zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
Uber To California: Make Us
Uber To California: Make Us-June 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:56

Image for article titled Uber To California: Make Us

, the California bill that would codify a state Supreme Court ruling putting in place a strict test for whether a worker classifies as an independent contractor and has potentially profound implications on the ridehail industry, to become law. But that is unlikely to change much for Uber and Lyft drivers when the law goes into effect on January 1, 2020, as it appears at least one of these companies will gear up for a legal fight instead.

Tony West, Uber’s chief legal officer, told reporters in a conference call today that the company has no plans to reclassify drivers as employees should Newsom sign AB5 as expected. Uber maintains that drivers would still be classified as independent contractors even under AB5's stricter test because “drivers’ work is outside the usual course of Uber’s business, which is serving as a technology platform” for different marketplaces.

Same thing we’ve seen before: .

Today, many Uber and Lyft drivers in major cities across the country are striking to protest their…

“The law does not say that drivers are employees,” West maintained. “What the law does is it changes the legal test to make the determination whether or not a driver is an employee or an independent contractor.”

And West says Uber’s position continues to be that drivers will still fall on the independent contractor side of that test. “We believe, given all the facts and circumstances...we believe we can make the harder test, we can pass the harder test to the satisfaction of arbitrators and courts who hear the issue.”

In other words, Uber has no plans to change their designation of drivers any time soon.

To be fair, Uber has good reason to believe they won’t have to, at least not for a very long time. To understand why, look to Massachusetts.

AB5 is a bill based on the Dynamex California Supreme Court decision, which adopted the so-called “ABC Test,” which itself is based off that has been on the books for Uber and Lyft’s entire existence. Yet, Uber and Lyft drivers are independent contractors in Massachusetts just like everywhere else.

The reason for this, according to Gavriela Bogin-Farber of the Massachusetts-based labor law firm Messing, Rudavsky & Weliky, P.C., is because the law simply establishes the test courts have to apply when worker statuses are challenged in court. It is not, as she put it, “self-executing.” Workers have to sue and judges have to rule on the issue for that specific company before any change has to take place.

And the courts are still working this out. Earlier this year, Uber filed all the way back in 2013 involving drivers from Massachusetts and California for $20 million. No judge ruled on the issue of whether drivers are employees or independent contractors.

There is one wrinkle to AB5 that could potentially speed things up. Under a last-minute amendment to AB5, to sue companies for worker misclassification. This would not only allow lawsuits to happen faster, but also circumvent the question of whether the issue ought to be settled in forced arbitration.

In any event, West made clear during Wednesday’s conference call Uber will continue to classify drivers as independent contractors to let voters decide.

West likened AB5 to a “harder test” that Uber must pass, but one he believes they will. “A harder test does not predetermine an outcome,” West added. That will be up for the courts to decide.

And until such case law is established, Bogin-Farber said, “Uber can continue to classify workers as they want.”

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Blip: Happy Luv Day
Blip: Happy Luv Day
Yes, happy anniversary, everyone. To commemorate this day, I’d like to remind everyone that Chevrolet once sold a re-badged Isuzu pickup truck and I wrote about this truck and the peculiar name that would likely very much not fly on a modern truck a few years back, and reached...
Jun 18, 2026
Oil Companies Are Doing Too Well, Again
Oil Companies Are Doing Too Well, Again
I would not expect rising gas prices to go anywhere, but it’s interesting to see how one hand of the economy (the oil industry) is attacking the other (consumerism) and I don’t know how it’ll eventually shake out. All that and more in for February 14, 2022. I love...
Jun 18, 2026
Highway Of Agony: How Traffic Safety Films Introduced Millions Of Kids To Scenes Of Real Death
Highway Of Agony: How Traffic Safety Films Introduced Millions Of Kids To Scenes Of Real Death
“There’s trouble ahead. Trouble that may or may not be a signal 30. What will we find? A minor mishap? Or will we look upon the stark face of death?” a deadpan narrator asks his audience. It’s a question you are forced to grapple with every time the scene changes...
Jun 18, 2026
VW Things Had A Real Moment In Super Bowl Ads
VW Things Had A Real Moment In Super Bowl Ads
I don’t usually like to write too much about Super Bowl commercials, because, you know, screw ‘em. I’m not here to advertise for any carmaker or crypto whatever or medicated shoe insoles or whatever they’re talking about. However, I am honor-bound to report to you when mainstream culture intersects...
Jun 18, 2026
Picking A Super Bowl Winner Solely By The Quarterbacks' Cars
Picking A Super Bowl Winner Solely By The Quarterbacks' Cars
Super Bowl LVI will kickoff at SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles in less than two hours. Los Angeles Rams will take on the Cincinnati Bengals to decide the championship of the National Football League. The Rams have the unique opportunity of claiming the Vince Lombardi Trophy in their home...
Jun 18, 2026
Here's How You Could Replace Your Car's Fuel Pump With A Human Heart
Here's How You Could Replace Your Car's Fuel Pump With A Human Heart
We at Jalopnik are sharing the love this heart-filled holiday by reposting this little writeup, published Valentine’s Day in 2017. Enjoy. Ah, Valentine’s Day! The day we expect our significant others, lovers, and expensive sex mannequins to gamely pretend to forget about our many, complicated flaws and remember why they...
Jun 18, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved