zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Beyond Cars
/
MH17 Was Barely Above Restricted Airspace When It Was Shot Down
MH17 Was Barely Above Restricted Airspace When It Was Shot Down-October 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:14:29

Many people are asking: What was an airliner doing flying over a war zone? This is a valid question considering that many aircraft have been shot down over Ukraine recently and it was known that pro-Russian forces had recently seized advanced SAMs. Technically, MH17 was flying where it was supposed to, which indicates a larger failure.

There was a put out on .

Was flying so close to a exclusion zone that had known anti-aircraft activity an unnecessary risk taken by the pilots or by their carrier? Possibly, but there are other carriers that have also operated over the same airspace regularly in the previous months, and yes, fuel savings is a major factor in route planning, as is weather.

The larger issue may be the failure of the intelligence system, U.S. or otherwise, to notify international aviation authorities in each country and/or region of the fact that and their level training when it comes to operating them and their associated command and control apparatus was totally questionable.

It seems clear that the Ukrainian anti-aircraft missile defense regiment A-1402 was overran and…

In addition to rebels recently getting their hands on SA-11 'Buk' road-mobile SAMs, Russia has amassed a massive anti-air arsenal along its border, and the . Although flight above 25k feet is well outside of the MANPADS threat, it does become a major factor should a flight have to descend below that altitude in an emergency.

Man Portable Air Defense Systems (MANPADS), otherwise known as shoulder fired heat-seeking…

In all reality, so much anti-air warfare was going on over Eastern Ukraine that it should have been off limits, especially considering the FAA ordered flights to not overfly Crimea during the earlier stages of Russia's invasion, of which there was no air war.

To add to the pile of evidence that would support a total restriction of commercial flights in the area, earlier in the week

In horrific news, Malaysia Air flight 17, a Boeing 777 flying from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur,…

with the Ukrainian Government saying it was shot down by a Russian fighter that had crossed over the border. Ukraine's account of a fighter downing the SU-25 may have been inaccurate, as it would justify the fact that a non-MANPAD missile took the jet down. Either way, there was so much evidence that the anti-air threat posture had rapidly advanced over Eastern Ukraine, why didn't the flight restriction change with it?

This puzzling disparity between the hostile realities in the region and its accessibility to commercial traffic is even more so considering that the U.S. is closely monitoring the electronic order of battle (radar and integrated air defense radio emissions) in the region. The U.S. has admitted that they detected the radar emissions of what was most likely a SA-11 "Buk" missile system originating from the western side of the Russian-Ukraine border. American surveillance assets also detected the actual hot infrared plume of the missile's exhaust as it ascended toward its defenseless target, and its fiery aftermath.

The sources of collection for such data when it comes to monitoring for SAM systems coming online and fire control radars "painting" targets can be collected from aircraft such as the RC-135 Rivet Joint, U-2 Dragon Lady, RQ-4 Global Hawk, EP-3 Aeries and other classified stealth aircraft such as the RQ-170 Sentinel or its bigger and more clandestine brother known informally in the press as the RQ-180. Even ships operating off the coast can detect and classify these emissions. Satellites in low earth orbit may also provide some of this information in near real time as well.

As for the detection of the that was most certainly picked up by the and associated satellites. This technology was built as an early warning system aimed at detecting ballistic missile launches during the Cold War and to become a key node in . One of its "off label" uses is rumored to be detection of SAM launches.

As for what happens next, geopolitically it is debatable. Ukraine and pro-Russian and Russian forces all blame one-another, yet it is widely assumed that Russian special forces and intelligence units are operating alongside rebel forces, if not as fighters than as "technical advisors" at the minimum. If Russia provided the expertise on how to successfully employ the SA-11 there will be major repercussions, but that is in no way certain. Ukraine has operated the "buk" and other SAM systems for decades and there is no reason not to believe that active or retired Ukrainian military personnel fighting for the rebels could not have put the commandeered and self-contained SAM system to use.

On the other hand, there are rumors that the . This, along with surely points to deeper Russian involvement, especially considering the notoriety of one of the supposed people speaking on it.

Now, as the shock of losing another Malaysian Air Boeing 777 subsides, the focus will turn towards how this happened, who caused it, and how it could have been prevented. Sadly, like most human-made disasters, it was probably the result of not just one, but a series of systemic failures that cascaded together in a moment in time, resulting in horrible and totally pointless tragedy.

Illustration by Sam Wooley.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Beyond Cars
Jet Skis Are Basically Water Cars Now
Jet Skis Are Basically Water Cars Now
Jet Skis used to be the motorcycle of the water, right? They were small and relatively light and nimble, at least compared to boats, and they could rip away all day, doing high speed water maneuvers. And if you dug too hard into a turn or carried way too...
Oct 24, 2026
Thousands Of Flights Are Being Cancelled Due To Omicron
Thousands Of Flights Are Being Cancelled Due To Omicron
Earlier this week, the CDC after a positive Covid test based on a study that could have been titled, “Delta Airlines said please and c’mon, just look at that face, how do you say no to that.” While airlines, broader response was . Now, it seems it all may...
Oct 24, 2026
It's A BusTrain
It's A BusTrain
A small town in Japan just celebrated the maiden voyage of its first that combines a and a , and comes with little train wheels that hoist its rubber tires into the air so that it can sit onto the tracks and oh, my god this thing is precious!...
Oct 24, 2026
Best Reviews 2021: If The 2022 Honda Grom Doesn't Make You Happy Maybe You Can't Be Happy
Best Reviews 2021: If The 2022 Honda Grom Doesn't Make You Happy Maybe You Can't Be Happy
We drove a lot of cars in 2021, we’re reposting a few of our favorites here. Cheap, efficient, and fun: I can only imagine those were the three things in Honda’s design brief for the original Grom. By those metrics, the Grom was a smash success, delivering miles per gallon...
Oct 24, 2026
Cars Arrive At Port Covered In Salty Ice After Ship Sails Through Bad Weather
Cars Arrive At Port Covered In Salty Ice After Ship Sails Through Bad Weather
recently arrived in Russia with a precious cargo of cars to be delivered to new owners. There was just one problem: much of the ship and its load of cars were encased in frozen seawater. On December 27, Panama-flagged car carrier Sun Rio arrived in Vladivostok, Russia’s port. It departed...
Oct 24, 2026
A Father And Daughter Turned An Old Train Caboose Into A Cozy House
A Father And Daughter Turned An Old Train Caboose Into A Cozy House
A father and daughter have created one cool place to lay your head while giving new life to . In northeast Iowa sits an old SOO Line caboose overlooking a horse pasture. Inside is cozy lodging with all of the amenities of home. On this year, I decided that...
Oct 24, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved