zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Culture
/
Rising Traffic Deaths In The U.S. Are Not From Accidents, But From Car Crashes That Can Be Prevented
Rising Traffic Deaths In The U.S. Are Not From Accidents, But From Car Crashes That Can Be Prevented-October 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:12:10

Image for article titled Rising Traffic Deaths In The U.S. Are Not From Accidents, But From Car Crashes That Can Be Prevented

Traffic deaths in the U.S. are increasing at a rate that population growth cannot account for alone. The spike in traffic deaths has forced the to consider big policy changes that sound empty but may actually help, according to a new book by . Even if goals like “” seem naive, Singer says these policies can make a difference.

Singer spoke to about her book, There Are No Accidents, which argues that in order to address the spike in U.S. traffic deaths, we have to start looking for causes beyond human error and look at the conditions that compound risk. Those conditions, it turns out, are under our control.

The is worth a read, but two points stick out. Namely, that the word “accident” implies inevitability (which is misleading), and that car crashes happen inside the context of layers of risk that stack:

We die by accident because of risk exposure. The layers of risk compound, increasing the likelihood that mistakes aren’t survivable. As our regulatory systems have declined since the Reagan administration, we’ve lost a lot of ability to police how corporations expose us to unsafe conditions. At the same time, economic inequality drives accidental death in a variety of ways.

A good way to think of it is that you’re more at risk to get killed in a car crash if you drive an older car. You’re also more at risk if you live in a place where everyone drives older cars. You’re also more at risk if the roads are in worse repair. Those are three layers of risk, and if you’re only exposed to one of those layers, you’re less likely to die in an accidental death than someone who is exposed to all three. And that’s part of the reason we see such strong correlations between accidental deaths and the economies of local and state populations.

The problem, Singer , also traces to how we think of of crashes as “accidents.” Singer says “accident” has a hint of passivity. Like an accident is something that happened and no one is to blame. The majority of the time someone did mess up, and the risk of that mistake killing someone relates to the conditions of the crash. These are well within the control of policy and to some degree, carmakers, too. Singer on:

“Accidents happen when errors occur under dangerous conditions, but you can create conditions that anticipate errors and make those mistakes less of a life-or-death equation,” she writes. “Or you can focus all your energy on errors, and let the same accidents happen again and again.”

A lot of the time, companies aren’t open to regulation or oversight, and that attitude is what we should push back against, Singer argues.

Imagine if said that developing their automated driving systems and making them safer would cost too much, or end up bankrupting the company. Well then tough shit. If a feature isn’t safe, it’s not a feature; it’s a bug. Singer says tried pulling that move, claiming would shut the company down, and yet Ford is still around today.

Image for article titled Rising Traffic Deaths In The U.S. Are Not From Accidents, But From Car Crashes That Can Be Prevented

Carmakers may try to skirt responsibility (well, except for ) but it’s up to policy changes enacted by people to not let the car companies get away with it.

I can get onboard with Singer’s argument because the idea of risk being layered sounds more complete than that of population growth. If this alone explained the rise in traffic deaths, then there should be a linear progression to that increase. Bloomberg traffic deaths have grown at three times the rate of U.S. population growth. There’s more at work here.

Image for article titled Rising Traffic Deaths In The U.S. Are Not From Accidents, But From Car Crashes That Can Be Prevented

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Culture
Aston Martin's Big Lagonda Revival May Have Reached A Dead End
Aston Martin's Big Lagonda Revival May Have Reached A Dead End
Aston Martin was to enter its electric era with a flagship under the Lagonda brand next year. That vehicle is no longer part of the company’s plans, based on recent comments made by executive chairman Lawrence Stroll in an interview with the . In fact, the full revival of...
Oct 21, 2026
Alleged Dirtbag Andrew Cuomo Is Also Just The Blandest Boomer Car Guy
Alleged Dirtbag Andrew Cuomo Is Also Just The Blandest Boomer Car Guy
Rebecca Traister at New York magazine of the “toxic workplace” that is the office of New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. I urge you to read it in full! For our purposes here, however, I will highlight one passage in particular. The passage comes about a quarter of the way...
Oct 21, 2026
Let's All Say Farewell To The Honda S660, Even Though We Never Said Hello
Let's All Say Farewell To The Honda S660, Even Though We Never Said Hello
We didn’t deserve the midengine Honda S660 kei convertible, which is probably one of the reasons we never got it. It was the successor — I’m not even going to preface that with “spiritual” — to the of the ’90s, which also didn’t come to the U.S. The S660...
Oct 21, 2026
Michigan Man With A Suspended License Appears In Virtual Traffic Court From Where Else, The Driver Seat
Michigan Man With A Suspended License Appears In Virtual Traffic Court From Where Else, The Driver Seat
delivers solid absurdity thanks to the silly ways that lawyers and defendants make their appearances through Zoom. A Michigan man is a strong contender for one of the worst virtual traffic court appearances as he showed up to court for his suspended license from the driver seat. The virtual...
Oct 21, 2026
Here's How Fans Are Resurrecting Beloved Cars From Retro Games In Modern Racing Sims
Here's How Fans Are Resurrecting Beloved Cars From Retro Games In Modern Racing Sims
The Assoluto Bisonte seen above weighed about 2,750 pounds in its 1999 race trim and derived its power from a mid-mounted pushrod V8 of 3 liters. The four different teams that ran it during the Real Racing Roots campaign that year quoted different power figures, though the most well-known...
Oct 21, 2026
Bollinger Says It'll Start Deliveries In 2022
Bollinger Says It'll Start Deliveries In 2022
Bollinger, the electric truck startup , is getting closer and closer to becoming more than “isn’t bad,” in that it’s getting closer and closer to becoming more real. Its CEO said Friday that deliveries of its trucks would start next year. Bollinger is planning the B1, which is the...
Oct 21, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved