zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Racing
/
This Is Why Mercedes' Formula E Powertrain Sounds Way Different Than All The Others
This Is Why Mercedes' Formula E Powertrain Sounds Way Different Than All The Others-November 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:11:07

Image for article titled This Is Why Mercedes' Formula E Powertrain Sounds Way Different Than All The Others

Mercedes is making its Formula E debut this year as the series launches into its sixth season, and the team is already making waves at pre-season testing in Valencia. The Mercedes’ power unit sounds way different than any of the other cars on track, especially under braking. What’s up with that?

Plenty of people noticed it, but thankfully was at the track and decided to break it down for those of us who weren’t able to poke our noses into the Mercedes garage and see what was going on.

He runs through audio of a few other teams before getting to Mercedes, and there’s an obvious difference. The Merc has a much higher-pitched howl to it compared to the already pretty-high-pitched whistling we’ve come to expect from FE cars (you can hear more comparisons ). It’s probably most obvious on a spectral frequency graph:

Mahindra on the right, Mercedes on the left.

An analysis of all the cars reveals that the BMW powertrain is similarly high pitched as compared to Mercedes powertrains (used by both Merc and Venturi). That implies the power units are spinning much faster as they regenerate energy under braking.

As a quick refresher course, the battery in the car can feed energy to the MGU (the motor generator unit, or the powertrain), which then channels that energy into the gearbox and subsequently into the wheels. But when a car brakes, the energy is removed from the wheels and converted back into electrical energy by the MGU, which is then stored in the battery.

The MGU can run at varying speeds, anywhere from 20 to 40,000 RPM. When running at a higher RPM, though, the gearbox will be doing way more work to step down all that power to something more appropriate to keep the wheels moving. That obviously creates a hell of a lot more strain on the gearbox than a lower RPM would.

But there are still benefits to a fast MGU—mainly in terms of size and weight. The faster the MGU, the smaller and lighter it can be. In this case, size definitely does matter.

As the spectral frequency graphs show, most teams are opting for around 2,000 Hz, with Mercedes and BMW being closer to 4,000 Hz (roughly correlating with a faster RPM than the other cars). The faster the MGU, the higher pitched it sounds.

There isn’t a guaranteed performance advantage to opting for a faster MGU. Jaguar, for example, opted for a faster MGU speed in season five and only ended up finish seventh place in the constructor’s championship. A smaller, faster MGU may prove to be helpful in qualifying situations while during the race it could overheat or wear out more quickly.

So while Formula E is still largely a spec series, there’s a lot of interesting development going on underneath the bodywork. And only time will tell if Mercedes and BMW have made the right call this year.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Racing
This BMW Z4 Just Turned Into A Fireball At The Pits During N24
This BMW Z4 Just Turned Into A Fireball At The Pits During N24
It was in third position when it entered the pits, but then it decided to fire up properly and get a bit further from a podium finish. But if you think that stops a dedicated team at the Nürburgring 24 half an hour before midnight, think again. Foam, many fast...
Nov 9, 2025
This Used To Be An Audi R8 LMS At The Nurburgring
This Used To Be An Audi R8 LMS At The Nurburgring
Phoenix Racing won last year’s Nürburgring 24 by setting a new distance record after completing 159 laps. The car you see here is wearing their #1 sticker. The guy I asked at Audi couldn’t tell me what happened, and the R8 was got covered up very quickly, but he did...
Nov 9, 2025
Scuderia Cameron Glickenhaus Finishes The Nürburgring 24 At 35th
Scuderia Cameron Glickenhaus Finishes The Nürburgring 24 At 35th
The started with 180 cars on the grid this year, but finished with much less as the night like always on this very tight circuit. Scuderia Cameron Glickenhaus as well with the brand new , but kept on rocking by crossing the line at #35. The SCG 003C worked brilliantly...
Nov 9, 2025
Driver Makes Save Of The Year After Brake Failure At COTA
Driver Makes Save Of The Year After Brake Failure At COTA
Everyone wants to drive Circuit of the Americas! No one wants to crash at COTA. Speeds are high, and there are pricey barriers to hit. Fortunately, this Porsche 911 GT3 Cup car with no brakes managed to park it right before hitting the barriers. Code Brown level: high. Driver Luke...
Nov 9, 2025
Ed Carpenter Escapes Unharmed After Latest Terrifying IndyCar Flip
Ed Carpenter Escapes Unharmed After Latest Terrifying IndyCar Flip
Ed Carpenter is the latest driver to experience a in IndyCar. His #20 Chevrolet spun exiting turn 2 during a practice session this morning, hit the wall backwards, then climbed up the wall, eventually landing upside-down. The result was pretty scary. Thankfully, he escaped the flip unharmed. If there’s anything...
Nov 9, 2025
Killing Your Stomach With The Indianapolis 500
Killing Your Stomach With The Indianapolis 500
I’m not sure what’s actually worse for you: the traditional ice-cream-based parfait covered in whipped cream and sprinkles, or this delicious looking mac and cheese creation from Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Mac and cheese topped with pulled pork? I would eat this, and then I would eat another, and I would...
Nov 9, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved