zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Why Uber Could Be Held Criminally Liable In Fatal Crash Involving Autonomous Car (Updated)
Why Uber Could Be Held Criminally Liable In Fatal Crash Involving Autonomous Car (Updated)-August 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:37

Under an executive order signed this month by Arizona’s governor, Uber could be held criminally liable for a fatal crash involving one of its self-driving cars that struck and killed a pedestrian Sunday.

Arizona’s Republican Gov. Doug Ducey’s , implemented March 1, lay out a specific list of licensing and registration requirements for autonomous car operators. Specifically, Ducey’s order specifies that a “person” subject to the laws includes any corporation incorporated in Arizona.

The change, highlighted before the crash happened, could leave Uber open to possible criminal charges.

In response to questions from the alt-weekly, Ducey spokesman Daniel Scarpinato and Ducey’s chief of staff, Kirk Adams, said the state wouldn’t be held liable if an autonomous car negligently killed a pedestrian:

“The technology has advanced considerably, and the industry has grown rapidly,” said Kirk Adams, Ducey’s chief of staff. “The companies still have work to do, certainly from a public understanding of the technology. That’s their job. Our job is to make sure that we are protecting public safety.”

[...] The corporation that operates the vehicles would be responsible, they said, and the company could be held criminally liable just like a person.

As the new executive order states, a “person” is defined as including corporations . The company would also pay any traffic tickets the driverless vehicle may incur, they said.

While Ducey has been incredibly welcoming of autonomous car testing in Arizona, this order represented a stronger push toward regulation and safety, ending the sort of free-for-all that the state had in place before.

The governor’s office didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment from Jalopnik. Uber said earlier Monday that it’s cooperating with the police investigation of the crash.

And as the news outlet Law & Crime explains, the concept of corporate manslaughter is :

But the concept is more or less foreign to U.S. law and it’s not quite obvious who would be served with an indictment in the event Uber was charged with a crime. Other questions arise: Who would be arrested over the death? Does Uber’s CEO have a jumpsuit in his future? The potential for a corporation to be charged with manslaughter raises multiple issues of novelty and legal first impressions.

An initial statement from Tempe police said that the victim, 49-year-old Elaine Herzberg, was crossing the street outside of a designated crosswalk. Arizona isn’t a “full pedestrian right-of-way state,” Law & Crime explains, which would “seem to mitigate the potential for Uber (or whoever) to be charged with a crime over Herzberg’s death.”

“However, previous Arizona defendants have been charged with vehicular homicide-related crimes in instances where the driver was somehow at fault,” the news outlet said. “Therefore, the placement of the pedestrian is likely to be considered a factor in any criminal liability determination–not a controlling element.”

It wasn’t immediately clear whether police in Tempe, Arizona, had a criminal investigation underway. A press conference with the the city’s police department is scheduled for 6 p.m. EST.

The this afternoon revealed that, according to a preliminary investigation, the vehicle was traveling at approximately 40 MPH and does not appear to have attempted to stop before hitting the pedestrian. The official said the investigation will continue as a standard collision investigation in response to a question about determining who was at fault. The official deferred defining autonomous driving to Uber. You can watch the short news conference in full below:

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
Video Shows Pedestrian In Fatal Uber Crash Stepped In Front Of Self-Driving Car: Police (UPDATED)
Video Shows Pedestrian In Fatal Uber Crash Stepped In Front Of Self-Driving Car: Police (UPDATED)
A video from an Uber-owned self-driving car that fatally struck a woman on Sunday shows that she abruptly moved in front of it, police , a factor that could play into the investigation of the crash. Sylvia Moir, police chief in Tempe, Arizona, where the crash occurred, told the Chronicle...
Aug 12, 2026
Elon Gets His Money, Now He Has To Deliver
Elon Gets His Money, Now He Has To Deliver
Tesla shareholders on Wednesday approved a compensation package for CEO Elon Musk that could net him close to $56 billion, so long as he meets incredibly ambitious milestones. The pay package was approved by a “wide margin,” , despite . The approval gives Musk an additional $2.6 billion in stock...
Aug 12, 2026
Lyft Is Offering A Flat Monthly Subscription Service For Frequent Riders
Lyft Is Offering A Flat Monthly Subscription Service For Frequent Riders
Ride-hailing company Lyft is testing out a new monthly subscription model—a la Spotify or Netflix—that would provide passengers a set number of rides for a fixed cost. For now, it seems, the terms may vary, depending on the customer. The rollout of Lyft’s subscription model apparently began in earnest last...
Aug 12, 2026
Get Real About Self-Driving Cars
Get Real About Self-Driving Cars
Yesterday’s news that a self-driving struck and killed a pedestrian in Arizona made it clear that Silicon Valley has succeeded in setting impossibly high expectations for autonomous driving technology. That needs to change. The crash occurred around 10 p.m. Sunday in the City of Tempe. Police have said that an...
Aug 12, 2026
Apparently Autonomous Cars Will Need Smarter Door Hatches Too
Apparently Autonomous Cars Will Need Smarter Door Hatches Too
Autonomous cars, if they do in fact one day takeover the roads, will someday hopefully eliminate the need for a driver at the wheel. In that future scenario, German auto parts supplier Kiekert believes traditional door hatches also won’t be necessary. Apparently future humans will struggle with opening doors. Kiekert...
Aug 12, 2026
Why Uber Could Be Held Criminally Liable In Fatal Crash Involving Autonomous Car (Updated)
Why Uber Could Be Held Criminally Liable In Fatal Crash Involving Autonomous Car (Updated)
Under an executive order signed this month by Arizona’s governor, Uber could be held criminally liable for a fatal crash involving one of its self-driving cars that struck and killed a pedestrian Sunday. Arizona’s Republican Gov. Doug Ducey’s , implemented March 1, lay out a specific list of licensing and...
Aug 12, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved