zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Racing
/
Leaked Letter Shows How Bad Formula One's Finance Problem Really Is
Leaked Letter Shows How Bad Formula One's Finance Problem Really Is-May 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:11:48

A to Bernie Ecclestone cosigned by smaller Formula One teams Force India, Sauber and Lotus explains just how lopsided the sport's distribution of commercial revenue is along with other key facts, such as how none of the smaller teams voted to move to the new V6 turbo engine.

The letter calls for an urgent meeting in Abu Dhabi to discuss the situation, which the smaller teams describe as a slippery slope to a grid filled with "Super GP2" and customer cars. Force India deputy team principal Bob Fernley penned the letter to Bernie Ecclestone, chief executive of the Formula One group.

The teams are asking for a more equitable distribution of funding among the teams so that the smaller teams can stay in existence without having to resort to customer cars or a second class of racing.

While the smaller teams typically receive only $52-64 million from Formula One Management per year, those in the F1 Strategy Group—Red Bull, Ferrari, McLaren, Williams and Mercedes—will receive approximately $412 million, as a group. The large teams receive almost half of the $835 million Prize Fund that Formula One Management will allocate to the teams for 2014.

There is in the current team contracts that explains how teams have agreed to supply a third car to a team experiencing financial hardships which has the smallest teams worried. If the smaller teams can no longer afford to participate on their own, they will end up as customers of the larger teams.

Customer cars don't allow for the kind of innovation and technological strategy that people expect out of Formula One, so the smaller teams have every reason to be up in arms about that clause, even if it is one that was meant to help them.

Clearly, Formula One's payout structure is broken. The rich teams keep getting richer, and the smaller teams get the shaft. The richer Strategy Group isn't affected by the cost crisis, so they care less about fixing it. Fernley explains:

Since Austin, Lotus, Sauber and Force India F1 have been in communication with Donald [Mackenzie of CVC Capital Partners, one of the owners of F1] and your good self in order to highlight the critical situation independent constructors in Formula 1 are facing today. From our meetings we noted positively that our concerns were acknowledged and there was a basis for a constructive dialogue. However, after our meeting in Brazil we clearly see the direction of Formula 1 towards customer cars / super GP2. It is equally clear that the Strategy Group has no intention at all to reduce costs.

The letter refers to the group making all of F1's decisions as a "Cartel," further driving home the fact that the small teams feel left out of crucial decision-making processes and are extremely unhappy.

The letter continues:

The shareholder's (sic) focus during the negotiations was on securing the co-operation with big teams in view of the planned IPO; we were effectively given no room for negotiation. Furthermore, the impact of providing various share options to key people and entities may well have clouded their judgement in respect of creating what is effectively a questionable Cartel comprising, the Commercial Rights Holder, Ferrari, Red Bull, Mercedes, McLaren and Williams, controlling both the governance of Formula One and apparently, the distribution of FOM funds.

Whilst the FIA are involved in The Strategy Group, they are impotent to act.

None of the smaller teams on the letter voted for the move to the costly V6 turbo engines, either. While the manufacturers want to use F1 to showcase new technologies, the smaller teams just want a chance to win. Fernley explains in the letter:

70% – 80% of the FOM income has to be allocated to the engine. For us, as engine customers, the engine technology, i.e V6 or V8 turbo-charged or hybrid, is of much less significance, as opposed to engine manufacturers, who are using Formula One as a marketing tool to showcase high-end technology. Unlike manufacturer-owned teams, our core business is Formula One.

Yet, we have no choice but to spend most of our income on the engine, and the remaining 30% is by far not enough to construct, enter and run a team over a twenty race season.

Fernley's letter claims that engine-related costs (such as installation and gearbox design) can total up to $43 million per season. James Allen that figure is closer to $20 million for the lowest-priced power unit alone. That is a significant chunk of an already small payout.

The average budget for a Formula One season is estimated to be $219 million.

The smaller teams are desperate to resolve the inequitable distribution of funds each year. Sure, there should be some incentive to win and place well, but it shouldn't come at the cost of less moneyed and established competitors.

Previously, smaller teams have asked for a limit on the number of developments teams can make per season, rather than an outright budget cap. This is something that Formula One could measure at each grand prix. While I'm not sure this fits in the spirit of Formula One being the pinnacle of motorsport, it's at least a feasible work-around.

I'd still rather see FOM funds be distributed more evenly in light of the additional engine costs that the smaller teams have been forced to incur.

Someone tell Bernie that this isn't "." It's asking for a reasonable long-term solution to F1's finance problem.

F1's endangered three smallest teams want to table new proposals at Abu Dhabi GP aimed at getting a

We've lost the two backmarkers to out-of-control costs. Let's not lose the mid-pack teams. The back- and mid-field teams always have played an important role in developing in new talent, and it would be a shame to see them disappear from the grid.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Racing
EXCLUSIVE: See And Hear Nissan's Front-Engine GT-R Le Mans Car On Track
EXCLUSIVE: See And Hear Nissan's Front-Engine GT-R Le Mans Car On Track
Here's the Le Mans race car that everyone is talking about in the carbon-fiber nude. The had largely been kept out of public view until a group of traveling fans saw it turning laps at Circuit of the Americas . Now we have clearer photos and video of Nissan's wild...
May 9, 2026
Vintage African Rally Footage Makes Everything Better
Vintage African Rally Footage Makes Everything Better
Some of the toughest rallies in the world aren't rally raid style competitions like the , or even in inclement weather, but rather, they're in Africa. Stage road too rough? These guys probably don't even want to hear it. The East African Safari Rally, for example, was dropped from the...
May 9, 2026
Robby Gordon's Suspension Can Lift A Wheel Over A Small Child
Robby Gordon's Suspension Can Lift A Wheel Over A Small Child
Ever feel as if you need more suspension travel? Say, your roads are rough, or you just want to climb stuff? Take a look at the suspension setup on the HST Gordini, the race truck Robby Gordon custom-built for the car category at Dakar. Here's Robby's celebration after the final...
May 9, 2026
The Shortest Chili Bowl Driver Won The World's Biggest Midget Car Race
The Shortest Chili Bowl Driver Won The World's Biggest Midget Car Race
Who is Rico Abreu? Well, he's the winner of the 2015 Chili Bowl Nationals, for one, which is the dirt track race in the world. More importantly, he's a young four-foot, four-inch barrel of awesome who you should get to know now because he's inevitably going to pop up elsewhere...
May 9, 2026
The Gnarliest Crashes And Flips Of The Chili Bowl
The Gnarliest Crashes And Flips Of The Chili Bowl
This year's Chili Bowl Nationals had a record number of flips. Sixty-one flips, to be precise. Didn't have time to watch the whole event? Here's a montage of all of the gnarliest flips from the week leading up to the feature races. Check out how much air these cars get!...
May 9, 2026
The New Ford GT Looks Incredibly Badass In Gulf Livery
The New Ford GT Looks Incredibly Badass In Gulf Livery
Some people say it's time for everyone to stop fawning over retro liveries. Maybe that's true. But when a legendary race car like the is reborn for 2015, it's only natural to wonder what it would look like in classic Gulf Oil colors. Wonder no more! Just as our friends...
May 9, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved