zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Racing
/
Formula One's Never-Ending Grid Penalties Need To Stop
Formula One's Never-Ending Grid Penalties Need To Stop-June 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:11:20

For Formula One teams struggling with reliability issues, qualifying can feel like the place where you can run the session, but the results don’t matter. Grid penalties will send you to the back anyway. We’re not even done with practice at Monza and four cars already have grid penalties. It’s too much. It’s been too much for the past couple years. There has to be a better way to handle this.

[Full disclosure: Mobil 1 and Red Bull Racing wanted me to go to Monza’s media day so much that they tossed me a pass to poke around the paddock yesterday, and paid for travel, lodging and food. Friggin’ delicious Italian food, too. It’s a rough job, I know.]

NASCAR, for better or for worse, goes out of their way to make sure the results on track—as seen by fans—are the results of the race as often as possible. Shuffling cars around in the standings is their nuclear option for when someone’s blatantly cheating, or if there’s a they’re really trying to enforce. The reason? No one really likes hearing race results change hours after the race is over.

Maybe this is the attitude F1 needs to adopt for qualifying. F1's qualifying sessions are usually a lot of fun to watch. The series itself wants people to watch, too. All the brouhaha about last year was rooted in a desire to get more people to tune into qualifying.

Yet I get frustrated when some of my qualify relatively well, but still can’t catch a break because they’ve used too many power unit components already this year.

The power unit is the catch-all term for the internal combustion engine and hybrid system, divided up into six elements that Formula One defines in detail . Each team can use a maximum of four of each element before they start incurring grid penalties.

We’re barely over halfway done with the season and we’re already seeing teams invoke big penalties. The Italian Grand Prix is only two practice sessions into its weekend, yet we’ve got grid penalties for Toro Rosso driver Carlos Sainz Jr. (10), McLaren driver Fernando Alonso (35) and both Red Bull drivers Max Verstappen (15) and Daniel Ricciardo (20). Sainz may get bumped back further after his engine blew in spectacular fashion during Free Practice 2 as well.

All of these penalties already drop their respective cars down into the bottom half of the grid. There were so many that Sky Sports had to specify the order they would be penalized.

And these are on the low side. McLaren driver Stoffel Vandoorne got an insane 65 grid-place penalty at Spa-Francorchamps last weekend. It’s become excessive and absurd.

Granted, these penalties came from a desire to keep costs down by limiting the number of engines teams can use. Anything F1 can do to keep costs more manageable for smaller teams is a good move, especially since we’ve seen several come and go quickly in recent years. However, I can’t imagine allowing a fifth set of power unit components for the year to give struggling teams a better shot at scoring in the points would be too bad.

But that’s only solving part of the problem. Grid penalties change qualifying results and often annoy the fans who watch those sessions, a point which even Formula One’s heads have noted. Formula One Managing Director of Motorsports Ross Brawn told :

I hate the fact that we’re having to affect the racing because of the technical issues. I know you can say if a car breaks down in a race that’s a technical issue and you’ve affected the race, but I think the fans understand that.

For a fan to stomach that his hero is on the back of the grid because he had to change the engine, that’s not great sport.

We’ve got to find a solution to that, either through a different form of penalty or to remove the penalty altogether and just live with the problem that it was trying to fix.

Preach that gospel far and wide, brother, because it’s been my biggest source of irritation with recent F1 races.

So, maybe F1 should find another penalty that doesn’t affect the results so much—at least for the smaller numbers of component swaps, such that teams who are clearly abusing the rules could still have results affected after a certain point.

Something F1 teams would really hate that would happen entirely off the track would be ideal, like making certain components off-limits to development or suspending members of the crew. (The phrase “mandatory ” also came to mind, however, I realized that could be grossly unsanitary.)

Brawn suggested a potential loss of constructors’ championship points, or the loss of allowed “tokens” for power unit changes to Motorsport.com—both of which would get the job done.

I’m sure the same minds who give us cars capable of pulling G-forces that near those of a fighter jet can come up with something creatively onerous that would leave the qualifying results alone. But something’s got to give. I’m tired of tuning into qualifying only to have the results I see play out on track get owned by grid penalties on top of grid penalties.

Luckily, there’s hope now that even F1's higher-ups are as sick of the practice as I am. Do us a solid and change that for next year, please.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Racing
After Delivering 8 Seasons At The Back Of The Grid, Haas F1 Team Dumps Guenther Steiner
After Delivering 8 Seasons At The Back Of The Grid, Haas F1 Team Dumps Guenther Steiner
The partially North Carolina-based squad has determined that after , it needs to mix things up a little. The team’s firebrand has been following an abysmal 2023 season which saw the team score just four points-paying finishes. The team’s , where scored a fourth-place finish, but that season too...
Jun 18, 2025
Listen To In-Car Audio From Race Cars While You Work
Listen To In-Car Audio From Race Cars While You Work
If you follow racing in the U.S., you probably already know about the . Most of the episodes are too much of a distraction to put on as background noise while you work, but a couple of recent entries in his series have been working incredibly well for me....
Jun 18, 2025
Race Team Would Rather Create A Fake AI Woman Rather Than Hire A Real One
Race Team Would Rather Create A Fake AI Woman Rather Than Hire A Real One
In another unsurprising example of motorsport’s inhospitable mindset toward hiring competent women, the Racing team has announced a new partnership with Ava Rose, a literal , who will... engage with fans? Share knowledge about technology? “Navigate the cutting edge of innovation to create positive change” (whatever that means)? I...
Jun 18, 2025
Get Ready To Spend All Your Money On Retro Formula 1 Merch
Get Ready To Spend All Your Money On Retro Formula 1 Merch
Fellow nerds, get ready to open your wallets, because I’ve found what may be the greatest store of all time. With designs from Formula 1 teams like , you’re sure to find something that fits your particular nostalgic niche. I’d like to introduce you to Racing Retro. I first...
Jun 18, 2025
Local Businesses Want Compensation After Allegedly Losing Money During Formula 1 Las Vegas Grand Prix
Local Businesses Want Compensation After Allegedly Losing Money During Formula 1 Las Vegas Grand Prix
If you listen to Formula 1 or local officials from Las Vegas and Clark County, you’d probably think November’s inaugural Las Vegas Grand Prix was a success. Some sources estimated that the city of Las Vegas made over $1 billion in revenue from the event — but there were...
Jun 18, 2025
You've Probably Never Heard Of The Coolest Canadian Car Ever Built
You've Probably Never Heard Of The Coolest Canadian Car Ever Built
Name a car from the early 1960s built by a famed racing driver with curvy, lightweight aluminum bodywork, a big American engine, and a reputation for being unruly and fast as all hell. Your first thought was probably the famed Shelby Cobra, did you know there was a who...
Jun 18, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved