zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Uber's Autonomous Test Cars Had Volvo's Safety Systems Disabled
Uber's Autonomous Test Cars Had Volvo's Safety Systems Disabled-May 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:37

Ever since autonomous Volvo XC90 test car fatally struck a pedestrian in Tempe, Arizona last week, many people familiar with modern car technology have asked this: why didn’t Volvo’s own automatic braking or crash avoidance systems kick in? Now we know. According to one supplier, Volvo’s standard systems were disabled for the Uber cars.

This comes to us from , which spoke to supplier Aptiv Plc, the company that makes the radar and camera systems for Volvo. A spokesman for the company stuck up for its technology, effectively saying what’s on the Uber cars has nothing to do with the systems on commercially available Volvos.

From the story:

“We don’t want people to be confused or think it was a failure of the technology that we supply for Volvo, because that’s not the case,” Zach Peterson, a spokesman for , said by phone. The Volvo XC90’s standard advanced driver-assistance system “has nothing to do” with the Uber test vehicle’s autonomous driving system, he said.

Aptiv is speaking up for its technology to avoid being tainted by the fatality involving Uber, which may have been following standard practice by disabling other tech as it develops and tests its own autonomous driving system.

Additionally, the story says, tests by safety tech company Mobileye revealed its own systems would have been able to detect the pedestrian one second before the crash based solely on the dash cam video, Bloomberg reports.

Last Sunday, a self-driving Uber Volvo struck and killed 49-year-old pedestrian Elaine Herzberg while she crossed a busy street at night. Its human minder was later revealed to have been looking down prior to the crash.

While it would have been somewhat understandable for a human driver to miss a pedestrian crossing the road in the dark, many of today’s cars—including the Volvo XC90—have cameras, radar, sensors and automatic braking systems designed to detect and prevent exactly that kind of accident. In other words, even if a human couldn’t have seen Herzberg and stopped in time, one imagines the Volvo should have been able to.

The accounts from Aptiv and Mobileye are yet more evidence that Uber’s autonomous tech wasn’t up to par with that of competitors, and possibly should not have been on the road at all. Uber’s cars were by human minders than ones made by Google’s Waymo and others, and as Jalopnik reported last week, the company .

In the aftermath of the fatal crash involving an self-driving Uber vehicle and pedestrian…

Until these supplier accounts came out, neither Volvo nor Uber were especially forthcoming about whose technology did what in this crash, and probably for good reason. The question of responsibility here is a major one.

Last week, when Jalopnik asked if the Uber cars have Volvo’s systems disabled or not, or if a standard Volvo would have automatically engaged braking under similar circumstances, a Volvo spokesman merely said “We cannot speculate on the cause of the incident” and “we await the full investigation report.”

When pressed for further clarification, he did not respond. Uber also did not respond to questions about the technology from Jalopnik.

Yet it’s pretty apparent from our own testing of newer Volvos—as well as similar new cars with automatic braking—that this crash could have been “caught” by the car, even in the dark. For example, here’s the XC90's 2015 Euro NCAP safety test illustrating how it works:

At the very least, the cars won’t be an issue on Arizona’s roads anymore. Last night Gov. Doug Ducey ordered the state’s Department of Transportation in the state. Uber meanwhile continues to halt all testing, as it has since the crash occurred.

Hat tip to YupIGottaWagon

This story has been updated to better reflect how Mobileye’s review of the crash went. Mobileye does not state that the system would have detected the pedestrian one second before the crash, but that it was able to detect the pedestrian before the crash using only the dashcam footage Uber released.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
Costco Will Sell The Chevy Blazer EV At A Discount To Go With Your Rotisserie Chicken
Costco Will Sell The Chevy Blazer EV At A Discount To Go With Your Rotisserie Chicken
knows that you keep coming back for the and Kirkland brand, but you can now also buy a cheaper at your local warehouse. Chevy notified its dealers that members are eligible for a $1,000 rebate on the through January 2, according to . The discount is part of ,...
May 12, 2025
Truck Fans Would Rather Wait For A Toyota Tacoma EV Than Buy A F-150 Lightning Or Cybertruck
Truck Fans Would Rather Wait For A Toyota Tacoma EV Than Buy A F-150 Lightning Or Cybertruck
fans are already cooling on despite more options on the market and news of upcoming models from the likes of Chevy and Ram. The and have yet to be released, while the has recently joined the and for sale in the U.S. And, yet, all of these current and...
May 12, 2025
GM Says It's Dropping Apple CarPlay And Android Auto Because They're Unsafe (Update)
GM Says It's Dropping Apple CarPlay And Android Auto Because They're Unsafe (Update)
GM is still dealing with the fallout of its decision to drop Apple CarPlay and Android Auto in favor of developing its own in-house system. In the last eight months, the company has had to deal with while still maintaining its in-house system will be “.” Since neither of...
May 12, 2025
Volkswagen EVs Can Now Power Your House For Two Days (Update)
Volkswagen EVs Can Now Power Your House For Two Days (Update)
Experts have said that one of the ways to speed up EV adoption is for them to support . The ability for owners to power their house off their car or from the grid is vital. Just nine EVs on the market currently support bidirectional charging, but now VW...
May 12, 2025
Biden’s First EV Charging Station Goes Online After $7.5 Billion In American EV Investments
Biden’s First EV Charging Station Goes Online After $7.5 Billion In American EV Investments
Despite in investments for the development of in the , not a single charging station had gone live thanks to — until now. The first EV charger paid for by Biden’s Bipartisan deal has come online in Ohio, according to , which marks the operational start of what the...
May 12, 2025
Danish Investors Dump Tesla Shares After Elon Musk Calls Strikes In Sweden 'Insane'
Danish Investors Dump Tesla Shares After Elon Musk Calls Strikes In Sweden 'Insane'
Danish pension fund PensionDanmark is dumping all of its stock and putting the U.S. EV maker on its exclusion list of the companies it chooses to invest in – or not. The fund is selling all of its shares due to Elon Musk’s refusal to enter into labor agreements...
May 12, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved