zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
Uber And Lyft's California Reckoning Is Nearly Here
Uber And Lyft's California Reckoning Is Nearly Here-July 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:34

Image for article titled Uber And Lyft's California Reckoning Is Nearly Here

Uber and Lyft, two companies that have never turned profits, really want you to believe that their very existence in California is riding on . That very well may be, but not because there is anything wrong with California state law. It will be because Uber and Lyft’s business models rely on worker exploitation.

To recap: last year, California AB5, which required so-called gig economy companies like Uber, Lift, and Doordash to classify their independent contractors as full employees, endowing them with benefits like unemployment insurance, sick leave, and healthcare. Uber . The state of California later also sued, accusing Uber and Lyft of not complying with the law. The matter has been tied up in the courts since.

On Thursday, a California appeals court , saying that it had to comply with AB5, though that ruling won’t take effect until after the matter of Proposition 22 is decided at the ballot box on November 3.

How should you vote on Proposition 22, if you live in California? I’m glad you asked. The language voters makes it all pretty clear:

A YES vote on this measure means: App-based rideshare and delivery companies could hire drivers as independent contractors. Drivers could decide when, where, and how much to work but would not get standard benefits and protections that businesses must provide employees.

A NO vote on this measure means: App-based rideshare and delivery companies would have to hire drivers as employees if the courts say that a recent state law makes drivers employees. Drivers would have less choice about when, where, and how much to work but would get standard benefits and protections that businesses must provide employees.

This is a classic California proposition. To get what you want, you must vote NO. Californians love the ritual of checking and double checking ballot guides before voting and repeatedly asking themselves “am I stupid?” while trying to figure out who worded all of this shit.

One of the benefits of the gig economy, its proponents argue, is that it frees up workers to go from job to job, not tying them to any one employer. I can see how some part-time Uber drivers might argue that a higher barrier to entry to driving Uber—and having less flexibility about how much to work—might make remaining to be an independent contractor appealing. But on the other hand it’s hard to argue that the drivers who treat Uber or Lyft as full-time jobs don’t deserve the protections and benefits a full-time job usually gives you.

For some people, in other words, I can see how the issue isn’t open-and-shut, but for voters without skin in the game the best indicator of how to vote may be the fact that Uber, Lyft, and other Proposition 22 supporters have spent around $200 million in their campaign. An opposition campaign, meanwhile, has raised around $15 million, . That money is mainly coming from labor unions.

Polling on the issue, perhaps unsurprisingly, presents a clouded picture. Per The NYT:

Despite the big spending and a barrage of television advertising, only 39 percent of likely voters said they supported Uber and Lyft in a poll last month by the University of California, Berkeley, while 36 percent opposed their proposal and others were undecided. People close to the campaign said they would want to see close to 60 percent approval in polling before they could breathe a sigh of relief.

That means passage—or not—is still very much up in the air with so many undecided. Uber has said that, in fact, it won’t bail from California should Proposition 22 lose; instead it’ll likely scale back significantly and raise fares. Maybe that’s the outcome that should’ve happened to begin with.

If your business model relies on exploiting workers and still doesn’t make money, it’s possible you have a bad business.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
I Entered My Lifted Miata In A Real Off-Road Race, Here's What Happened
I Entered My Lifted Miata In A Real Off-Road Race, Here's What Happened
I have two automotive loves: The first is the Miata, the second is off-road racing. For a while I raced air-cooled Volkswagens in the deserts of California and Nevada and I was lucky enough to co-drive in a class 11 stock bug in the Baja 1000 a few years...
Jul 6, 2025
2024 Kia EV9: What Do You Want To Know?
2024 Kia EV9: What Do You Want To Know?
At long last, we are about to get behind the wheel of for the first time. Sure, , and sure, , and sure , but hey — what can you do? Anyway, before we get behind the wheel of this three-row electric beast, we want to know what you...
Jul 6, 2025
Toyota Is Moving A Prewar 700-Ton Press Machine Halfway Around The World
Toyota Is Moving A Prewar 700-Ton Press Machine Halfway Around The World
closed its São Bernardo Plant in November 2023, marking the end of its first overseas production facility. The closure caps off a period of continuous car production in São Paolo, , lasting over 60 years. The plant was home to a Komatsu 700-ton press that predates itself. And now...
Jul 6, 2025
Subaru Had It Right All Along
Subaru Had It Right All Along
When first came to the United States, it sold small funky cars that were decidedly un-American. As the company grew its own identity and became more established in the U.S., it became the first automaker to offer an all-wheel-drive passenger car in 1975. Subaru was also an early-adopter of...
Jul 6, 2025
Watch ABS Fail When MotorWeek Tests A 1997 Chevy S-10
Watch ABS Fail When MotorWeek Tests A 1997 Chevy S-10
MotorWeek’s is some of the on the internet. The long-running automotive news magazine has a treasure trove of tests after being on the air for over 40 years. Where else can you find detailed instrumented testing of long-forgotten cars like the or a ? MotorWeek’s recent Retro Review upload is...
Jul 6, 2025
I Can't Get Enough Of This YouTuber Who Builds Tiny, Fully Functional Scale-Model Cars
I Can't Get Enough Of This YouTuber Who Builds Tiny, Fully Functional Scale-Model Cars
I love tiny, of . I have a that is roughly half the size of a normal cat, and she’s perfect. I own a 2013 , which is like the miniature version of a normal-sized vehicle (at least here in Texas) — but beyond that, I also own a Hot...
Jul 6, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved