases through its content.

Tom McParland is a contributing writer for Jalopnik and runs . He takes the hassle out of buying or leasing a car. Got a car buying question? Send it to [email protected]

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
The 2019 Audi E-Tron Makes a Strong Case for Choosing Charge Speed Over Range
The 2019 Audi E-Tron Makes a Strong Case for Choosing Charge Speed Over Range
It’s 2019 and the electric luxury car scene is finally starting to grow and diversify. The —Audi’s first fully electric mass-production vehicle—is the latest competitor to step in, offering the German automaker’s take on a plush and practical EV. Audi’s first effort here is solid, especially when it comes...
Aug 27, 2026
Why Ostensibly Boring Cars Like This $2,700 Ford LTD Are the Ultimate Bargains
Why Ostensibly Boring Cars Like This $2,700 Ford LTD Are the Ultimate Bargains
I’ve been surfing Craigslist pretty much nonstop over the past decade, and in that time, there’s been one group of vehicles that has tempted me more than any other: “boring cars” in beautiful condition. Vehicles like the spotless, affordable you see above. I don’t know what to think about...
Aug 27, 2026
At $8,500, Is This LT1-Powered 1993 Chevy S10 a Pickup With Pick Up That You Might Pick Up?
At $8,500, Is This LT1-Powered 1993 Chevy S10 a Pickup With Pick Up That You Might Pick Up?
Small pickups like today’s S10 aren’t crowding new car dealer lots like they once did. This one comes with Corvette power so it might draw a crowd on its own accord. That is, if its price doesn’t scare them away. We all greeted yesterday’s like it was a long,...
Aug 27, 2026
At $14,750, Could This 1993 40th Anniversary Year Chevy Corvette be Your Party Favor?
At $14,750, Could This 1993 40th Anniversary Year Chevy Corvette be Your Party Favor?
The seller of today’s 40th anniversary year ‘Vette says that pictures just don’t do it justice. Let’s see if that missing justice can be found in its asking price. The general definition of a ‘Muscle Car’ is a small, two-door, rear-wheel drive body shell into which has been wedged...
Aug 27, 2026
The 2020 Porsche Cayenne Coupe Doubles Down on Absurdity but It’s Fun and Fast
The 2020 Porsche Cayenne Coupe Doubles Down on Absurdity but It’s Fun and Fast
The takes one of the sportiest crossovers on the market and gives it a slight redesign that better reflects the speed its 541 horsepower twin-turbo V8 delivers. It’s also more expensive than a normal Cayenne, because something isn’t stylish if you aren’t paying more for it. ( Porsche flew...
Aug 27, 2026
Drive Your Cars You Cowards
Drive Your Cars You Cowards
Here at Jalopnik, we try not to be redundant in the subject matter of our blogs. Redundancy would be boring for us, boring for you, and would eventually rid us of our prized spot on your bookmark bar. But if there’s anything that needs to be said , and...
Aug 27, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved