zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
Your Car Will Probably Be Driven By A Remote Human Before A Computer
Your Car Will Probably Be Driven By A Remote Human Before A Computer-September 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:33

Image for article titled Your Car Will Probably Be Driven By A Remote Human Before A Computer

If we’ve learned anything from Silicon Valley, it’s to over-promise and under-deliver. And if we’ve learned anything else from Silicon Valley, it’s that replacing humans with artificial intelligence is not nearly as easy as it sounds.

Put these two tendencies together, and you get an awful lot of humans performing grunt work that tech companies previously wanted to automate away only to find they couldn’t write algorithms that performed as well as any human could. The first examples that immediately jump to mind are , , and only to admit “humans are underrated.”

Don’t look now, but self-driving cars are a prime candidate to be the latest major “automation” technology that is performed not by a computer, but by a human you can’t see. Think of it kind of like drone piloting, except if the Department of Defense had initially promised drones would fly and bomb all by themselves.

I’ve been thinking about this possibility for a while—partly after reading my colleague Jason Torchinsky’s —as there are a number of startups working in what they call the tele-operations field. But I was reminded of it recently when gig economy company Doordash purchased Scotty Labs, as “a tele-operations company that is working on technology to enable people to remotely control self-driving cars.” “Remotely control self-driving cars” is one hell of an oxymoron!

Scotty’s approach autonomous driving in some scenarios with remote driving in others. And they’re far from the only ones. , “Waymo, General Motors’ Cruise, Nutonomy, Zoox, Drive.ai, Uber, and Nissan are all quietly developing teleoperation systems” in addition to the subject of WIRED’s article, Phantom Auto (WIRED did not mention Scotty).

In some ways this makes sense. The available evidence so far is that self-driving cars can probably get pretty damn good at driving in uncomplicated situations like well-marked highways without road work, but more complex situations like urban driving . Calling up a human elsewhere to take control of the complicated situations doesn’t sound so crazy.

As the automotive industry continues to throw all of its weight behind developing self-driving…

But driving a car in a populated area from hundreds or thousands of miles away is a bit more complicated than piloting a drone. Remote pilots , where what’s on the screen is seconds behind what’s happening in real life. For drone pilots, latency is problematic and annoying but not a deal-breaker.

That’s not the case with cars. Even a single second of latency would make it nearly impossible to drive the car safely, not to mention if the car experienced connectivity issues or other network failures.

And that’s just the most glaring complication tele-operation poses. Liability in the case of crashes, labor issues, and regulatory hurdles are all giant cans of worms. Who will the drivers work for? What kind of safety regulations or driving standards will apply to them? Can they live in one state and drive in another? What about another country? Will people want some random stranger driving their car?

Regardless of how these questions get sorted, remote drivers feels much more in keeping with the reality Silicon Valley has actually delivered rather than the ones it continually promises with extended deadlines. called this reality “a new underclass of urban servants” which includes “the ‘Uber for X’ economy—that nebulous network of people contracted through online marketplaces for driving, delivery, and other on-demand services,” an economy of which Scotty’s new owner Doordash is very much a part.

For those lucky enough to benefit from such services—as with anyone rich enough to have servants—life becomes a frictionless amalgam of goods and services magically appearing before you. But for the servants, it means long, underpaid hours with no benefits and limited protections from labor law.

Obviously, tele-operations doesn’t exist yet, so one cannot say what life will be like for these hypothetical remote drivers. But if history is any guide, it will be a race to the bottom in terms of pay and work conditions, perhaps involving endless terminals in a vast warehouse. As with so many aspects of our lives these days, it’s only too easy to envision a future that is not only sub-optimal, but dystopian.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
Slower Charging Might Help Secure An EV Future: Report
Slower Charging Might Help Secure An EV Future: Report
While it seems like most of the world is focused on finding ways to charge quickly, some European power companies have actually come to the opposite conclusion. It may actually be better—and more sustainable—to charge our EVs slowly during off-peak hours. EVs are becoming a more appealing option to...
Sep 14, 2026
Your Car Will Probably Be Driven By A Remote Human Before A Computer
Your Car Will Probably Be Driven By A Remote Human Before A Computer
If we’ve learned anything from Silicon Valley, it’s to over-promise and under-deliver. And if we’ve learned anything else from Silicon Valley, it’s that replacing humans with artificial intelligence is not nearly as easy as it sounds. Put these two tendencies together, and you get an awful lot of humans...
Sep 14, 2026
School Buses Are Perfectly Suited To Be Electrified Cheaply, Efficiently, And Yes, Crappily
School Buses Are Perfectly Suited To Be Electrified Cheaply, Efficiently, And Yes, Crappily
For many of us with offspring that we don’t keep chained in basements or workhouses, today was the first day of school. I sent my own kid, Otto, off to his first day of third grade, which he was whisked to by a huge, yellow, loud, lumbering diesel beast...
Sep 14, 2026
The Porsche Taycan Might Be The Fastest Four-Door EV On The Nürburgring
The Porsche Taycan Might Be The Fastest Four-Door EV On The Nürburgring
Does it feel like we’ve been handing out records to just about anyone these days, or is it just me? Anyway, the soon-to-be-released has apparently been crowned the fastest four-door (heavy emphasis on four-door, there) to drive the . So, congrats to them? Earlier this year, Volkswagen took home the...
Sep 14, 2026
Faulty Automatic Braking Has Drivers Afraid Of Their Own Cars: Report
Faulty Automatic Braking Has Drivers Afraid Of Their Own Cars: Report
Advanced driver assistance systems, which include lane-keeping, adaptive cruise control and automatic braking, are designed to make cars and driving safer than ever. But sometimes, functions like automatic braking malfunction and have the opposite effect, wrecking a driver’s confidence in driving at all. Ideally, automatic braking helps slow down...
Sep 14, 2026
Turns Out A Road Made Of Solar Panels Was, In Fact, A Bad Idea
Turns Out A Road Made Of Solar Panels Was, In Fact, A Bad Idea
There will be some hiccups on our path to a more environmentally-friendly future. Some hiccups, , will be bigger than others. So, I’m willing to excuse France for the very, very predictable failure of their solar panel road. On the off chance you have not been thinking about the...
Sep 14, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved