zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
Words Apparently Matter When It Comes To Car Crashes
Words Apparently Matter When It Comes To Car Crashes-May 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:51

Image for article titled Words Apparently Matter When It Comes To Car Crashes

The headline on this blog used the word car “crashes,” not “accidents,” because words matter. That is the conclusion of about how “minor changes in crash coverage can shift a reader’s perceptions of what happened and what to do about it.”

To test this, researchers asked 999 randomly selected people (yes, it bothers me they couldn’t get one more person, too) to read one of three accounts of a car crash involving a pedestrian.

The first was “pedestrian-focused” and reads most like what you might find in your evening news or local paper . In this account it was an “accident” and the police responded to “a pedestrian struck by a car...wearing dark clothing.” The second article was “driver-focused” in which the fatal “crash” involved “a driver striking a pedestrian.” The third, a “thematically-framed” approach, was similar to the driver-focused one but added a paragraph of context about the increasing number of pedestrian deaths on a road with high traffic speeds and few streetlights.

Here’s how the respondents assigned blame for the crash, broken down by which article they read:

Image for article titled Words Apparently Matter When It Comes To Car Crashes

Those who read the pedestrian-focused account were, unsurprisingly, far more likely to blame the pedestrian and least likely to blame the driver. The same holds true for those who read the driver-focused account. Perhaps most interestingly, those who read the thematic account, and therefore understood the larger context in which the crash took place, were far more likely to blame “other” factors.

Although the researchers don’t say precisely what those “other” factors may be, we get a clue elsewhere in the study. Those who received the thematic frame were more likely to support infrastructure changes (93.4 percent) than those who received the pedestrian or driver-focused versions (85.3 and 85.2 percent, respectively).

The researchers are not saying that journalists and others describing crashes should start automatically blaming drivers, but people should be aware that the language they use often gives readers the improper impression pedestrians are to blame.

“At the moment, the default setting is for crash coverage to blame the pedestrian,” the researchers noted, to back up their claim. There are good journalistic reasons to avoid this practice; mainly, those reporters rarely have actual evidence the pedestrian was to blame. “Despite the lack of evidence,” the researchers noted, “writers rarely break from the practice of blaming the victim.”

Instead, it is the reporter’s goal to describe what happened and make the public aware of the circumstances that caused the crash. Often, neither driver nor pedestrian was breaking the law, because we have a lot of crappily-designed roads that invite or even force conflict between road users.

“In short, if the goal is to call public attention to external circumstances that cause road deaths, thematic framing helps to accomplish this goal,” the researchers concluded. In other words, context matters, and readers get that. We’d all be better off if more journalists included it.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
The Honda Prelude Was Controversial In Japan Because Of Something Called The 'Pervert Lever'
The Honda Prelude Was Controversial In Japan Because Of Something Called The 'Pervert Lever'
Here in America, the Honda Prelude is remembered as a fun, sporty little car, a reminder of a time when everything Honda made was clever and reliable, and the without sacrificing Honda quality. People in of the , which is why finding out that it is so hard to imagine....
May 9, 2025
Beverly Hills Police Are Keeping The Streets Safe From Miscreants Driving Sofas
Beverly Hills Police Are Keeping The Streets Safe From Miscreants Driving Sofas
Residents of Beverly Hills have one less thing to be concerned about, one less worry to add to the considerable pile of their difficult, hardscrabble lives: their streets are safe from prowling leopard-print sofas with tall, lanky Brits on them. But who is this long, snow-haired madman terrorizing the...
May 9, 2025
Japan Wants You To Stop Buying All Its Skyline GT-Rs
Japan Wants You To Stop Buying All Its Skyline GT-Rs
Being in the export and import business in Japan pays off. As sketchy as that might sound, Japan exports a little . Most of these cars are pretty unremarkable, bound . But a small percentage of cars leaving Japan every year are held dear by many enthusiasts in the country....
May 9, 2025
The Original Pagani Zonda Still Doesn't Get Enough Credit
The Original Pagani Zonda Still Doesn't Get Enough Credit
I was just wasting a good amount of my afternoon reading about the Orca C113. Not familiar with it? Don’t feel bad, there’s a reason for that. The Orca C113 () was going to be one of the fastest cars in the world, the product of a composites specialist...
May 9, 2025
Why Motor Trend's Dyno Test Of The 2020 Chevrolet C8 Corvette Revealed Huge But Wrong Power Numbers
Why Motor Trend's Dyno Test Of The 2020 Chevrolet C8 Corvette Revealed Huge But Wrong Power Numbers
Back in October, wrote that, during its dyno testing, a had made horsepower and torque numbers well above the rated 495 horsepower and 470 lb-ft. The publication concluded then that the car “produces more power than what Chevy claims.” But now in a new follow-up, the team admits that...
May 9, 2025
Does Aspark Want Us To Bone This Car Or What
Does Aspark Want Us To Bone This Car Or What
I had forgotten about Japanese automaker Aspark and its all-electric hypercar, the , until today. It’s certainly a cool-looking thing with incredibly aspirational performance claims. But besides all that, I have this weird feeling Aspark (or whoever wrote the Owl’s press release) really, really wants us to bone this...
May 9, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved